AdventAI

THE FAITH CURE.

By A. Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 23., June 8, 1886

BY A. SMITH.

There is a system of healing the sick, called “Christian science,” or “metaphysical healing,” that is just now becoming quite popular; and, robed in a religious garb, as it is, many will doubtless be deceived by it unless they are able to meet it by an appeal to the only reliable detector of error—the Bible.

Rev. Mrs. M. B. G. Eddy, of Boston, Mass., claims to have originated the so-called system of metaphysical healing, in 1866. Mrs. Eddy is president of the Massachusetts Metaphysical College, where, at an enormous tuition fee, instruction in the art is given to many pupils; and about sixty practitioners, in various parts of the United States, are reported in the April number, present year, of the Christian Science, the official organ of the body. If published testimonials and verbal reports of those who have been treated on this principle are to be relied upon, marvels of healing have been wrought that are sure to bring the system into general public favor, and with it a belief in the dangerous religious tenets of the author.

In “Science and Health” (19th edition), p. 470, a book published by Mrs. Eddy, in the chapter on Genesis, the author says: “The Scriptures are very sacred to me. I aim only to have them understood spiritually.”

This professed love of the Scriptures is no proof in itself that the author’s religious views are correct. No doubt even Satan himself would be pleased with the Bible if its plain denunciations of his wickedness could be so sweetened and doctored as to hide his true character.

On Gen. 1, Mrs. E. says, in elucidation of her spiritualization of the Bible, that the terms earth and water “represent spiritual ideas.” On Gen. 2: 15, she says, “Eden is man’s body.” Under “Glossary,” she thus defines, “Angels. God’s thoughts; spiritual institutions,” etc.; “Baptism. Purification by spirit; being submerged in Truth,” etc.; “River. Channel of thought.”

Let us test her position: “There cometh a woman of Samaria to draw spiritual ideas.” John 4: 7. “And John also was submerging in Truth in Enon near to Salim, because there was much spiritual ideas there.” John 3: 23. “And the Lord God planted a garden eastward in man’s body, and there he put the Eden whom he had formed.” Gen. 2: 8. “And were all submerged in Truth of him in the channel of thought of Jordan, confessing their sins.” Mark 1: 5.

Mrs. E. defines, “Death. An illusion; for there is no death. Man is incapable of sin, sickness, and death. Man cannot depart from holiness. . . . The mortality of man is a myth; for man is immortal.”

Will the reader please examine Rom. 3: 23 and 5: 12; Job 4: 17 and 14: 10.

Mrs. E. defines, “Devil. A lie; error; neither a person nor a principle.”

No doubt the Devil would dance with glee over the idea that he does not exist, could it come to be generally believed. “Then went the lies out of the Garden of Eden, and entered into the swine.” Luke 8: 33.

The author defines “atonement” thus: “Atonement. The teachings, demonstrations, and sufferings of the man Jesus. . . There is a future state of probation and progress.”

A writer in the Christian Science says, “The glorious truth of the power of God, or Principle, as taught and demonstrated by that blessed teacher Mrs. Eddy, of Boston; and again we behold the power of Truth in casting out evil spirits, healing the sick, and reforming the sinner. May we not, then, believe this to be the second coming of Christ—Truth; and that Truth shall continue to advance, till all shall know him, from the least to the greatest?”

On Luke 23: 43, Mrs. Eddy says: “With death, a paradisaical rest from physical agony would come to the criminal, but the paradise of spirit would come to Jesus, in a higher sense of life and power. The thief died and disappeared, but Christ Jesus lived and reappeared. He was too good to die.”—Christian Science, April number, p. 11.

For a refutation of the above, see Rev. 1: 18; Rom. 5: 6; 14: 9.

It will be noticed that Mrs. Eddy and her colleagues teach that Christ did not die for our sins, that there will be a future state of probation, and that Jesus has already come the second time. But what said Jesus himself on this question?—“For there shall arise false Christs, and false prophets, and shall show great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect. Behold, I have told you before. Wherefore if they shall say unto you, Behold, he is in the desert; go not forth: behold, he is in the secret chambers; believe it not. For as the lightning cometh out of the east, and shineth even unto the west; so shall also the coming of the Son of man be.” Matt. 24: 24–27.

Concerning God the Father Mrs. E. says: “Mind, not matter, is the creator. The divine Principle, not person, is the father and mother of man and the universe.”

That God the Father is a person, see Heb. 1: 1–3; John 16: 28, 29, etc.

On Gen. 2: 2, Mrs. Eddy waxes eloquently mystical, as follows: “Unfathomable mind has now expressed itself, in all hight, depth, breadth, might, majesty, and glory. . . The numerals of infinity, called seven days, can never be reached according to the calendar of time. We can understand these days, only as we lay aside finite calculations, accept the infinite calculus, and pause, in expressive silence, to muse on the divine wonders.”

Unfortunately Mrs. E. has not elucidated the subject of the “infinite calculus” sufficiently for our obtuse minds to grasp the meaning of the term days, other than we have been taught from infancy to believe—periods of twenty-four hours each, divided into two grand divisions of darkness and light. No doubt the subject is elaborately treated upon in certain works to which Paul refers in 1 Tim. 6: 20. Concerning the “little book” of Rev. 10: 2, a writer in the Christian Science says: “‘Science and Health’ [the work published by Rev. Mrs. Eddy] is this book, sweet to the spiritual man, but bitter to the material man.” On the term “little book,” I transcribe the following from “Thoughts on the Revelation”:—“‘He had in his hand a little book open.’ There is a necessary inference to be drawn from this language, which is that this book was at some time closed up. We read in Daniel of a book which was closed up, and sealed to a certain time: ‘But thou, O Daniel, shut up the words, and seal the book, even to the time of the end; for many shall run to and fro, and knowledge shall be increased.’ Daniel 12: 4. Since this book was closed up only till the time of the end, it follows that at the time of the end the book would be opened; and as its closing was mentioned in prophecy, it would be but reasonable to expect that in the predictions of events to take place at the time of the end, the opening of this book would also be mentioned. There is no book spoken of as closed up and sealed except the book of Daniel’s prophecy; and there is no account of the opening of that book, unless it be here in the tenth of Revelation.”

Using Mrs. Eddy’s definitions of terms, the passage in Rev. 10: 2 would read: “And a spiritual institution had in his hand a little book open; and God’s thoughts set his right foot upon the sea, and his left foot on the spiritual idea.”

Reader, choose for yourself between “Science and Health” and the Bible—one, the text-book of the faith-cure system; the other, the word of God.

Speaking of one Carter, who came to embrace faith healing, the journal says: “Although he has a scientific turn of thought, his reverence for God’s word, and his religious enthusiasm, have prevented his otherwise acute judgment from being on the alert to detect error.”

So it appears that reverence for the Bible is detrimental to a perception of error, and yet that people profess to greatly love to read it, and to delight in prayer, but so spiritualize both that the Scriptures lose their force on important vital questions. That there were to be wonders and miracles wrought in the last days we believe the Bible plainly teaches; and of a character, too, so exactly like the genuine work of the Spirit of God, as to come near deceiving the very elect. See Rev. 13: 13, 14; Matt. 24: 24.

On “prayer,” Mrs. Eddy says: “The habit of pleading with the divine Mind, as one pleads with a human being, perpetuates the belief in God as humanly circumscribed,—an error which impedes spiritual growth.”—Science and Health, p. 483. Mrs. E. clinches her system of faith in the following terms: “A simple statement of Christian science, if demonstrated by healing, contains the proof of all that I have said of it. If one of my statements is true, every one must be true; for I never depart from my principle and rule.”—Id. p. 469.

By the same rule, if one of her statements is proved to be wrong, all are wrong, and the whole system is a counterfeit, and unworthy the confidence of Christian people.

“But do you not believe,” says one, “that God can, and does now, in answer to prayer, heal the sick?”—Yes, certainly; and yet it is evident that ever since the fall of man the work of the Spirit of God has been counterfeited; and doubtless it is especially so in these last days. We have seen from their own writings that the people who advocate and practice metaphysical healing, deny the death of Christ; represent God as a principle; claim a future state of probation; declare that the second coming of Christ has taken place, and many other absurdities contrary to plain declarations of the Bible. Although there may be modifications of the general belief, yet the whole body must be leavened with error fatal to the vitality of true religion. Do the advocates of the “faith cure” follow the Bible rule for healing the sick? See James 5: 14, 15. Let the reader observe.

“But,” says one, “could I not be healed by them and not indorse their religious views?” We answer, Leave their method of curing disease entirely alone. If the Lord is willing to heal you of infirmity while you walk in obedience to his will, accept it gratefully; but if not, you would better suffer on a little longer here, and have immortality in the near future.

The prince of the power of the air can afflict the bodies of men and women as he did Job’s and many others, and whom he afflicts he can heal. It is evident that this so-called faith cure is a modified or Christianized form of Spiritualism, all the more dangerous because of its hiding its real character. The Bible bears a plain testimony against going after such things; and if God’s people will but “prove all things” by the Bible, there will be little danger of their going astray.