THE EVER-RECURRING QUESTION.
By E. W. Farnsworth
BY ELD. E. W. FARNSWORTH. NOTHING is more interesting to one who closely watches the current of passing events, than to note how quickly new ideas germinate and take shape; how swiftly old theories are dropped, and new ones grasped and acted upon. When the writer first began to preach, about ten years ago, almost every one believed that Christ changed the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day, and that there was abundant testimony in the Bible to prove it. But in this respect, times have changed greatly since then. The men now are scarce who will so far hazard their reputation as scholars and critics as to try to maintain that there is any authority in the New Testament for the observance of Sunday. They generally admit that there is none, and try to build their argument for the Sunday rest purely on man’s spiritual and physical needs. This idea is most clearly illustrated by a discourse preached by Charles H. Parkhurst, D. D., at Madison Square Presbyterian church, New York, January 24, 1886, and published in the Christian Union of May 20. While there are many things in the discourse which we do not and cannot indorse, yet the confessions in reference to the foundations for Sunday-keeping are so sweeping as to be decidedly refreshing. He says:— “This gives us an opportunity to dwell for a few minutes on some matters relating to Sunday and Sunday-keeping; and this, not so much because we have anything new to say about it, as because we cannot quite afford, under all the circumstances of the times, to say nothing about it.” “The case is a difficult one to state justly. That is one reason why the pulpit has so little to say concerning it, and one reason why so much that is written upon it misses its mark. It is a hard mark to hit. One reason of this is that the target is obscure; and another, that so many arrows are flying through the air at all angles, that it becomes difficult to gain a clear, sure, and steady aim. It is certainly wise to confess the difficulties. We have no pet theory to push. A few things relative to it seem very clear; the residue, more or less hazy. Enough is evident to meet our practical necessities, even if some of our philosophical ambitions do have to go unsatisfied.” “If Christ himself had made some definite utterance in regard to observing holy time, matters would be simplified. Opportunities occurred frequently when he might have said something very definite, and when that was exactly what the people wanted him to say; but he dealt with the matter only generally. Paul, likewise, handles the question in much the same way. The apostolic churches evidently observed religiously the first day of every seven; but we never hear Paul telling them to, and never discover him sketching any plan of Sunday observance. No one who wants an itemized scheme of Sunday-keeping can obtain any such thing, either from Paul or the Lord. No one has yet made a careful study of the New Testament if he has not discovered, in regard to a number of matters, clear evidences of an intentioned indefiniteness.” “There is no end to the number of undigested discourses that have gone to pieces from having their foundation knocked out from underneath them. And it hurts; it impairs confidence in preaching. Whether it is a structure of wood, brick, or truth that we are putting up, our first care needs to be, not to carry our walls outside of a foundation that we are not sure of.” “The Christian Sabbath, in form and spirit both, is quite another day from that contemplated in the fourth commandment. The Christian Sabbath is distinctly commemorative only of Christ’s rising; the Jewish Sabbath is distinctly commemorative only of God’s resting. The Christian Sabbath comes the first day of the week; the Jewish, the seventh. I know it has been repeatedly said that all that is meant and intended is that a seventh of time should be kept holy. That is not all that it means and intends. Something more than the proportion of time is aimed at. We do not keep the fourth commandment by hallowing one day in seven, unless it is the seventh day that we hallow. The seventh day is specified, and the reason for specifying it is specified; and every child who intelligently knows the commandment, can tell why it is that it was the seventh rather than the sixth day that was ordained and consecrated to holy uses.” “And as Christian teachers and preachers, let me say, we want to caution ourselves against even seeming to play fast and loose with facts to the end of establishing a doctrinal point, no matter how good the point. Whenever in matters of religion we find it expedient to work the logical faculty, the work needs to be done along logical lines as sharp and rigid as though we were demonstrating a proposition in Euclid. The end does not sanctify the means, and an orthodox conclusion will not save from disrepute the lame logic that is used in reaching it. In all such matters, we need to remember that a broken argument will not be kept from limping by being braced with the splints of pious intention. There is not sufficient premise in the fourth commandment to yield the Christian Sabbath as its conclusion.” What sweeping confessions! and yet, how true! He confesses frankly that a man does not keep the fourth commandment by keeping Sunday. Let none say hereafter that they keep the commandments when they keep the first day of the week. How evident it is that other ministers have found the Sunday question “a difficult case to state;” and the reason evidently is, that “the pulpit has so little to say about it,” and in trying to state it, they “miss the mark.” How many of them in their very souls have felt that it was a “hard mark to hit”! He confesses the “target” (Sunday-Sabbath in the New Testament) “is obscure.” Obscure, indeed! no man ever had a magnifying glass powerful enough to reveal even the faintest outline of its disk. “The residue more or less hazy.” Hazy! from the stand-point of a Sunday observer, Egyptian darkness is comparatively light. And who could be expected to “hit a mark” when everything is so “obscure” and “hazy”? Can a man shoot straight when all is total darkness around him? This explains the cause of the confusion in the ranks of Sunday observers. But the Bible says: “For the commandment is a lamp; and the law is light.” Prov. 6:23. There is no “obscurity” or “haze” there. It is only when men put on theological, foggy spectacles, that things become obscure.