A SAD MISTAKE SOMEWHERE

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 31, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 35.

Read the full edition

“A SAD MISTAKE SOMEWHERE.”

It is generally understood among observers of the seventh-day Sabbath, that the many leading men who, as vice-presidents and otherwise, stand at the head of the National Reform movement, are not in the dark as to what such a movement designs, or what must be its ultimate result. The evidence is far more conclusive that, with a full understanding of its nature themselves, they are concealing its real design from the people at large, more effectually to guard against the possibility of failure. It appears, however, from the following, that this is not universally true; that there are some, even among the vice-presidents of this association, to whom the idea of religious persecution as a possible outcome of the National Reform movement, is altogether new and strange, and who would be disposed to treat observers of the seventh day with just consideration. Such an one is the editor of the Christian Cynosure, a Chicago paper, who, referring to a sermon delivered by Eld. R. M. Kilgore during the recent tent meetings in that city, in which he alluded to the National Reform movement and the Sabbath persecutions, spoke as follows, under the heading quoted above:—
“Eld. R. M. Kilgore (Seventh-day Baptist [Adventist]) is thus reported in the Inter Ocean, July 19: ‘What is the significance of the National Reform movement which is agitating our country from center to circumference? What is the aim of this great party?—It is to unite church and State. It is to change our Constitution so as to restrict the rights of conscience.’ And further on: ‘Already persecution has broken out in Arkansas, Tennessee, and Pennsylvania, and those who worship God according to the teachings of God’s word are suffering under this [Sabbath] law.’”
“The president of the National Reform Association is Felix R. Brunot, understood to be an Episcopalian. There are some one hundred vice-presidents, more or less, of whom the editor of the Cynosure is one. Bishop Huntington is, and the late Bishop Simpson of the Methodist Episcopal Church was, another; and one hundred men could not be selected in the United States to whom the idea of ‘church and State,’ the coercing of conscience by the civil law, would be more abhorrent than to the list of vice-presidents which have for years been published in the organ of that body which seeks a recognition of God as the author of civil government. And if there are Seventh-day Baptists now in jail, or fined, because, having kept Saturday as their Sabbath, they have refused to keep Sunday also, their names and the jails where they are confined should be published at once.”
“The American people have for years gone the length of tolerating Mormon Danites and polygamists, who practice polygamy and assassination, and called that religion; and will they punish, by fine and imprisonment, civil, orderly Christians, who only differ from them as to the hours of Sabbath rest? Nothing could be more abhorrent to our Constitution than such persecution.”
To this Eld. Kilgore prepared and forwarded the following reply, setting forth the facts of the persecutions and arrests in Arkansas, in which our readers will no doubt be interested:—
“We are Seventh-day Adventists, and not Baptists. As I am now on the ground where our brethren are feeling the effects of the bitter spirit of persecution, I am glad to give you and your readers the desired information.”
“Two years ago a church of S. D. Adventists was raised up in this place (Springdale, Ark.). Last fall they erected a house of worship. For painting, one Sunday, on the rear of the house, unseen from the road, J. W. Scoles was indicted by the grand jury at Fayetteville, Washington Co., Ark., tried, convicted, and fined by the circuit court. An appeal was taken, and the case is now pending the action of the supreme court of the State. James Poole, of the same county, a conscientious Sabbath-keeper, for pulling weeds in his garden on Sunday morning was indicted by the grand jury, and fined by the same court. William Martin was indicted by the grand jury for sowing oats, and was tried before the circuit court; but the jury disagreed. J. M. Davis was indicted by the grand jury for ‘harrowing oats on the Christian Sabbath, or Sunday,’ and tried before the circuit court. Failing to sustain the charge, the court secured a man who gave oath that he saw Mr. Davis hauling wood on Sunday; and without even an indictment for said offense, the court fined him, and taxed him the costs. F. N. Elmore, for three minutes’ labor on Sunday, was indicted, convicted, and fined in the circuit court of this county. The second arrest of J. A. Armstrong, of Springdale, was effected July 9, for digging potatoes on Sunday, for the table. In four hours after his arrest he was on his way to jail at Fayetteville, where he was kept five days, to commute the fine imposed upon him, which he refused to pay, thus refusing to honor an unjust law and a partial administration, which oppressed the conscientious observers of the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, while others who observed neither day conscientiously were permitted to go unmolested.”
“The railroad cars could rumble, and carry their heavy burdens, and the loud noise of the locomotive could be heard more than once every Sunday, and yet go unrebuked. The factory could continue its vocation, and keep its hired servants at work every Sunday; the hotels could send their runners to each train, soliciting patronage, and collecting fees for labor performed on Sunday, without a word of censure from the authorities. Other citizens could drive their hogs to market; livery teams could be hired to pleasure seekers, and money could be exchanged for such service; and no one was disturbed enough to take cognizance of the matter and report it to the grand jury. And when the jury was told of these breaches of the law by a Sabbath-keeper who was summoned to testify against a brother, no notice was taken of them, while the brother was arrested and fined for quietly wielding a paint brush, after he had, the day before, conscientiously observed the Sabbath according to the command of God.”
“Allen Meek, of Star of the West, Pike Co., was indicted by the grand jury for planting potatoes on Sunday morning, on the testimony forced from a friend who had come to visit him, and with whom he spent the remainder of that Sunday. While the case was pending in the court, he was cited to appear on Monday morning twenty-five miles distant. The road being rough, he was compelled to repair his wagon on Sunday. He was again indicted, and fined for that offense, on the testimony of a man who came to see him on business. The man of business on Sunday could cause the arrest of a Sabbath-keeper, and he go free. Others in the same county, with whom I am personally acquainted, and whose names I could give, have also been arrested and fined in the same manner; but this is enough.”
“Any one can see that it is not because the Sunday law is broken, or that these good and conscientious Sabbath-keepers make more noise or disturbance than others; but the strong arm of the law is the best argument that can be wielded against their faith and practice. However ‘abhorrent to our Constitution such persecution’ may appear to the editor of the Cynosure, we are now realizing its effects.”