Under the heading “The Seventh Day,” the Christian Oracle (Disciple), in its issue of June 17, 1886, published the following:—
“The commandment of God directs the keeping of the seventh-day Sabbath. Some Christians regard themselves “at liberty to not keep it.” The word of God likewise directs the keeping of the commandment which says, “Thou shalt not commit adultery;” the Mormons regard themselves at liberty not to keep it. The word of God directs the keeping of the second commandment; the Catholics regard themselves at liberty not to keep it. The word of God directs the keeping of the third commandment; Colonel Ingersoll and his kind regard themselves at liberty not to keep it. Now upon what principle can these “Christians” convince those “saints,” and Catholics, and atheists of sin? We should like to see some one frame an argument that would show that they are wrong, that would not equally condemn himself, and all those who, with him, “regard themselves at liberty not to keep the seventh-day Sabbath.”—Advent Times.
“This challenge has been thrown out several times in the camp-meeting, and is regarded as a strong point. It is very easily met. Jesus gave a commission to his apostles to teach all things he had commanded to his disciples. Those apostles carried out that commission, and taught Christians all things they were to observe. A Christian does not commit adultery, because the apostles expressly condemned it twelve times in the New Testament.
“Christians do not commit idolatry, because the apostles expressly commanded them not to do so. See 1 John 5:21, and four other places.
“Christians do not take the name of the Lord in vain, because the apostles expressly commanded them not to do so. See James 5:12, and different places four times.
“Christians do not keep the seventh day as a Sabbath, because the apostles never commanded them to do it, nor condemned them for not doing it. If an apostle of Jesus ever taught, or it can be shown that they ever required, Christians to keep the seventh day as a Sabbath, or condemned them for not doing it, we will keep it.
“When the apostles of Jesus condemned adultery twelve times, profanity six times, and idolatry five times, and Sabbath-breaking not once, it seems to us marvelous that such a proposition as that above should be made.”
The effort which some make to limit everything to the teaching of the apostles, claiming that we should believe and practice only what they have expressly re-enacted, reminds one of the anecdote of the young skeptic and the Quaker. The young man declared that nothing could be known that was not recognized by the senses; that he would not believe that anything existed that he could not see. The Quaker contemplated him awhile with mingled curiosity and amusement, and then said: “Young man, did thee ever see thy brains?”—“No.” “Does thee believe thee has any?”
“The apostles,” says our contemporary, “taught Christians all things they were to observe.” Do you observe Sunday?—Yes. Did the apostles teach you to do so?—Oh—well—er—. The editor should have extended his list of practices and reasons therefor considerably further. Thus—.
“We Christians do not make unto ourselves any graven images, because the apostles have—well—because—they have said nothing about graven images.”
“We Christians hold nothing to be idolatry but covetousness, because the apostles have given us no other definition of what idolatry is.”
“We Christians keep the first day of the week because the apostles have expressly—well—oh—haven’t said anything about it, ‘never commanded us to keep it, nor condemned us for not keeping it.’”
“We Christians do not believe the Romans sinned by violating any and all of the ten commandments from the crucifixion of Christ till A. D. 60; for we have no evidence that the apostle got around before that time to write to them and let them know what their obligations were.”
“We do not keep the seventh day, because Christ spoke of some law, already in existence when he came into the world, not a jot or tittle of which was to pass away so long as the heavens and the earth should endure (Matt. 5:17-20); and the seventh-day Sabbath was a part of that law; but nevertheless we believe that that law all passed away, and Christ gave a new law privately to his disciples, to be made known by them as best they could as the requirements of God upon men.”
“Christians believe they are to worship God and serve him alone, because Christ told the Devil so off in the wilderness privately, three years and a half before the same law in existence on that subject was abolished.” Matt. 4:10.
And so the list of absurdities might be extended to almost any length. But it is said that the apostles have given us an example of keeping the first day of the week. A greater hallucination never existed. But granting all that is claimed for Sunday in the New Testament, even then, as compared with the seventh day, the evidence in favor of the latter, both in the recognition and practice of the apostles, is more than ten to one.
It is indeed marvelous that any one should fall a victim to the idea that God commissioned the apostles to be his law-givers to the world. There is one law-giver, says the apostle James (4:12), and one mediator, Paul adds, between God and men, the man Christ Jesus. 1 Tim. 2:5. The apostles, to be sure, went forth teaching as Christ had instructed them; but they based their teaching on obligations already existing, which Christ recognized, and the perpetuity of which he plainly taught.
We worship God as supreme, refrain from making and worshiping images, hallow God’s name, keep his Sabbath, and maintain the relations with our fellow-men enjoined in the decalogue, because these obligations have existed from the beginning in the very nature of things; because they have never changed nor ceased to exist; because Christ taught them; and because God will not judge the world at last by a fluctuating and contradictory standard. These reasons cannot be shaken; and no better for any moral duty could be found. Nor would there be any difficulty in persuading all men to the same view; indeed, no other would probably ever have been held, were it not for the wrong position on the Sabbath question into which they have been seduced by the great apostasy.