AdventAI

THE SUNDAY QUESTION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 28., July 13, 1886

From the St. Louis Republican of July 4, 1886, we learn that the columns of that paper had been opened for a limited discussion of the Sunday question, which had called out some interesting correspondence. Among the entertaining points made in the number before us, a Catholic priest, D. S. Phelan, tells Protestants some pretty plain truth about the Sunday institution, and gives them a lively rally because they do not observe the Friday fast, which rests on the same authority. He opens by saying that Sunday is—

“A MATTER OF POSITIVE LAW.

“I have been asked my views on the question of Sunday observance. I have no views; it is a matter of positive law. Dogmas of faith and canons of discipline are grave and stubborn things; views are trifles, light as air. The Sunday is an institution of the Church. The attempt to identify it with the Jewish Sabbath, or to make it heir to its rites and ceremonies, is futile and absurd. The ceremonial law of Moses is abrogated—buried in the same grave with the synagogue. The Lord’s day, in its specific form, is the creation of the Church, although the obligation to sanctify one day in the week would seem to be of divine origin. When the Church set apart the first day of the week for public worship, she enacted that all her children who reached the years of discretion should first hear mass, and secondly abstain from servile work on that day. This is positive law, and any man’s views contrary to this enactment are treasonable. The mass is the one great sacrifice of the new law, and all the faithful are obliged to assist at it on the Lord’s day. Sunday is likewise a day of rest—made so by the Church’s enactment. She says we may not do any work on that day which is of a servile or ordinary wage-earning character.

“But how about games or amusements on the Lord’s day? ‘What saith the law?’ The Church does not condemn them, although she encourages the faithful to works of piety and prayer. She knows the world too well to impose a burden on men they cannot bear. She is satisfied with what is essential, while counseling what is of supererogation. It would be well for all Christians to spend the whole of Sunday in church; but the Church obliges them to be there only about one hour.

“Why do our separated brethren lay so much stress in observing this Sunday ordinance of the Catholic Church? They are more Catholic than the Catholic Church. But they are Catholic only on Sunday. On Friday they are pagans. Why do they eat meat on the latter day? The Church, who presented the method of Sunday observance, forbids the use of flesh meat on Friday. Why, too, do they not observe the laws of the Lenten season? They emanate from the same authority which fixed the time and method of the weekly public worship. The Pharisees were in the habit of higgling about trifles, while they neglected the weightier things of the Mosaic law. Our separated brethren are in the same predicament. They take the Sunday from the Church, and make it the scarecrow of Christendom, while they throw away the Friday abstinence and the Lenten fast, not to speak of the annual confession and communion.”