The Scriptures make it plain that when the Lord returns he is to come with power and great glory, his enemies are to be subdued, and his kingdom established over all the earth. But what is the teaching of Scripture as to the nature of this kingdom, and what the method of its coming? Is this kingdom the church? and is its establishment the same thing as the spread of the gospel through the agency of the church until it fills the earth? Those who so understand God's word hold that there is to be no literal kingdom in the outward, visible sense, but an invisible, spiritual sovereignty set up in men's hearts through belief in the truth, and this becomes at last universal by the acceptance of Christ and his salvation by all men. The question before us is, Do the Scriptures so teach, making the kingdom and the church identical?
THE WORDS NOT INTERCHANGEABLE.
If they do, then obviously the Scripture terms which set forth the kingdom and the church, should be interchangeable, and we may substitute one word for the other and get the same sense. Let us try a few passages and see. Matt. 3: 2: “Repent ye; for the church is at hand.” Chap. 6: 10: “Thy church come.” Verse 33: “Seek ye first the church of God and his righteousness.” Chap. 7: 21: “Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the church, but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.” Chap. 8: 11: “And I say unto you, That many shall come from the east and west, and shall sit down with Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, in the church.” Matt. 25: 34: “Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the church prepared for you from the foundation of the world.” Luke 19: 12, 15: “A certain nobleman went into a far country to receive for himself a church. . . . And it came to pass, that when he was returned, having received the church.” Luke 22: 29: “And I appoint unto you a church, as my Father hath appointed unto me.” Mark 11: 10: “Blessed be the church of our father David, that cometh in the name of the Lord.” Matt. 26: 29: “But I say unto you, I will not drink henceforth of this fruit of the vine, until that day when I drink it new with you in my Father's church.” Acts 1: 6: “Wilt thou at this time restore again the church to Israel?” 1 Cor. 15: 50: “Now this I say, brethren, That flesh and blood cannot inherit the church of God.”
It must be apparent to all that any attempt to read Scripture in this way is to read into it that which was not in the minds of the writers, and in some passages is to make it squarely contradictory to what is elsewhere plainly taught. And the difficulty is only increased if the word kingdom be substituted for church. Matt. 18: 17: “And if he shall neglect to hear them [the two witnesses], tell it unto the kingdom; but if he neglect to hear the kingdom, let him be unto thee, as a heathen man and a publican.” Acts 12: 5: “Prayer was made without ceasing, of the kingdom unto God for him.” Acts 14: 23: “When they had ordained elders in every kingdom.” Chap. 18: 22: “When he had . . . gone up and saluted the kingdom.” Eph. 5: 25: “Husbands, love your wives, even as Christ also loved the kingdom, and gave himself for it, that he might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the word.”
Such a substitution makes nonsense of the word of God. The quick and sure inference is, that these two words were never meant to be taken as synonymous, but to stand for two things widely different in their nature from each other.
SCRIPTURE STATEMENTS ANALYZED.
And this appears the moment we begin to analyze these Scripture statements. Luke 12: 32: “Fear not, little flock; for it is your Father's good pleasure to give you the kingdom.” But this little flock already constituted the church. How, then, could they have appointed or given to them that which they already were—on the supposition that church and kingdom are one and the same? So of the nobleman who went into a far country to receive a kingdom, recorded in Luke 19. The nobleman is unquestionably the Lord Jesus Christ. But if the church be the kingdom, how can he go away from his servants, who constitute the church, to receive it? And how harmonize such a receiving of it and returning with it, and then calling to account those servants who compose the church or kingdom? And so also 2 Peter 1: 11: “For so an entrance shall be ministered unto you abundantly into the everlasting kingdom of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.” This is the reward promised to those believers who “give diligence to make their calling and election sure.” It is clearly something to be enjoyed hereafter. But if church and kingdom are one, they have already obtained entrance and been in possession and enjoyment of its bestowals and satisfactions. So of manifold other passages. Any attempt to read them, obliterating the distinction between the words “church” and “kingdom,” will inevitably involve confusion, and make God's word darkness instead of light.
CHURCH AND KINGDOM DIFFERENTLY CONCEIVED OF.
Again, every careful reader of Scripture cannot fail to note certain forms of conceiving of the church and the kingdom, and certain methods of speaking of them which emphasize as strongly as any positive statements the difference between the two. The apostles plant or organize churches but not kingdoms. They ordain elders, but never anoint kings. The church is a growth, the kingdom a revelation. The church is a body, a building, a community; the kingdom is a sovereignty, a government with a throne and a monarch, and the proper accompaniments of majesty. Men share in establishing a church, have to do with its order and management. So they are associated with the growth of the church, aid in its extension, determine its purity and power. But the kingdom is altogether of God. It is a stone cut out of the mountain without hands. God alone originates it, rules it, brings it to its disclosure and triumph. Men may work and pray for and hasten its coming—that is God's appointed way for its revelation; but they never enlarge it, nor shape it, nor empower it. They simply prepare the way for it to be manifested. The church is local and limited, the kingdom world-wide and universal. The church is now visible, active, potent; the kingdom is now invisible, its principles working secretly in men's hearts, but in the day of its coming it will be outward, visible, glorious. In the church, Christ reigns by his Spirit in the heart: in the kingdom, he reigns personally, visibly, upon a throne. We look for the gradual completion and transformation and exaltation of the church; we look for the sudden coming or manifestation of the kingdom, perfect, resplendent, everlasting. In the church, believers are now associated with their Lord as his witnesses, stewards, friends, joint heirs; in the kingdom, they are to be associated with him as sharers of his blessedness, royalty, glory. Deut. 7; Matt. 24: 31–51; Luke 1: 32; 19: 11–17; Rev. 3: 21; 19, are a few of the passages which teach this.
OBJECTIONS CONSIDERED.
Quite likely there will come to mind certain Scripture testimonies that do not seem to accord with this view. The parable of the mustard seed and of the leaven, such sayings as “My kingdom is not of this world,” “The kingdom of heaven is within you,” “The kingdom of God is not meat and drink, but righteousness, and peace, and joy in the Holy Ghost,” and “The kingdom cometh not with observation,” are of this character. Whatever the explanation of them, this principle of interpretation must apply, that every doubtful passage of the word must be explained by those that are unequivocal upon the points involved. Scripture cannot contradict itself. The truth underlying the parables of the mustard seed and the leaven must be identical with that which underlies the drag-net full of good and bad fish, the tares and the wheat, the son returning suddenly and unexpectedly to the house left in care of the servants, the ten virgins, etc. When all such passages that are thought to teach the invisible and spiritual nature of the kingdom, and its gradual development, are collated and put side by side with those that teach its literal, objective, visible character, and its sudden manifestation and triumph by the exercise of omnipotent power in the overthrow of its enemies, every reader will be astonished at the amazing fullness and emphasis of Scripture as to the literalness of the kingdom and its establishment in the world. The Scriptures which seem to teach otherwise will be found to be exceptional and very few at that, while not one of them but will admit of easy explanation in harmony with the witness of the great bulk.—E. P. Goodwin, D. D., in Advance.