AdventAI

A CONSISTENT PUBLISHER.

By G. W. Morse

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 46., November 23, 1886

BY G. W. MORSE.

The publisher of the Sunday School Times has been frequently importuned to change the name of that paper to the Sabbath School Times. In a recent issue, the editor gave quite a number of extracts from the letters he had received requesting such change, and added the following comment:—

“The term ‘Sabbath’ is, as we have already said, the name of an institution, not the name of a day of the week. It is a term that is applied, in the Bible text, sometimes to a single day,—a day of the week or a feast day,—sometimes to an entire week, sometimes to a full year, and sometimes to an indefinite period of time. To limit its use to the mere designation of a particular day of the week would be to concede that the fourth commandment is a specific command to observe that particular day of the week,—the seventh day of each week by its ordinary numbering,—that day, and that day only, as the day of sacred rest and worship; and this would be equivalent to charging a breach of the fourth commandment on all Christians who observe any other day than Saturday as the Sabbath of the Lord our God. The editor of the Sunday School Times honors the spirit of those Christians who faithfully adhere to Saturday as the day which they understand to be the day of God’s appointment for Sabbath observance; but he cannot conscientiously charge all other Christians with a violation of God’s commandments, as he would do if he admitted that the term ‘Sabbath’ is the name of a particular day of the week as such. Hence it would be a sign of moral weakness on his part if he were to yield to any popular clamor for a misuse of human language, in order to secure a condemnation of those Christians who religiously observe Saturday as the Sabbath.”

“It is true that the term ‘Sunday’ has its traces of the old paganism of our fathers; but the same may be said of the name of every other day of the week. Would it seem to be the right thing for the editor of the Sunday School Times to apply a vestige of paganism as the name of every day of the week except one? Is that a sort of religion that would commend itself in Missouri or Kansas? We trust not. As to the question of the origin of religious words in our English language, it will be found that very few of those words were created in heaven expressly for sacred uses, and have been used accordingly in all their history. To decide on using no words which have a trace of paganism in their beginnings, would be to limit our ordinary speech within most inconvenient boundaries. But apart from the question of the day of the week as such, there is another reason for refusing to substitute the term ‘Sabbath-school’ for ‘Sunday-school.’ The ‘Sunday-school’ is an institution, or an agency, as well known by its own name as the modern life-insurance system, the railroad system, or the banking system; and it has a right to be known by its own name. . . . We could no more change the name of this paper to the Sabbath School Times, or the Bible School Times, with a clear conscience, than we could change it to the Hosanna Assembly Times, in memory of the children’s joyous gathering on the slopes of Olivet, on the first Palm Sunday of Christian history. In fact, a change of the name of the Sunday School Times, in view of the representative character of this paper, would be in violation of the conscientious convictions of its proprietors, and would indicate a moral weakness of which they ought not to be guilty.”

It is rare that we observe such consistency among the adherents of the Sunday Sabbath as is displayed by the editor of the Sunday School Times in thus refusing to change the name of his paper. He discovers that it will first be necessary for the institution to change its name, before it will be proper to change the name of that great organ of the same.

While commending the consistency of our esteemed contemporary in the matter above referred to, we can but lament the discovery of points of weakness in other particulars that are quite inexcusable. He starts off by remarking that “the term Sabbath is . . . the name of an institution, not the name of a day of the week.” It is to be regretted that he did not go a little further and state when, by what means, and for what purpose the Sabbathp. 724 was instituted. He evidently discovered that should he do so, he would find some very formidable breakers ahead. For instance, he would have been obliged to state that the Sabbath was instituted in the garden of Eden by the direct act of God, before man fell, as a memorial of creation, to be observed by mankind perpetually. He would have found that the seventh day of the creative week was taken as the specific day for the celebration of the Sabbath, and that it can no more be changed to any other day of the week and retain the same reasons for its observance, than a man can change his birth-day to some other day of the month than the one upon which he was born, or than Independence Day of this country can be changed to the fifth day of July. Man might, by defiantly repudiating the Sabbath instituted by God, institute a Sabbath according to his own fancy; but to appropriate in behalf of such man-made Sabbath, the reasons and command given by God for his holy day, would be the most heinous violation of the first, the eighth, and the ninth commandments. It would, in the first place, be recognizing other authority than God’s as superior to his. It would be stealing of the most daring character, and an out-and-out falsehood.

The editor of the Times evidently discovered the foregoing liabilities, should he admit that the Sabbath institution was inseparably fixed to a definite day of the week, and so, with adroitness worthy a better cause, he takes the position that the Sabbath is a most convenient institution; one, indeed, that man may move around from one day of the week to another, to suit his fancy. Having taken this position, he is prepared to sanction the observance of any day of the week as Sabbath, by any class of people in any part of the globe. According to the Times, they are all keeping the Sabbath of the Lord! Indeed, we may conclude that the Times believes that one may keep a whole week, or even a year, as the Sabbath, and that such observance will satisfy the demands of the law for seven weeks, or seven years, as the case might be. Thus one would be at liberty to work continuously for six years, and then observe the seventh year as the Sabbath, and still fulfill the requirements of the Sabbath command. Notice his words:—

“It [the Sabbath] is a term that is applied, in the Bible text, sometimes to a single day,—a day of the week or a feast day, sometimes to an entire week, sometimes to a full year, and sometimes to an indefinite period of time.”

We cannot conceive how a position could be taken on this important subject that would be more destructive to the usefulness and uniformity of the Sabbath, than the above. Total abolition could not do much more by way of destroying the divine origin and nature of the institution, and making it entirely subject to the whims and conveniences of mankind. We are astonished to see our contemporary thus turn a Sabbath destroyer.

While it is true that the mere word “sabbath” is variously used in the Scriptures, as suggested in the foregoing extract, it is not true that it always has reference to the Sabbath of the Lord, instituted at creation and commanded by the fourth precept of the decalogue. The editor of the Times knows that there were, under the old dispensation, numerous feast days, holy days, etc., to which the term “sabbath” was applied. He also knows that in all cases, almost without exception, throughout the Bible, wherever the term “sabbath” occurs, there is little or no difficulty in discovering whether a ceremonial institution is referred to, or the Sabbath of the Lord. This last-named institution maintains its distinctive characteristics upon all occasions, and under all circumstances where it is mentioned; and there is not in the entire Bible the least scintilla of evidence that it could be celebrated upon any other than the day of the week upon which it was founded; viz., the seventh day. Even the ceremonial sabbaths all had fixed dates and duration, and were not left to any such fluctuating, helter-skelter system as the Times endeavors to establish for God’s holy day. We do not call to mind any of them that were not to be celebrated every year, or as often as they came, on a definitely prescribed day of a certain month; and the time of their continuance was stated with equal definiteness.

This endeavor to traduce God’s great memorial to the level of transitory, shadowy, ceremonial institutions is unworthy any Bible student, least of all a great public journal of wide-spread influence. With one more reference, we close this criticism. It is this:—

“To limit its use [that of the term sabbath] to the mere designation of a particular day of the week, would be to concede that the fourth commandment is a specific command to observe that particular day of the week,—the seventh day of each week by its ordinary numbering,—that day, and that day only, as the day of sacred rest and worship; and this would be equivalent to charging a breach of the fourth commandment on all Christians who observe any other day than Saturday as the Sabbath of the Lord our God.”

Such frankness as indicated in the foregoing paragraph is truly refreshing. It means simply this: that if God selected a definite day of the creative week upon which to institute a memorial of his creative work; and if the fourth commandment means literally just what it says, the seventh day of the week at the present time, and that day only, is the Sabbath of the Lord our God. Or, in other words, if the Bible record of the institution of the Sabbath, and the command for its observance, are true and valid, only the observers of the seventh day are conforming to the same.

We respectfully suggest that our esteemed contemporary can do no more valiant service for the cause of God in the restoration of his Sabbath than to accept the conditions of its own admissions, and act accordingly.