IMPORTANT LETTER FROM AN ENGLISH ASTRONOMER.
Time-setters well understand that their first necessity is to break down the chronological theory maintained by S. D. Adventists; for if this latter be correct, all the prophetic periods have terminated, and there are absolutely no data upon which to base any calculation of definite time for the Lord to come. The strongly fortified dates of 457 B. C. for the beginning of the 70 weeks, A. D. 27 for the beginning of Christ's ministry, the spring of A. D. 31 for the crucifixion, and the autumn of A. D. 34 for the termination of the 70 weeks, the first 490 years of the 2300, must all be disproved, or it is certain that the whole period of the 2300 years terminated in 1844, and we are now in the indefinite waiting, watching time described by the prophet when he says, “Here is the patience of the saints; here are they that keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.”
The efforts to overthrow our position on the dates above named have been characterized by a recklessness of assertion, and an utter disregard of historical testimony, which are truly astonishing. As a leader in this work, one Wm. Sheldon has seemed to take delight in thrusting himself to the front through the World's Crisis. His point of attack has been the date of the crucifixion of Christ. Christ, according to the prophecy of Daniel 9, was to be cut off [be crucified] and cause the sacrifice and oblation [the Jewish ceremonial system] to cease in the midst, or middle, of the last, or seventieth, week. Now if the date of this event was in the spring of A. D. 31, where it was placed by the most intelligent interpreters of prophecy in the great movement of 1844, and has been placed by S. D. Adventists ever since, it fixes the end of the 70 weeks in A. D. 34, and the end of the 2300 days in 1844. Hence that date must in some way be overthrown by any one who would extend the 2300 days to a point later than 1844.
To do this, Mr. S. some time ago manufactured this assertion: that if Christ was crucified in A. D. 31, he was crucified on Tuesday; for he claims that the passover fell in that year on Tuesday; and as Christ did not rise from the dead till the first day of the week, he must have lain in the grave five days. Then with a degree of effrontery most astounding, inasmuch as it must have been based either on utter ignorance in regard to the matter, or on a knowledge of facts to the contrary, he asserted that all the leading astronomers of America and England agreed that the passover in A. D. 31 fell on Tuesday. Then with an air of triumph he flourished the assertion about in every conceivable attitude that S. D. Adventists had no alternative but to give up their date of the crucifixion and abandon their whole prophetic scheme, or admit that Christ, contrary to all the testimony in the case, lay in the tomb five days.
A moment's thought is sufficient to convince any one that it is impossible from astronomy to tell the day of the week on which any event so long ago as the beginning of the Christian Era occurred, on account of the different method of computing months and years then in use. While we can tell the year and the day of the Jewish month on which an event occurred, we cannot tell the day of the week. And the object of Mr. S. in making such an assertion is very apparent. He thought that many would take for granted the truthfulness of his assertion, and none would be prepared to dispute it, and thus an impression could be carried against our views and in favor of his own. He did not seem to think, though he was careful not to mention the names of any astronomers who held that the passover in A. D. 31 fell on Tuesday, that it would be a very easy matter, with the present facilities for the interchange of thought, to ascertain the views of leading astronomers on this subject.
When the assertion came out, simply for the purpose of testing the matter notes of inquiry on the point were sent to the astronomers connected with the leading institutions of learning in our country, and not one was found who was willing to take any such position or was prepared to indorse it in any one else. Eld. Webber, of Maine, also corresponded with several parties concerning the matter. In preparing to reply to one of his inquiries, Mr. Swift, of the Warner Observatory in Rochester, N. Y., wrote to an English astronomer, celebrated for his chronological researches, in regard to the matter. In due time Mr. Swift received a reply, which he forwarded to Eld. Webber, and which the latter placed in our hands at the late Maine camp-meeting. We have before us the original letter, which reads as follows:—
“THE VICARAGE, FLEETWOOD.
“DEAR SIR: I cannot claim for myself to be such an expert in matters of chronology as you describe, but I will do my best as regards your question.
“The fact is that in the early ages of science so little was known respecting the ‘precession of the equinoxes,’ and other causes which affect the computation of time, that it is impossible to connect with accuracy such epochs as the observance of the Jewish passover at that early period with the time of its observance in the present day. All we can do is to say that if the modern computation of time had then prevailed, such and such would have been the date of its observance. In this view I am supported by the late Professor de Monjou, whom I consulted, and who characterized a calculation which I made on the supposition alluded to, as ‘much too bold.’
“If in the year A. D. 31, the Jews had used the present system of reckoning years (regard being had only to change of style), they would have found the full moon on which the paschal feast depended, to have taken place on March 25. The year with them began at the equinox, but their instruments for observing the phenomenon were very imperfect. We must be content therefore if we can rely upon the correctness of the years in which the facts of history took place, without prying too curiously into the exact day of the years. I fear if you make a determination you will have to make many hypotheses in order to show that it is reliable. The best work to consult is Sir Harris Nicolai's ‘Chronology of History.’ But Ferguson's Astronomy, p. 377 in the edition of A. D. 1770, will give you some information.
“Believe me,
“Yours faithfully,
“JAMES PEARSON.”
In the card accompanying the foregoing letter, Mr. Swift says: “I do not believe it is in the power of man to determine the exact day. If it was, there would be no question arising in regard to it.”
To such an ignoble end comes Mr. Sheldon's false and foolish assertion that the passover in A. D. 31 fell on Tuesday, and that the leading American and English astronomers agree in that position. It doesn't pay to resort to such tricks to oppose the truth. In the light of the foregoing facts, whenever our readers in the future meet with anything from the pen of Wm. Sheldon, they will be able at once to determine the scale of its importance, and rate it at its true value.