AdventAI

“THOUGHTS UPON THOUGHTS.”

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 43., November 2, 1886

We have before us a four-page dodger bearing the title, “Thoughts upon Thoughts. Criticism on Uriah Smith’s ‘Thoughts,’ by Rev. Z. R. Ward, Parker, Dakota.” This was sent in sometime during the past summer, while we were away at the camp-meetings, and would have been noticed sooner but for our absence from the Office.

Whatever talent Mr. Ward may have in other directions, prophecy is a field in which he evidently is not at home. He writes like a man who is trying to see through a pair of wooden spectacles with cast iron lenses. He says we put in papal Rome as the fifth kingdom of Daniel 2. Those who have a copy of real “Thoughts” will see that we do nothing of the kind. The papacy is not brought out in Daniel 2, and we make no comments upon it there. We deal with the different matters of the prophecy as they are introduced, not before. The prophecy of Daniel 2 deals with Rome as a whole, making no distinction between its pagan and papal forms, and brings us down to its division, whether into ten parts or less or more, it matters not here to stop to inquire; but it was divided, that is certain; for so the prophecy expressly declares. Then, after alluding to the attempts which would be made by different ones to consolidate these kingdoms, to make them cleave together, and the utter failure of all such attempts, the prophet passes over to the fifth kingdom, the kingdom of Christ, which is to dash in pieces all earthly kingdoms, and having cleared the territory of the debris as chaff would be taken violently away by a cyclone, this kingdom is to fill the whole earth, and stand forever.

Now this fifth kingdom is not set up till after Rome is divided. Whatever division or kind of division may be referred to, it is certain that division of some kind must take place in the Roman Empire before the fifth kingdom is set up. But Rome was a unit for over three centuries after Christ. Therefore it is absolutely and forever impossible that this kingdom could have been set up in the days of Christ. Why will men continue to butt their obtuse heads against incontrovertible facts?

That Christ is carrying on a work in this world which is designed to gather out of its inhabitants such as can be saved, to be the citizens of the coming kingdom of glory, and is therefore called a kingdom of grace, we admit. But this kingdom is co-eval with the plan of salvation. Its presence is seen wherever a work of grace goes on among mankind; and it will continue till the subjects are all prepared for the kingdom of glory, when in the grand cataclysm of fire the dispensations will change, and such divine power will be manifested against the foul interloper, sin, and all its organized governments and infatuated followers, as will be seen to be indeed a “dashing” of the image to atoms by the stone cut out of the mountain without hands.

But Mr. Ward has this kingdom set up in the days of Christ. It has been established, he says. Then of course it has smitten the image, and dashed it to atoms; for it cannot be “established” till it has done this. This kingdom, on his hypothesis, must of course be the church, and only the true church; for Christ would recognize no other as his. Then we inquire,—

1 Where, then, is the King of this kingdom?—Nowhere on earth; for the church is not to have any visible head on earth. Papists are more consistent in this matter than Protestants; for they have set up their king, the pope; and Protestants have an opportunity to see in that the logical evolution of their own theory.

2. Where is the territory of this kingdom?—Nowhere on earth; for the church has no territory, and controls no kingdom. The apostate Romish Church tried to run the kingdoms of Europe during the Dark Ages, but it made them ten-fold more the children of the Devil than they would have been if they had been left to their ancient paganism.

3. And where are the subjects of this kingdom?—A little flock, scattered here and there; for Christ’s true followers have never been more than this at any one time in this world, and never will be; and this little flock have been harried and tormented and slaughtered without mercy by the governments of earth. And this is the smiting of the image, and dashing of it to pieces! Dashing with a vengeance! May Heaven mercifully preserve a little common sense among men in reference to his word.

4. And then Mr. W., blindly following an idea absorbed from his theological predecessors, but not even hinted at in the prophecy, says, “The stone is rolling on to its mountain ascendency.” The prophecy says nothing about the stone’s “rolling.” But the image is dashed to pieces, and the territory it has occupied is entirely cleared, before the stone takes its place here as the fifth kingdom of the prophecy, at all. And as to what he considers the rolling of the stone, the progress of true and genuine Christianity is growing less, and true faith is waning away, till when Christ appears, his own words will be applicable, “Will he find faith on the earth?”

If Mr. W. will not represent us as bringing the papacy into Daniel 2, and then fight that man of straw, but wait till we come to it in the prophecy, he will do us more justice and himself more credit.

He says that Daniel does not say anything about ten kingdoms arising out of the Roman Empire, either in Daniel 2 or 7; that the ten horns do not denote ten kingdoms at all. He claims that the ten horns denote only ten individual, personal kings; and his only reason for this is that they are called “kings” in the prophecy. These horns belong to the beast which he acknowledges to have been pagan Rome. So to meet the prophecy, he singles out ten of the old Roman emperors, and says these were the ten horns. Why does he single out ten of the emperors to answer to these horns to the exclusion of the others? There is no sense in it at all. Rome had seven kings, eleven Cæsars, five good emperors, and thirty military despots who went by the name of emperors, and seventeen emperors of the West, after the empire was divided. If one of these was represented by a horn, the others were just as much; and the beast should have had seventy horns instead of ten. The utter absurdity of singling out ten of these, and saying these are the ten horns, when there are sixty others standing by which have just as good a claim to that distinction, is at once seen.

Moreover, these horns are said to be “out of” this kingdom. Dan. 7:24. How can a king who comes to the throne to rule and conduct the kingdom be said to be a king “out of” that kingdom? The idea is so ridiculous that it is a marvel it should have been entertained a moment by any one. We might just as well say that twenty-two presidents have arisen “out of” the United States.

As to the use of the term “kings,” the angel told Daniel (7:17) plainly that the four beasts were four “kings” which should arise out of the earth. Why does not Mr. W. claim that these four beasts are simply individual kings, because this term is applied to them, the same as he contends about the horns. To three of these kingdoms there is no other term applied but “kings.” And doubtless Mr. W. would have contended stubbornly that these were only so many persons, had not the prophecy headed off that puerile conception by saying expressly that the fourth beast was the fourth kingdom. Verse 23. And in saying this the prophecy simply gives us a key by which to interpret the word “kings,” showing that the words “king” and “kingdom” are used interchangeably; and that when the word “king” is used, “kingdom” is meant. The ten horns, therefore, are ten kingdoms. These ten kings are “out of” the fourth kingdom; but it is impossible for a king to arise “out of” a kingdom. If he was raised up to rule that kingdom, he was a part of that kingdom. If he became a king over something else, he was not “out of” that kingdom, unless he took a part of that kingdom with him; and if he did this, that which would be “out of” the kingdom, would not be the king himself, but the new kingdom which he established. In no way is it possible to make Mr. W.’s position hold.

Other absurdities in this wretched attempt at criticism will be noticed hereafter.