THAT Satan, as the antitypical scape-goat, will receive upon his own person at last all the sins that are borne from the heavenly sanctuary as our Lord finishes its cleansing, and will perish with them, is very distinctly taught in the Mosaic types. Yet some seem to conceive that such a doctrine involves the idea that sins are punished twice, which they consider sufficient ground for the entire rejection of such a view. A correspondent from the State of New York writes:—
“Eld. B. L. Whitney, a Seventh-day Adventist minister, at the camp-meeting a few years ago, in Canton, N. Y., offered five hundred dollars in gold, if any one would furnish any proof or authority from the Bible for keeping the first day of the week, or Sunday, for the Sabbath. The same sum is now offered if any one will furnish any proof from the Bible that any other being is punished or suffers for the sins of the righteous except the Son of God. Those who profess to be giving the Third Angel’s Message, teach that the Devil will be punished for the sins of the righteous. I would like the gold, but see no chance to win. Can it be possible that two beings suffer for the same sins? No such thing in the type.”
We do not know who offers this reward, as our correspondent says he would like to win the gold, but sees no chance; and this does not matter, for we care nothing about that feature of it. We are, however, solicitous to understand and teach the truth on this interesting and important point.
In the type the sins of the people were borne out from the sanctuary and laid upon the head of the scape-goat. This is explicitly stated in Lev. 16: 21. This goat, on account of having these sins upon him, was considered a malign creature. On account of these sins he was caused to perish. Were it not for these he would have lived on. So far as the representation of the type was concerned, he perished solely on account of these sins; and with him the sins were considered as having perished. But other victims had died for these same sins; for these sins that caused the death of the scape-goat were the ones which were borne from the sanctuary; but no sin was borne into the sanctuary except through the blood of a victim. For each one of these sins therefore two victims died: singly as the offerings were brought to the sanctuary day by day, and collectively in the scape-goat at the end of the service. This is certain.
Now all this work typified similar facts and a similar service connected with the ministration of Christ. Christ was the antitype of all those offerings brought by the sinner to the priest,—offerings the blood of which was shed on account of the sinner’s sins, and through which said sins were conveyed into the sanctuary. The scape-goat, which did not receive the sins till after they had been atoned for in the sanctuary, and both the sanctuary and the people had been cleansed from them, could not be a type of Christ, but must have prefigured some being upon whom Christ will lay the sins which he, as priest, bears from the sanctuary, just as the priest in the type bore them out and laid them upon the head of the scape-goat.
All the inferences to be drawn from the Scriptures, and very definite opinions from both Jewish and Christian writers, show that the scape-goat typified Satan. Now as the scape-goat perished beneath the load of sins which the priest bore from the sanctuary and laid upon him, so in the antitype, the sins from which Christ cleanses the heavenly sanctuary, must enter as a factor,—in what proportion of course we cannot tell,—into the load of guilt under which Satan at last perishes in the lake of fire. Herein the case of Satan must differ a little from that of the scape-goat, this being one of the points, in all probability, in which, as Paul says, the law did not have the very image of the things to come (Heb. 10: 1); for the goat perished wholly on account of the sins of the people, but Satan has an account of his own to answer for as well.
And it seems peculiarly appropriate that the sins removed by Christ from the account of the righteous, should be set back to the account of Satan; for he is indirectly the cause of them all. He is the father of sin. Through him it came into the universe, to do its fearful work; and to whatever extent men as agents have become involved in the same work, he stands behind as the prompter and inciter of their evil deeds. And when the sinner leaves the service of Satan, and transfers his allegiance to the Saviour, is it not consistent and right that it should be so arranged that he leave the consequences of his transgressions with him who incited their commission?
Then, as stated by our correspondent, the questions arise, Are sins punished twice? Do two beings suffer for the same sins? The careful reader will perceive that these questions are not the same. Two victims did certainly suffer for the same sins in the type; and there must be a corresponding antitype to each. Yet we do not think it follows that sins are punished twice, as we will now endeavor to show.
Take the cases of the wicked: has not Christ suffered for their sins? The Scriptures testify that he had upon him “the sin of the world” (John 1: 29); that he bore these sins “in his own body on the tree” (1 Pet. 2: 24); and that he “tasted death for every man.” Heb. 2: 9. Now has not Christ suffered just as much for the sins of the wicked as he has for the sins of the righteous? But will not every wicked man receive the punishment for his own sins, the “just recompense of reward,” in the lake of fire? Is not every one judged out of the things written in the books, according to his works? Rev. 20: 12. Does not every one answer for the things done in the body (2 Cor. 5: 10), even to every secret thing? Eccl. 12: 14. And according to, and for, these deeds will not every sinner receive just punishment, tribulation, and anguish, in the great day? Rom. 2: 6-9. And yet for every such sinner did not Christ taste death, and for his sins suffer just as much as for the sins of Paul or Peter or John? Then are these sins of the wicked punished twice, once in the person of Jesus, and then again in the persons of thep. 713 wicked themselves? This difficulty about the double punishment of sin does not lie against our view of the scape-goat especially, but against what all must acknowledge to be well established facts.
The difficulty, however, we apprehend, lies in a misconception of what it was necessary for Christ to do. Some seem to think that he must have endured the aggregate of all the physical suffering which will be inflicted upon all the wicked. But was it necessary for this to be taken into the account at all? Without referring to that awful sense of rejection by God, which he experienced, and which no human mind can fathom, and which the sinner in his measure will at last feel, we may look at him as simply presenting himself before the law, as if a transgressor, and surrendering his life to its claims; but so exalted was he in the scale of heavenly principalities, and of such infinite value was the life he offered, that it was an ample equivalent for the lives of all the denizens of earth from the beginning to the end of time. On this great fund of satisfaction to the law, so to term it, the sinner is permitted to draw. Seeking pardon through Christ, behind his accepted Saviour he presents himself to the law and says, You have my life in this my substitute to cancel your claims against me, as a transgressor. The law accepts the equivalent; and the sinner goes free.
If, then, the claims of the law are satisfied, why is there any more account made of those sins at all?—Perhaps there would not be, if the sinner was the only one concerned in them. But he is not; there is another party to the transgression, in reference to whose responsibility no satisfaction has been made to the law; for Christ did not die for the Devil or his angels; and the law thus having still to do with the transgression, and man having been rescued by the intervention of Christ from his share in the responsibility, the whole guilt of that course of sin in which the sinner and Satan were inseparably connected, reverts to the last-named party to be expiated in the lake of fire. The consistency of this principle is recognized in many of the business and commercial transactions of men; and on this principle, and this alone, can there be found a correspondence between type and antitype. Thus it is evident that some other being besides the Son of God does suffer for the sins of the righteous, and others besides the Son of God likewise suffer for the sins of the wicked; but, properly speaking, the sins themselves are punished but once.
With this view of the subject, the scene at the end of the thousand years is clothed with a sublimity which no language can picture. There, when for the first and only time the whole human family stand together in the presence of God, the righteous within the city, the wicked without, all the angelic hosts both good and evil are also gathered together; and there every sin ever committed, from the first inception of Satan’s fatal apostasy in heaven, to the last blasphemy uttered on the margin of the lake of fire, is represented in the person of Satan and his evil angels, and his wicked human followers, and all passes into the fiery vortex which shall forever rid the universe of its polluting presence.