AdventAI

Dodge Center.—

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 45., November 16, 1886

Minnesota.

AMONG THE CHURCHES.—Since my last report, I have seen some evidence of the blessing of God. I can truthfully say, “The Lord is good, and greatly to be praised.” I remained at Pelican Rapids until Sept. 28, when I went to the Sauk Centre camp-meeting, leaving fifteen trying to keep all the commandments of God. At the Sauk Centre meeting the Lord seemed near, and I left with a strong determination to labor on in the cause of the Master. From this meeting I started out on a short tour through my district, visiting the churches at Crow Wing, Verndale, Stowe Prairie, Wadena, and New York Mills, and passing through Frazee City came to Pelican Rapids Oct. 22. I found that the enemy had succeeded in causing two to give up their hope in the truth; others were firm and doing well. Bro. L. Johnson arrived the same day, and we labored together until the following Thursday. Six were baptized, and a church of ten members was organized. Five others are keeping the Sabbath who we hope will join the organization later. Thursday I came to West Union, where I spent the Sabbath. I am now on my way to Stowe Prairie, to attend the district quarterly meeting. Nov. 3. BYRON TRIPP.

AMONG THE CHURCHES.—Since our camp-meeting at Sauk Centre, which but few Scandinavians attended, I have visited Lake Johanne, Gilchrist, Artichokep. 716 Herman, Pelican Rapids, and Eunice, and the work of God is onward. The most of the brethren in all these places show by their works that they love present truth; and my earnest prayer is that through Jesus Christ our Lord they may be victorious over all that would hinder them from glorifying God, and remain faithful to the end.

At Pelican Rapids I met Bro. Tripp. Although we there felt the hatred of the enemy toward those who keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus, yet we received many blessings. A church was organized, composed of ten members. Six received baptism, and four had previously been baptized. Officers were chosen. There are several more who keep the Sabbath of the Lord who we hope will soon unite with them.

At Eunice one brother was baptized and received into the church, and a sister decided to keep all the commandments of God. These brethren are all poor, but this year the Lord has blessed them with good crops, which helps them much. We celebrated the ordinances, and an elder was chosen and ordained. A young brother from here will attend our school in Battle Creek this winter. I am now at Monticello. Nov. 4. L. JOHNSON.

Dodge Center.—

While at Dodge Center, Oct. 24, 1886, we received the following communication, which will speak for itself:—

“To Elds. W. B. Hill, H. Grant, etc., the ministerial brethren at the S. D. Adventist quarterly meeting in Dodge Center, greeting:

“Dear brethren: As I am here for the purpose of considering the claims of Mrs. E. G. White’s so-called ‘visions’ to inspiration, and other points in the Advent doctrine, it would be very agreeable to me to have you present to hear me. And as you have been very bold in declaring your readiness to meet ministers of other denominations in discussion, I therefore invite you to a public discussion of the points of difference between us. You shall have the free use of the S. D. Baptist house here, and the whole evening to yourselves, and shall be treated with Christian kindness and fairness.

“You shall have every alternate evening as long as you see fit to continue the discussion.

“If you hold the truth, you need not fear discussion or investigation. If you do not hold the truth, the sooner all concerned know it, the better.

“Patiently awaiting your decision, I am your brother in the Lord Jesus, “ALEXANDER McLEARN.”

After consulting the brethren here, it was thought best to accept the invitation so urgently given. Accordingly, arrangements were made to consider the following subjects: The “Testimonies,” the Nature and Destiny of Man, and the Sanctuary. Eld. M. was to lead out, and I was to follow. The “Testimonies” were considered first. He began with his sad experiences at Battle Creek, claiming that sister White’s “Testimonies” were the cause of his grievances. He admitted the church members to be among the finest and best people he ever knew or met with; but he set forth the leaders, with few exceptions, as being deceivers and falsifiers of the worst kind, as being lords in God’s heritage, and ruling the flock with despotic sway. He seemed to warm up while thus traducing our leading brethren. He soundly berated us for going from house to house and persistently teaching our doctrines, visiting the disaffected, those of limited judgment and lacking sense, claiming that we should be despised and that we are despised, one of his brethren responding warmly, “It serves them right.” About this time we began to think the sweet spirit of Christian kindness was not quite so prominent as his letter of invitation had led us to expect. When he spoke of S. D. Adventists and their work, he manifested a bitterness impossible to conceal. He next took up the old and long-ago exploded objections to the “Testimonies,” such as suppression, the shut door, etc.

We replied that as to his troubles in Battle Creek, we could say but little, as we were not present, and were not very well acquainted with the circumstances in the case. If the men he had so bitterly assailed could be present and speak for themselves, things might look very different. It would be interesting, no doubt, to hear them give their version of the matter. Does our law judge a man before it hears him? These men had not been heard, therefore could not be judged or condemned. It is marvelous that such wicked men should attract to themselves the best men and women we ever knew. It is wonderful that such exceptionally good people would continue so long under the leadership of such bad men. Lastly, these men are not deceivers and falsifiers as he has set forth, but are the Lord’s faithful servants; yet he has spoken evil of them behind their backs, and no backbiter shall abide in the Lord’s tabernacle or dwell in his holy hill. Ps. 15:1.

As to the charge of going from house to house, we pleaded guilty. In that respect, he had brought in a true bill against us; but that we merited contempt for so doing we could not admit, as that would involve the apostle Paul in the same condemnation, for he testifies: I “taught you publicly, and from house to house.” Acts 20:20. It is a fact that some good Seventh-day Baptist deacons and others invited us to their homes, and we read the Bible and prayed with them, but failed to discover that they were very limited in judgment, or especially lacking in sense.

Concerning suppression, shut door, and other objections urged by him against the “Testimonies,” we had good liberty in replying to them. After answering objections, we showed that the “Testimonies” stood every Bible test, that God’s Spirit should be poured out upon his people in the last days, that they should see visions, and prophesy, and that the spirit of prophecy would be a prominent characteristic of the remnant church (Rev. 12:17; 19:10); and closed with an appeal to the S. D. Baptists to be friendly with us, as they and we are the only people in the world upholding God’s down-trodden Sabbath, and as far as possible unite with us in the good work.

Our people were much strengthened in the belief that the “Testimonies” are of God, and rejoiced greatly in the truth. But trouble was in the camp of our S. D. Baptist brethren. We had been cordially invited into their church, and now the great question seemed to be, how to get us out again as soon as possible. We pleaded for more than one discourse each on each subject; but that was not to be thought of. Eld. McLearn then came to the front with the statement that he must go to Wisconsin, and could stay no longer than till Sunday evening. We urged that the terms of invitation extended the time as long as we saw fit to continue the discussion; and now must we be limited to just three discourses? How is this? Did he not know his time was so limited when he sent us the challenge? or did he think his three discourses all that we would be able to endure?

He next stated that he had sent us this invitation entirely upon his own responsibility, and the board of trustees would not stand to it. Here was a marvel of marvels, that he should presume to promise us the free use of the church without consulting the leading brethren, and without any authority whatever for so doing. Granting this to be so, why should the board object? The invitation reads: “If you have the truth, you need not fear discussion,” etc. Even so of our S. D. Baptist brethren: if they have the truth, they need not fear discussion or investigation. But all this availed nothing. The decree was inexorable. We should be allowed three discourses and no more.

Another trouble was, they said, I did not conduct our side of the discussion properly. I brought in more scripture than Eld. McLearn, which was all wrong. Eld. McLearn demanded that we should refer to the scripture texts he quoted, and to those only. We agreed to examine carefully every text he quoted in support of his position, and fairly answer his argument; but we must have the privilege to compare scripture with scripture, and so harmonize the whole. Notwithstanding his demand was so unreasonable and unjust, he determined to force it upon us by appealing to the audience. The vote was so unsatisfactory to him that he waived his demand and proceeded with his discourse on the next subject; viz., the nature and destiny of man.

We have neither time nor space to refer to more than one, and that the most prominent, of his positions on this subject. A little new light was offered on Rev. 20:13: “Death and hell delivered up the dead which were in them,” etc. “Death,” he claimed, was from the Greek word thanatos, and denotes the abode of the departed spirits of the wicked. “Hell” is from the Greek word hades, and denotes the place where the bodies of the dead remain between death and the resurrection. At the resurrection, thanatos delivers up the spirits of the wicked, and hades delivers up their bodies; bodies and spirits are then reunited and cast into the lake of fire. We called his attention to the fact that both hades and thanatos delivered up the dead which were in them. Whatever hades delivered up was dead. Whatever thanatos delivered up was dead also. Therefore if thanatos delivered up the spirits of the wicked, they were dead spirits.

This new exegesis was disastrous in the extreme to his explanation of the rich man and Lazarus, which he claimed was no parable. We showed from the revised New Testament that the rich man was in hades, which, according to Eld. McLearn, contained his dead body only, while his conscious, intelligent spirit was away off in the regions of thanatos; yet his dead body in hades exercised all the powers of conscious intelligence, suffered torments, lifted up its eyes, saw Lazarus in Abraham’s bosom, engaged in conversation, exercised the power of memory, etc., etc. Strange dead body, this! Absurdity could go no farther; it had reached its climax.

This was a little too much. The board of trustees declared the discussion closed, and announced that henceforth the pulpit would be occupied by their own pastor. But upon the next day (Sabbath), by a vote of the church, Eld. McLearn was permitted to continue his work, which he did, and the following evening delivered his discourse on the sanctuary question. We were not present, but were informed by reliable persons who were present that he told the listening people that S. D. Adventists are the two-horned beast of Rev. 13, and have the mark, and to look out for them; and the reason he gave to show why S. D. Adventists are a united people, was that three men rule the whole body. In the General Conference, he says, there is never a negative vote. If a man should presume to vote negatively, off comes his head. What must we think of a man that claims to know all about us, to tell nothing but the truth, yet makes such a statement as this, which all who have ever attended our General Conference know to be utterly false? The way he tells these things is calculated to deceive; thus, “What I tell you is true, brethren; I have been there, and know all about it.” He is so positive, and makes his statements with so much assurance, that it would seem a person must believe them unless he knows better.

His great burden is the “Testimonies.” If the Seventh-day Adventists would only discard the visions, then the sun of prosperity would shine upon them, and all would be well and good. Well, let us see: The first-day Adventists are not hampered with the “Testimonies,” and they are in fragments; no unity exists among them. The followers of Snook and Brinkerhoff cast the “Testimonies” overboard, that they might take their upward flight, and where are they? Our S. D. Baptist brethren stand upon an eminence of two hundred years’ growth and experience in the work of promulgating the Sabbath truth. They have no such weighty incubus to hinder their progress or cripple their efforts; and yet they report themselves as scarcely holding their own.

S. D. Adventists believe the “Testimonies,” and although we are of recent origin, our membership (we say it not boastfully) is more than three times that of the most numerous of the classes mentioned, and rapidly growing. How is this? Our people are sending the truth to earth’s remotest bounds. At the last California camp-meeting $100,000 were pledged to carry forward the missionary work. If our good S. D. Baptist brethren would only look at our position and our work with unprejudiced eyes, it seems to us they could easily judge whether the “Testimonies” are a help or a hindrance.

There are many precious souls among them for whom we hope and pray. Eld. McLearn’s effort has already increased the interest to learn more of sister White and her work, and calls are being made for her writings by those who wish to investigate for themselves. The Advent doctrine is like gold; the more it is rubbed, the brighter it shines.

While listening to Eld. McLearn, I could scarcely realize that he once enjoyed the light of present truth. I could only think of the words of the Saviour: “If therefore the light that is in thee be [or become] darkness; how great is that darkness!” Again it is demonstrated how closely the “Testimonies” are connected with the present truth. He turned away from them, and confusion on every other point ensued until even the Third Angel’s Message is cast away. Not only so, but his mind is filled with astonishing bitterness against the truth; and nothing will be left undone that he can do to hinder and destroy it. When will men learn they can do nothing against the truth, but for the truth? “The dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ” (Rev. 12:17), which “is the spirit of prophecy.” Rev. 19:10. The dragon is angry with the remnant because they keep the commandments of God, and also because they have the testimony of Jesus Christ. From what we have seen of late, we are sure that the conflict is coming upon the “Testimonies” as well as upon the commandments of God; and God’s people must not waver or be of doubtful mind on either point. Both easily endure the test of the keenest criticism.

When a man like Eld. McLearn cannot endure to have his criticisms criticised, it is evident to all that they are not very well founded. It was very pleasant work for him to misrepresent and ridicule the “Testimonies,” but to have such work exposed and shown up in its true light was not so palatable. It is with him as it was with the Irishman and his peaches: he liked their flavor very well, but complained that the seeds lay hard in his stomach.

With reference to his charge about our challenging other denominations, I will say that the nearest we came to challenging any one in our tent meeting last summer, was simply to offer our tent to a certain minister to publicly make good what he was privately saying against us behind our backs. Nov. 5. W. B. HILL.