I HAVE a neighbor who tries to puzzle everybody with this question: “If God is good and loves us and wants us to be happy, as Christians assert, why did he make a Devil to tempt us to sin?”
This man came to me the other day; and I promptly met his question with another, “Did God make a Devil?”
“Of course he did,” was the reply; “for God made everything. To suppose that the Devil made himself is absurd, and to claim that he is uncreated and existed from eternity would give us two rival gods. If there is one God omniscient, omnipresent, and almighty, as you folks say, and there is a Devil who goes about like a roaring lion, God must have made him.”
“Well, let us see. Here is an apple that is rotten to the core. Does God make rotten apples?”
“No, he makes ripe apples, and we ought to eat them when they are ripe. If we keep them until they rot, that is our fault. But what have rotten apples to do with the Devil?”
“Perhaps more than you think. . . . Let me ask you another question. Does God make whisky?”
“No; I suppose not. He makes grain, and men turn it into whisky.”
“Yes the wheat, rye, and corn that are created for food are rotted, spoiled for all useful purposes, and then distilled into poison. Man does this, and then calls whisky ‘a good creature of God.’ Is it so?”
“No; but God knew when he made the grain grow that it could be turned into whisky. Why did he put into it the element for making poison?”
“We will come to that by-and-by. You were on the train the other day when the locomotive exploded, I believe?”
“Yes.”
“Well, when you stood viewing the wreck, the boiler all torn to pieces, the fragments of the engine thrown all about, did you read the letters on that piece of brass that used to be on the side of the locomotive, ‘Baldwin Works, Philadelphia’? It was lying in a conspicuous place among the broken wheels and levers.”
“Yes, I remember seeing it.”
“Did you say when you saw it, ‘I know who made this wreck; it was that locomotive company in Philadelphia. They had no business to send out a locomotive that could be blown up. They got up the machine, and they are responsible for all the consequences’?”
“Do you think I am a fool? Baldwin & Co. make first-rate engines. Thousands from their shops are running on the railroads of the world. They are perfectly safe when properly used. But the Baldwins or anybody else can’t make an engine that can’t be abused. The engineer in this case let the water get too low in his boiler. It was his fault, and not the fault of the maker. The very fact that an engine is a machine of such tremendous power makes it dangerous if it is not managed just right.”
“Well, don’t you see that God’s relation to Satan is like that of the Baldwins to an exploded engine? The only difference is that in the case of the Devil he was both locomotive and engineer. He put on the steam of pride until he threw himself from the track. And now he dashes to and fro, an archangel ruined, a guilty, wretched being, though still so mighty that he is called ‘the prince of the power of the air.’ And as misery loves company, he tempted other angels, and now tempts men, to share in his sin and sorrow. That is the way it came to pass that there is a Devil in the universe, and that he is the tempter of the human race.”
“But couldn’t God have made men and angels so that they would not have been able to sin?”
“Of course he could. He so made the stars. They are kept by attraction in their orbits, and cannot wander. But what is their obedience worth? It is like that of a clock, which you wind up, and it has to run and mark the time for you. It is a machine, and must do what it was made to. God had machines enough; he wanted free agents: and when he made free agents they could choose evil instead of good; they could disobey instead of obey. However innocent and upright they might have been at their creation, it was possible for them to fall. That possibility was inseparable from their freedom.”
“Do you wonder that God wanted men and angels as well as stars? You have a child; when Kitty comes to you with her kiss and says, ‘Papa, I love you,’ you are happy. But why? Is it because of the kiss and the words? Suppose a machine was made to look just like your child; that you could wind it up so that it would kiss you and say, ‘I love you;’ would that satisfy you? In some respects the machine would be better than the child. It would always kiss you when you wanted it to, while the child is sometimes wilful and perverse. But you would rather have the child with its possibilities of disobedience than the machine, though it is sure to obey. You want love that is free and not compulsory; and that is what God wants. He made Satan as he made Gabriel, but Satan used his freedom to rebel against his Maker. For this rebellion he only is responsible, as the engineer, and not the locomotive builder, was responsible for that wreck last week. So the answer to your question is, God made an angel free, holy, happy, and he made himself a Devil.”— Obadiah Oldschool, in Interior.