AdventAI

THE “SCIENCE” OF 1 TIM. 6:20.

By L. A. S.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 36., September 7, 1886

The “American Association for the Advancement of Science,” an assembly composed of a large number of the most distinguished scientists of the country, held a recent session for the discussion of scientific subjects, at Buffalo, N. Y. While it is but reasonable to suppose that the proceedings of this assembly were in the main characterized by sound sense, and in the highest degree instructive, we submit that part devoted to the subject of anthropology—the natural history of the human species—as a fair specimen of what the apostle Paul designated as “science falsely so called.” The conclusions arrived at on this subject, as summed up in a paper read before the convention, were as follows:—

“We find that the ideas of the antiquity of man which have prevailed of late years, and more especially since Lyell published his notable work on the subject, must be considered modified. No doubt, if we are willing to give the name of man to a half-brutish being, incapable of speech, whose only human accomplishments were those of using fire and of making a single clumsy stone implement, we must allow to this being an existence of vast and as yet undefined duration, shared with the mammoth, the woolly rhinoceros, and other extinct animals. But if, with many writers, we term the beings of this race the precursors of man, and restrict the name of men to the members of the speaking race that followed them, then the first appearance of man, properly so styled, must be dated at about the time to which it was ascribed before the discoveries of Boucher de Perthes had startled the civilized world; that is, somewhere between six thousand and ten thousand years ago. And this man who thus appeared was not a being of feeble powers, a dull-witted savage, on the mental level of the degenerate Australian or Hottentot of our day. He possessed and manifested, from the first, intellectual faculties of the highest order, such as none of his descendants have surpassed. His speech, we may be sure, was not a mere mumble of disjointed sounds, framed of interjections and of imitations of the cries of beasts and birds. It was, like every language now spoken anywhere on earth by any tribe, however rude or savage, a full, expressive, well-organized speech, complete in all its parts. The first men spoke because they possessed, along with the vocal organs, the cerebral faculty of speech. According to this supposition, there existed at an incomprehensibly remote age a merely “animal” man, differing but little from his brute ancestors, from which through long ages he gradually ascended, till, at a point somewhere from six to ten thousand years in the past, he became suddenly possessed of the faculty of speech, with its correlative endowment of thought and reason; all of which is in harmony with the interpretation now placed by a certain class of religionists upon Gen. 2:7 and kindred passages. If this view be correct—if this be the true method of interpreting those Scriptures which Christ commanded us to search because in them we “have eternal life,” well may we exclaim in the language of his disciples, “Who then can be saved?” L. A. S.