A PROBLEM FOR EVOLUTIONISTS.
By L. A. S.
One of the many little difficulties which evolutionary enthusiasts so generally ignore, or, seeing, “pass by on the other side,” relates to the antagonism of evolution with “natural selection,” one of the vital tenets of the great evolutionary theory. The Christian at Work, of Aug. 26, thus alludes to the problem:— “It is well known that Darwin’s theory of Natural Selection, involving the survival of the fittest, antagonizes the theory of evolution, and, as many conceive, disastrously so. For if the strongest survive, how comes it that, if man is descended from anthropoids, the smaller apes and monkeys have survived, while that Missing Link, with a brain weighing all the way from twenty-five to forty ounces, is still missing? This inquiry awaits an answer; and meantime evolution is being wounded in the house of its friends. Thus Prof. Moritz Wagner has felt himself obliged to abandon Darwin’s ‘Natural Selection,’ and he offers instead a theory of Isolation. In his view man was created somewhat after this fashion: ‘The progenitors of man, some sort of an ape, lived in tropical Asia. One pair, or perhaps a few pairs, migrated from their home in the northern part of the continent, and their return was prevented perhaps by glaciers. This pair were now in a very different climate, and were obliged to struggle more severely for their existence than they did in the luxurious tropics. This active struggle produced rapid changes, and since they were not able to breed with original unmodified stock, the variations were transmitted and modified. This finally resulted in the creation of man.’ There are too many perhapses in this theory, involving the idea that two anthropoids got on the wrong side of the glacier, and a less luxurious tropic produced a more luxurious, more complete man. Here again Natural Selection is made to wound Evolution. In this relation it may be mentioned that Prof. Hartmann, of Berlin University, in his elaborate work on anthropoid apes, just issued, concedes that the difference between the higher and lower apes is fully as great as that between man and the higher anthropoid apes. But he believes that man cannot be descended from any ape now existing, nor from any known fossil species, but must have descended from some common ancestral type which is no longer extant, but which continues to be approached more nearly in the young of both species. This brings us into the darkness again, confronted by the problem, If man is descended from the apes, how comes it his weaker relatives alone are living, while his more heroic statuesque progenitors are still among the missing?” The expounders of this noble “science” would confer a favor on some who are less credulous by pausing in their discoveries long enough to remove the interrogation point from a few such queries as is contained in the above. Meanwhile, let us try not to be envious of those who, from the lofty heights of evolution, obtain this sublime panorama of the origin and natural history of mankind. The many contradictory aspects, however, in which the subject appears to these individuals, leads to the conclusion that the atmosphere surrounding their point of observation has become exceedingly misty.