AdventAI

A JESUIT UNIVERSITY.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 44., November 9, 1886

In the Review of Oct. 26, we gave an extract from the convention address of Bishop A. Cleveland Coxe (Episcopal) on the dangers now threatening this country from the growth of Roman Catholicism in our midst, the influx of the Jesuits, and the proposed Jesuit college at Washington, D. C. They were ringing, stirring words, so much so that the Catholics have not seen fit to let them pass unnoticed; and accordingly, the highest Catholic functionary in this country, Cardinal Gibbons, launches at the Bishop a compound of strictures on his address, and personal reflections on himself. To this the Bishop returns a crushing reply, and we can serve our readers no better than by laying it before them. We find it in the Independent of Oct. 28, 1886. Under the heading, “A Jesuit University at our National Capital,” Bishop Coxe says:—

“In addressing my Diocesan Council on the 21st ult., I took occasion to remark on the new phases of Roman aggression to which the American people are now subjected. Carefully guarding myself from all personal reflections upon my contemporaries, I also uttered the most kindly remarks upon ‘Roman Catholics,’ as such, and confined my strictures to the Jesuits and their allies, against whom, as I was particular to mention, the severest censures had always proceeded from the Roman Catholics themselves. I instanced the divers nations which had been forced to expel them, and the complaints that had proceeded from divers popes, until Clement XIV. was forced to suppress and extinguish them altogether, as formidable enemies to the peace of the churches and the prosperity of states.

“In this connection I referred to the proposed Roman Catholic university at Washington, and to the perils with which it threatened our institutions, if the Jesuits are allowed to control it. I praised the efforts of those Roman dignitaries who share my anxieties, and are striving to keep it out of Jesuit hands; but I remarked that, under thep. 694 new and extended powers and facilities of the Jesuits, they will be its masters, at all events. In fact, both England and the United States have been so far committed to this society, apparently, that every Roman Catholic in these countries is under the Jesuit yoke, unless, as a subject or a citizen, he is bold enough to defy the foreign aggressions which would rob him of his rights, and impair his loyalty to native constitutions; for all civil and religious freedom is denounced by the ‘syllabus,’ an instrument clothed by the late pontiff with his ‘infallible’ authority, but well known to be dictated by the Jesuits and enforced, for their gratification, upon their brethren.

“The Church in which I have been placed in authority is profoundly American in its history and spirit. Its roots, as an American church, are embedded in our earliest colonial history; and after the independence of the colonies was established, its constitution was framed in the closest harmony with the national constitutions. It is needless to add that many of the framers of our constitutions were members of the Anglican Communion; and that the distasteful name of ‘Protestant Episcopal’ was accepted as our local and civil title, in order to signify our entire consent to be placed on the footing which we supposed prescribed to all religious bodies by the spirit of our laws. If this name is becoming more and more distasteful to our people, it is because we find others not equally submissive, and because we observe that arrogance and contempt for our equal rights and common privileges are successful, far and wide, in over-awing our politicians, and in obtaining from them many advantages denied to Christians who are truly loyal and loving Americans. It was in view of these facts, and other similar considerations, purely practical, that I reminded my own people of the new dangers now threatening us, and which are virtually setting up as a privileged religion an ecclesiastical system controlled by foreign authority and subjected to the despotism of a society against which all Christendom has been warned, not less by the lesson of history than by a Roman pontiff himself, in a most solemn instrument, designed to suppress that society forever; but which they have found themselves strong enough to disobey.

“I am sorry that so respectable a character as Cardinal Gibbons has seen fit to reflect on me personally, and to censure my manner of remark. It would have been more to the purpose had he announced the name of the ‘president’ who has been selected for the projected university, which he thinks ‘it better should not be known just yet.’ This would have enabled us to judge whether the moderate Roman Catholics have succeeded in placing a Sulpitian in that position, or whether the Jesuits are in open and undisguised possession.

“The Washington Star of Sept. 27, contains a reporter’s interview with the Cardinal on the subject, from which we learn that the president has been selected, and from which I take the further information following:—

“He does not think criticism of that sort will injure the prospects of the university. The attack would do no harm. He would not like to speak of Bishop Coxe in the manner Bishop Coxe has of speaking. He discussed the subject as of very little importance. Bishop Coxe, he said, had taken a notion, he did not know why, to attack this university, but it was only the commencement of a work of high civilization. The highest civilization, he said, had always grown around these great Catholic institutes of learning. The universities of Oxford and Cambridge, in England, had been founded by the Catholics, as had nearly all the other great institutions of learning in Europe. This, he said, would be the foundation of just such an institution, and there was no reason why it should excite suspicion or dread in any one.”

“1. The Cardinal does not like my manner of speech. I will soon recall to his memory the ‘manner’ in which Pope Clement XIV. expressed himself on the same subject. I can quote Roman Catholic authorities without number, whose remarks and judgments on the same subjects are not likely to please him any better; but I am sorry to add that ‘the manner’ in which his co-religionists are accustomed to treat of subjects very dear to the American people would furnish him with a more legitimate object of such strictures and complaints.

“2. The Cardinal ‘does not know why’ I have been led to object to the proposed university. He knows that I objected to it only because it was to be governed by the Jesuits; and why I should object to them as educators is quite apparent if he will compare the ‘syllabus’ with the American Constitution, or with the constitutions and laws of the several States.

“3. The Cardinal assures us that the university is ‘the commencement of a work of high civilization.’ Not very flattering to the existing civilization of the United States; but we may assuredly be allowed to inquire what country in which the Jesuits have controlled education, exhibits ‘the high civilization’ we are encouraged to expect? The papal states, before their emancipation from the Jesuits, ought to furnish us, of course, with the very highest type of the civilization they would transfer to America; for there no Protestant schools or influences had ever been tolerated. The statistics of illiteracy which have since been made public, have astonished Europe. Not one in sixty of the population received any elementary education, and the proportion of the people who could neither read nor write was below that of any respectable nation in Christendom. Let me suggest that if ‘a high civilization’ is the benignant purpose of the university, it would be well for its friends to send it to Mexico, Brazil, or any other part of America, which has been hitherto under the less beneficent influences of the society.

“4. The Cardinal forgets that the universities of Cambridge and Oxford were founded by Anglican Catholics (Ecclesia Anglicana is the expression used in Magna Charta), and not by Roman Catholics. If they were then in communion with the Roman pontiff, it was not on the terms now exacted. They recognized no creed of Pius IV., no ‘papal infallibility,’ no ‘immaculate conception,’ no ‘syllabus’; there were no Jesuits in existence in those days; and if the universities of Cambridge and Oxford are now justly cited by the Cardinal as examples of high civilization, will he kindly inform us where, in the wide world, ‘just such an institution’ is to be found, under Jesuit influences?

“5. But it is time I should inform the Cardinal ‘why I have taken the notion that there is much to excite suspicion’ in the projected university. It is, in short, because the highest names in literature, pre-eminently those in the Roman Communion, have taught me to dread the corrupt morality of the Jesuits, and to reject them, with abhorrence, as the educators of youth. I shall recur to the subject elsewhere; but, to answer the Cardinal, I shall rely only on the ‘infallible’ authority of his own pontiff, Clement XIV. I trust this pontiff’s ‘manner’ may prove more agreeable to him than my own. I give only a brief specimen of it, as follows. He says:—

“It was with the greatest grief of mind that we have observed the aforesaid remedies . . . to have had scarce any efficacy or force toward rooting up and removing the so many and so great disturbances, accusations, and complaints against the society (so repeatedly named above), and that sundry of our predecessors have labored in vain to restore peace to the Church by many constitutions touching (1) worldly traffic, which they ought not to have pursued, . . . or (2) the grievous dissensions and disputes inflamed by the society with the ordinaries (bishops), orders of Regulars, pious foundations, and communities of every kind in Europe, Asia, and America, not without the great ruin of souls and the amazement of whole nations. Also (3) respecting the interpretation and practice in many places of certain heathenish rites, . . . or (4) touching the use and interpretation of maxims which the Apostolic See has justly proscribed as scandalous and manifestly pernicious to the discipline of sound morality. As also, respecting (5) other points of the greatest moment, . . . from which, in this our age, as well as in the former, numerous inconveniences and hindrances have arisen; namely, riots and tumults in some Catholic countries, with persecutions of the Church in some provinces of Asia and Europe. . . . Cries and complaints against the society daily increased [i. e., under the immediate predecessor of Clement], as also dangerous seditions, tumults, dissensions, and scandals arose in divers places which . . . inflamed the minds of the faithful with party zeal, hatred, and enmity, and things were reduced to a situation so critical and perilous that those very princes whose ancient affection and liberality toward the society . . . was greatly commended by all tongues, were forced to send away and drive out of their kingdoms, territories, and provinces, the members thereof; looking on this as the final remedy for so many evils, and absolutely necessary to prevent Christian people from falling out, exasperating, and tearing each other to pieces, in the very bosom of our Holy Mother the Church.”

“6. Much more to the same effect appears in this apostolic brief of Pope Clement; but I reserve the rest for a future publication. Meantime, if such is ‘the high civilization’ the Jesuits are wont to promote, even among their own people, what must we expect from them among ‘heretics,’ with whom they are authorized to ‘keep no faith’? Sufficient is thus cited to inform the Cardinal where I got my ‘notion’ of Jesuit education. If he thinks this manner of speech, proceeding from the papal throne, preferable to my compendious way of directing attention to the sweeping condemnations of this same pontiff, I will pledge myself when I recur to the subject, to treat him to much more of the same purport and ‘manner’ out of the writings of his co-religionists, as well as from the brief aforesaid, which abounds in rhetoric of the same delicate and exemplary character.

“7. I must only add that, since our Roman Catholic brethren are here, and seeing that all things persuade us to charitable intercourse and good neighborhood, it is a pity that Cardinal Gibbons should object to my protest against the further importation and aggrandizement among us of a society which has so notoriously inflamed members of their own communion against one another, and set them to ‘tearing one another to pieces’ in the bosom of their common mother-church. If in all this the Cardinal ‘sees no reason for dread,’ he must remember that Pope Clement did, and that here I entirely agree with his holiness.”