LAST week we noticed a few of the strictures which Mr. Z. R. Ward, of Dakota, has offered in his little circular, under the foregoing title, upon the positions taken in “Thoughts on Daniel and the Revelation.” A few other points should perhaps receive a word of notice. He says that to save our theory of the papacy we have to “manufacture symbolic time.” If the Bible anywhere recognizes and uses symbolic time, we do not manufacture it when we use it; and that the Bible does recognize it, and show us how it is to be used, he himself admits, as every one also must admit who acknowledges the authority of the Scriptures. He may think we err in calling the time mentioned in Daniel 7 symbolic time, but that is a very different thing from “manufacturing” it. His inaccuracy in the use of words is a clear indication of the confusion that exists in his own mind, and the inaccuracy of his methods of reasoning.
Referring to the proof-texts on this point, Num. 14:34 and Eze. 4:6, he endeavors to parry their force by saying that they are limited to the particular occasions there mentioned. These passages, to be sure, are spoken with reference to particular occasions; but they are symbolic occasions. Ezekiel in lying upon his right side and left side for a certain number of days, was acting as a symbol; and inasmuch as time is connected with this act, the manner in which it is spoken of must give us the general rule for interpreting it, in all instances where it is used in connection with symbols. But the characters brought to view in Daniel 7 and 8 are certainly symbols; hence the time connected with them is also symbolic, and comes under the divinely-appointed rule of “a day for a year.”
He objects again that what he calls the “symbolic word,” that is, the word “day,” does not occur in Daniel 7, at all. Very well, we have the word “time,” which is elsewhere explained to mean a year, and a year is, in Bible computation, composed of 360 days. If a man never has had mind enough given him by his Creator to follow through a simple line of thought like that, he will never be held accountable for not understanding the prophecies. But more than this, the same period of time spoken of in Daniel 7 as a “time, times, and a half,” is in Rev. 12 and 13 reduced to months and days, being called in one case (13:5) “forty-two months,” and in the other (12:6, 14) “a thousand two hundred and three-score [1,260] days.” So there is no occasion for stumbling here.
Now, finding the word “time” in another part of the book of Daniel, Mr. W. makes a grand plunge for that with the idea that our theory is completely upset by it. He says: “To show the mere assumption of this theory, we will apply it to another prophecy, Dan. 4:33-34.” This refers to the time when Nebuchadnezzar was to be driven from his kingdom till “seven times” should pass over him. This he says would be twice as long as the continuance of the little horn, or, according to our theory, 2520 years. Then he waxes facetious over Nebuchadnezzar’s being turned out to grass 569 years before Christ, and having 65 years yet to feed! We must admit this, he says, or deny the prophecy, or change our “symbolic time.”
There are some people who seem to be capable of holding in their heads only one idea at a time. If perchance another comes in, the first is at once crowded out. Mr. W. seems to think that if time is symbolic in Daniel 7, it must be so everywhere else in the same book. It never seems to occur to him that time may be used in a literal sense as well as symbolic, and is to be so used in every case except in symbolic prophecy; and he ought to know that there are literal prophecies as well as symbolic; and time used in connection with literal prophecies is also literal. Now what was said to Nebuchadnezzar (Dan. 4:23, 32) was all literal, a plain statement of what should befall him. Nebuchadnezzar was not a figure, but a literal person; so the seven times to pass over him were simply seven literal times or years; and Josephus testifies that just this length of time he was driven from his kingdom.
If one should come to us with an arithmetic, and point in addition to the sum of 10 and 5 making 15, then, turning to the multiplication table, find the same figures multiplied, showing a product of 50, and claim that the author was mistaken here, and this ought to be 75 because it was so in the first example, we would say, No, little boy, you mistake; different principles are involved in the two examples; one is in addition, and the other in multiplication, and both are correct.
Just so with the word “time” in the book of Daniel. In Dan. 4:32 it is used in a plain, literal statement, and means just so much literal time; in the other case it is a part of a symbolic prophecy, which multiplies it by figures representing the number of days there are in a year. If there is some one living near Mr. W. who has an interest in his welfare, we would kindly request such an one, out of commiseration for his bewildered condition, to sit down by him and slowly and patiently go over this point with him, again and again, till he is able to see that there is a difference between literal and symbolic time, in literal and symbolic prophecies.
What follows in the circular under notice is composed, like the foregoing, of inexcusable perversions and palpable falsehoods. He says:—
“Mr. Smith having declared this eleventh horn to be the papacy coming out of the ten kingdoms, contradicts himself on p. 154, and exhibits a cut of ‘Rome,’ the fifth horn out of a broken partition of Alexander’s kingdom (the third beast), and p. 158 says the horn symbolizes both ‘pagan and papal’ Rome. Now if the papacy arose out of a portion of the third beast, it could not arise out of the divisions of the fourth beast; and vice versa, if it arose out of the ten divisions of the fourth beast, it could not have existed amid the fragments of the third beast.”
In this will be noticed the same contemptible effort to confuse the mind of the reader by confounding two distinct prophecies together, and then representing that we try to make one fit upon the other. Here he confounds the visions of Daniel 7 and 8. In Daniel 7, the little horn does not arise out of the ten, but simply among them, plucking up three of them. But in Daniel 8, the Roman power is not brought into the field of vision till it has made Macedonia, one of the four horns of the goat, a part of itself, and hence is there consequently represented as coming out of one of the horns of the goat; and in this vision Rome is represented in its unity, its great religious phases, first pagan, and long years afterward papal, not being noticed. When here introduced into prophecy, 161 B. C., it was pagan, and so remained for over six centuries and a half, till after its division into ten parts, among which divisions the papacy afterward arose. Yet he represents us as teaching that the papacy arose out of one of the fragments of Alexander’s empire. Such a charge is either knavish or idiotic; we leave the reader to judge which.
As noticed last week, he has the ten kings, represented by the ten horns, in the days of which the God of heaven was to set up a kingdom, refer to simply ten personal kings; and he has the kingdom set up at the first advent of Christ. It becomes, then, an interesting question to determine which ten individuals are thus pointed out. He says: “I suggest Augustus Cæsar, in whose reign Christ was born.” Then if the kingdom was set up in his days, it was not set up in the days of any other of the ten kings. He next names “Tiberius Cæsar, in whose reign Christ was crucified.” Was the kingdom set up in his days? Then it was not set up in the days of Augustus, whom he mentions first, nor in the days of Caligula, Claudius, Nero, Galba, Otho, Vitellius, Vespasian and Titus, whom he names afterward. If the kingdom was set up in the days of any one of these kings, it was not in the days of any of the others. But the prophecy says that it is in the days of these kings,—plural, all of them,—that the God of heaven sets up his kingdom. It is marvelous how any one can fail to see that the kings named in the prophecy are contemporaneous, and that while they are reigning together the kingdom of God is to be set up. That the ten horns of the fourth beast of Daniel 7 are also contemporaneous, is shown in the fact that the papal horn plucks up three to make way for itself. Mr. Ward makes Domitian the little horn that came up among the ten. But which three of the ten he names did Domitian pluck up to make way for himself, seeing they were all dead and in their graves before he came to the throne?
And now he shows still further confusion on the kingdom question; for he quotes Matt. 21:43,—“The kingdom of God shall be taken from you and given to a nation bringing forth the fruits thereof,”—and then adds: “Here the ‘kingdom of God’ had been set up, was in existence, in Christ’s day, and Christ declared it.” According to this the “kingdom” was what the Jews had, or it could not be taken from them. But no new kingdom was given to them in Christ’s day; and if they had it then, they had had it from the days of Moses; and he must transfer his ten kings back to Moses’ day.
Again, in speaking of the sanctuary, he shows his inability to take into his mind two ideas at a time; for because the “sanctuary” of paganism is mentioned in Dan. 8:11, he makes the sanctuary of verse 14 to be the same, and then drivels along through a set of foolish charges that we have the city of Rome cleansed, and the Catholic Church and even the pope cleansed!
But it is useless to pursue such folly further. His other points are equally misleading, false, and frivolous. He calls upon his brethren to procure his circulars by the quantity, and scatter them wherever “Mr. Smith’s book has been circulated.” “These,” he says, “ought to follow Adventist literature in general circulation.” If they will adhere to this rule, and let it follow, it will be all right; for if a person has had opportunity to read for himself, we have no fears of his being misled by Mr. W.’s sophisms. The danger is that it may fall into the hands of those who are not acquainted with Adventist literature, and who, having never read for themselves, will be liable to take his assertions as correct, and so be inadvertently prejudiced against the truth. We leave it to a benign Providence to fulfill Isa. 8:10 in reference to all such attempts to mystify his word.