In an article in the Christian Statesman of Oct. 21, 1886, appear two paragraphs that do not well harmonize. The article is published, as the writer says, “to show why most people believe that the Sabbath was changed to the first day.” The first reason is stated thus—
“This change was prophesied in Ezekiel 43 : 27. ‘And when these days are expired, it shall be, that upon the eighth day, and so forward, the priests shall make your burnt-offerings upon the altar, and your peace-offerings; and I will accept you, saith the Lord.’”
We will grant, for argument’s sake, that this prophecy is what the Statesman claims; viz., that it prophesies a change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week. It follows that on and after the time when this change should take effect, those people who were previously observing the seventh day of the week should observe the new day which is spoken of in the text as the “eighth day.” It is claimed, but by what right we will not now stop to discuss, that this “eighth day” would be the first day of the week. We will grant that claim for the time being. Now, according to the further claims of our opponents, it was the Jews, and the Jews only, who were under obligations to keep the seventh-day Sabbath so long as it was binding; and by the wording of the prophecy before quoted, it is evident that the ministrations of this so-called “eighth-day” Sabbath were to be performed by the very same persons who had previously performed the ministrations of the seventh-day Sabbath. The words are, “Upon the eighth day, and so forward, the priests shall make your burnt-offerings upon the altar.” No mention is made of a new order of officials for this new order of Sabbaths, but the continued service of the same officials who ministered under the previous system.
Thus we are forced to the conclusion that if the former, or seventh-day, Sabbath was a Jewish institution, the new one, said to be prophesied of in Eze. 43 : 27, is equally so. There is no intimation in the text that this new institution was designed for the Gentiles or any other people besides those who had previously observed the former.
Now we are prepared to consider another point made by the Statesman, in its endeavors to show why most people believe the Sabbath was changed. It is this:—
“Paul says in Col. 2 : 16, that we are not bound to observe any of the Jewish Sabbaths; therefore the first-day Sabbath must be binding.”
But hold! According to the Statesman’s own reasoning, this first-day Sabbath must be a Jewish institution; and here we find the position taken that “we are not bound to observe any of the Jewish Sabbaths.” Thus is the structure that was first erected, swept out of the way by a succeeding argument. By what logic the Statesman arrives at the conclusion last stated we cannot comprehend. Sincep. 699 it was first proved that the first-day Sabbath must be a Jewish institution, it would seem that the natural sequence would be this: “Paul says that we are not bound to observe any of the Jewish Sabbaths; therefore the first day of the week cannot be binding, because it is a Jewish Sabbath.”
But no; the Statesman reaches no such conclusion. By the use of some remarkable powers of reasoning, it makes out that the first-day Sabbath is a Jewish institution; then it proves that we are not bound to observe Jewish Sabbaths, and from this concludes that the first-day Sabbath is binding! And these are fair samples of the reasons “why most people believe that the Sabbath was changed to the first day,” taking the Christian Statesman as authority. We have long believed those reasons to be fallacious and self-contradictory, but hardly expected to see so prominent a champion of the first-day Sabbath as our contemporary before quoted, present so conclusive proof that such is the case. G. W. MORSE.