It was a rainy Sabbath, and but few were present in the little country church. As the preacher came in, some of the sisters gathered about him and said, “Don’t preach to us to-day, Bro. —, just talk to us.”
How many long-suffering congregations, with systems rasped under the loud, shrill, high-pitched tones of the preachers, if they could only find a voice during the sermon, would cry out to the pulpit: “Don’t preach to us any longer; just talk to us!”
Hooker, in his “Ecclesiastical Polity,” tells of the complaint of the people about the preaching in his day: “Some take but one word for their text, and afterward run into the mountains so that we cannot follow them, not knowing how they went up or how they will come down again.” So some preachers no sooner name their text than they mount up into a high swelling tone, as far removed from the ordinary way in which a man talks as the east is from the west; and, having once mounted, they never come down again until the end of the sermon.
Etymologically, the sermon, or homily, is a talk, and not a speech; a conversation, and not an oration. The best rule, then, for the ordinary preacher is, to make the conversational style the basis of his delivery. Not that he is never to rise from this, but let this be the point from which he starts out as his fervor leads him, and to which he returns after a short excursion. The following advantages will result: The preacher will not be so much in danger of wearying himself. One may talk for hours in conversation without fatigue. It is the unnatural, declamatory tone that makes the throat ache. Again, he will not be so much in danger of wearying the people. One may listen to a conversation for hours without feeling tired, but one cannot listen to a person declaiming in a uniform pitch for half an hour without fairly aching. In conversation one varies his tone to suit the thought, while one who declaims is in danger of keeping one pitch for all kinds of thought. To be sure, there are some in every congregation who think the preacher tame who only talks. “How do you like your new preacher?” said one neighbor to another. “Oh, he is improving wonderfully; he preaches louder and louder!” But those who have this test—in any congregation—are comparatively few.
A preacher who talks to people will be less liable to fall into affectation and cant. Said the colored brother, “De new preacher is mo’ larnt dan Mistah Boles; but bless you, sah! he ain’t got de doleful sound like Mr. Boles had. No indeed!”
But if a man assumes a preaching and doleful tone the moment he enters the pulpit, he cannot but be guilty of affectation; his tones cannot be a true index to his feelings. There are some good souls, indeed, upon whom the doleful tone seems to act as a kind of charm. They will close their eyes and float to heaven under the influence of the preacher’s tone, without any regard to what he is saying. But it is safe to say that while one in a congregation, under a preaching tone will close his eyes and soar to heaven, ten will close their eyes and sink to sleep.
If one speaks in the tone of conversation, he will use the short, simple words of conversation. Nothing is more manifest than that the pulpit should use, not the artificial words of books, but the simple, common words of life. Great swelling tones necessarily draw after them “great, swelling words.” All successful evangelists are colloquial and conversational in their preaching. “Nothing is more calculated,” said Mr. Finney, “to make a sinner feel that religion is some mysterious thing that he cannot understand, than this mouthing, formal, lofty style of speaking, so generally employed in the pulpit.”—Church Advocate.