THAT the readers of the REVIEW may have some idea of the kind of opposition the truth meets in this part of the vineyard, I wish to notice a discourse that I listened to Sunday, July 11. The speaker was one of those so-called Adventist preachers with which the country abounds, whose lamp went out years ago, since which time he has been running here and there after all. He has attempted to fill his lamp with several “time movements.” He has also tried a community of goods, and for several years he measured the great pyramid and thought he found wondrous light for the people who sit in darkness! But do not think from the above description of his vagaries that he is a “wandering star,” without standing among his brethren. For years he has been secretary of an Adventist association which holds semi-annually one of the largest camp-meetings in the Province of Quebec. His position in regard to the law of God is certainly novel. Let me give a few of his statements:—
“I admit all that Sabbath-keepers claim of the reality, value, and permanence of the law. The Sabbath is not changed. The Christian Sabbath is not God’s Sabbath changed. Sunday was fixed upon by the early church, but there was no divine authority for so doing. The law is based upon principles that are eternal. It was an expression of God’s will to man. The Jews and unbelievers ought to keep the law; but Christians are not under it. Christians live above the law. We are out from under the law, and where there is no law there is no sin. Seventh-day people are seeking to be justified by the law, and they cannot deny it. When you try to keep the seventh day or any other precept in the law, you are condemned in a moment. The law was Christ’s murderer, and it is an insult to Christ to try to keep the commandments. It is saying that the blood of Christ is not sufficient, and that we are saved partly by Christ and partly by the law.”
These statements were not all made in connection as I have given them, but at intervals during his discourse. The favorite text often referred to was, “Ye are not under the law, but under grace.” “Under the law” to his mind meant under obligation to keep it; and “not under the law,” of course, meant the reverse. To illustrate his theory he told a story of a Frenchman who was drafted for the army, but procured a substitute. The substitute was killed in battle. Afterward the same man was called on to go to war again, but he claimed that he was dead, having died in his substitute, and the case being carried before the courts was decided in his favor. This was the story, and his application to our relation to Christ was, that “the Christian, dying in Christ, his substitute, cannot be called upon to keep the law that caused Christ’s death.”
In reply it was shown that although the drafted man could not, perhaps, be drafted into the service again, yet he was still amenable to the law of his country; that if he should commit a murder the law would quickly take hold of him, and it would be the height of lunacy for him to plead that he was dead, and therefore not under obligation to keep the law! As the conscript was exempt from a second draft, so the sinner, justified by faith in Christ, who died in his place, is saved from his past sins; and if faithful unto the end, he has the promise: “He that overcometh shall not be hurt of the second death.” Rev. 2:11. But the freed citizen was still amenable to the law of the country whose laws allowed of his procuring a substitute, and in whose courts he obtained a release from the service; and the pardoned sinner is under the highest obligation to keep the law, his past violations of which have been pardoned by his Saviour. St. Paul so understood it; for he said: “Shall we sin, because we are not under the law, but under grace? God forbid.” Rom. 6:15.
Another statement, repeated many times, was: “Man cannot keep the law. Adam could not keep it. It is absolutely impossible for human nature to keep it.” Let us see what this statement leads to. God made man amenable to law, the penalty of transgression being death. But he made the law so strict, and the man so weak, that he could not keep it. And then when man in his weakness failed to keep the law—failed because it was utterly impossible for him to succeed—God pronounced sentence upon him thus: “Dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.” Gen. 3:19. If any one can see in this theory anything but the greatest injustice and downright cruelty on the part of God toward man, I should be pleased to have it pointed out. But it may be said that after this God provided a Saviour for man. Very true; but under such circumstances where would be the merit in so doing? Having made man himself, and made him so weak as to be unable to keep the law, and then condemned him to death for not keeping it, every principle of justice demands of God that he get man out from under the curse in some way. And if this theory be true, in the gift of God’s “only begotten Son” for man’s salvation, instead of being a manifestation of love to man, and the plan of salvation a work of grace or favor, God is only doing what he ought to do, and that to rectify his own mistake!
But as one absurd position always makes room for another, before he finished his discourse he claimed that the obligations resting upon Christians were a “thousand times wider and deeper than those placed upon man in the first place.” Thus: man could not keep the law because he was so weak; then God devised the plan of salvation, and our eternal destiny depends upon our acceptance of the plan and the fulfillment of the obligations it places upon us; yet these new obligations are a thousand times wider and deeper than those man could not keep before! If this be true, we may well inquire, “Who then can be saved? If Adam, fresh from the hand of God, could not obey the law of God, how can we, after six thousand years of sin and depravity, expect to fulfill obligations a ‘thousand times wider and deeper’? Let those answer who can.”
But did not Christ keep his Father’s law? Hear him: “I have kept my Father’s commandments.” John 15:10. Did he do this as the divine Son of God or as a man? “Wherefore in all things it behoved him to be made like unto his brethren. For in that he himself hath suffered being tempted, he is able to succor them that are tempted.” Heb. 2:17, 18. And while now with his depraved nature, man cannot keep the law in his own strength, the Saviour, granting to the penitent believer a full pardon for his past sins through the merits of his blood, will impart to such a one a sufficient amount of divine strength to do his will in the future.
St. James, speaking of man’s natural propensities, says, “The spirit that dwelleth in us lusteth to envy.” But he immediately adds, “But he giveth more grace. Wherefore he saith, God resisteth the proud, but giveth grace unto the humble. Submit yourselves therefore to God. Resist the Devil, and he will flee from you. Draw nigh to God, and he will draw nigh to you.” James 4:5-8. Here we see that if we draw nigh to God he will draw nigh to us, and impart to our weakness such strength that we may serve him aright. If we have not received such grace yet, let us not make him a liar, but acknowledge that we have not drawn nigh to God as we should, have not submitted our wills unto him as fully as we ought.
We are exhorted to “come boldly unto the throne of grace, that we may obtain mercy, and find grace to help in time of need.” Heb. 4:16. And St. Paul bears testimony thus: “For what the law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh: that the righteousness of the law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.” Rom. 8:3, 4. What could not the law do?—It could not save man after he had violated it. God was not to blame for this failure, nor was his law too strict. Man was the party to blame. It was his fault in weakly yielding to the tempter that made the law inoperative for his salvation. To save man under such circumstances, letting justice have her course and offering mercy to man, required the sacrifice of the Son of God. He received the blow due the sinner.
But can those who accept this plan go on in sin, violate that law whose integrity must be maintained at such a sacrifice?—No, no. He “condemned sin in the flesh: that the righteousness of the law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh, but after the Spirit.” Some versions read, “that the requirements of the law might be fulfilled in us;” really, that we might by his grace be enabled to keep the holy law of God. Then our obedience is all of grace; for it is God who gives us strength to do his will.
But suppose, after having been forgiven of our past sins, we fail to draw sufficient grace from the great store-house to keep the law of God, what shall we do? Shall we fail of the great salvation? Listen to the apostle John, addressing Christians: “My little children, these things write I unto you, that ye sin not. And if any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.” 1 John 2:1. The Christian’s privilege is to live without sin. But if he does sin, the same pardoning Saviour who has forgiven him all the past, still stands as his advocate to secure for him a new forgiveness every day. Oh, wondrous plan of redemption! Oh, abundant grace! I have made some mistake to-day. My speech has not always been with grace. But to-night, with this promise in my hand, I confess my sin and ask my Advocate to plead for me the merits of his blood. He listens to my supplications, and pardons my transgression. I love him more for this, and determine to strive harder every day to show my appreciation of love so great. Does this belittle my Saviour, or give me any chance to glory in myself or ascribe my salvation to the law?—Oh, no; it is all of grace, unmerited grace, to me.
“Oh wondrous power that seeketh From sin to set me free, Oh! precious blood that speaketh, Shall I not value thee?”
“Not unto us, O Lord, not unto us, but unto thy name give glory, for thy mercy, and for thy truth’s sake.” M. E. KELLOGG.