AdventAI

DIVORCE OF CHURCH AND STATE IN MEXICO.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 47., November 30, 1886

OVERTHROW OF THE TEMPORAL POWER OF THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH—THINGS THAT LED TO THE SEIZING OF THE CHURCH PROPERTY—ADVENT AND GROWTH OF PROTESTANTISM.

In order to appreciate the magnitude of the religious revolution which awes the student of Mexican history, one must remember that Spain and the Church were one. The hand of Rome was in the iron glove of Cortez; for the standard which the Spanish adventurer set up, bore in Latin the motto, “Let us follow the Cross, and in that sign we shall conquer;” and so it has been. Mexico was overrun in the name of Spain and Rome, and she was governed for three centuries for the profit of both with a relentless selfishness that has left its deep and broad impress on the material and religious life of the nation, to the infinite injury of both. Church and State were apparently indissolubly and profitably united for plunder, with a very incidental regard for the interests of the Indians. What the conquest achieved, the missionaries of the Spanish Catholic Church held fast. The religion of the cross was enforced by arms, and the walls of the new faith were cemented with the blood of those slain under its banner. The creed of force and not of love won these new triumphs for the church. The most careful students of this civilization seem to agree that there was nothing radical in the transformation which gave the Aztecs pictures of the Madonna and the saints in place of their idols and heathen forms. It was in the main a change of externals in which the shadow supplied the place of the substance. With scarcely an exception, the priests indorsed and inspired the cruelties by which the power of the Spaniards was extended over the native races of America. The story of the brutalities of fire, of torture, of blood-hounds, and of the pitiless sword, by which the tribes were conquered, marked the advent of the gospel of peace.

The old Spanish writers record all this with satisfaction as fitting work done for the glory of the Church. In all this dark chapter of history, one man stands out as a lonely apostle of mercy. It was fitting that the greatest modern Aztec painter should embalm the fragrant memory of the good friar, Las Casas, the one prominent representativep. 742 of the faith who unceasingly urged a policy of clemency upon the Spanish rulers. His record of the atrocities he was powerless to stay, forms the black inside chapter that tells of the gospel as first expounded in Mexico. “With mine own eyes,” he writes, “I saw kingdoms as full of people as hives are of bees, and now where are they? . . . Almost all have perished. The innocent blood which they had shed, cried out for vengeance; the sighs, the tears of so many victims went up to God.” The never-ending stream of blood that poured from the sacrificial stone before Huitzilopochtli was not stayed by these Christian hands. It was removed from before the god of stone, and continued to flow for the glory of the only true God. The conception of the Supreme Being in Mexico and in Spain was not so very different, and the transition from the one form of worship to the other was not unduly violent, it will be seen.

With the words of Las Casas sounding in his ears, one approaches the portraits in the national museum with peculiar feelings. Here are the men who did these deeds, from Cortez down through the some fifty Spanish viceroys who successively governed the country, with occasional bishops or archbishops among them. The face fullest, on the whole, of intellectual character is that of Cortez, and the picture is vouched for as the best extant. It masks rather than reveals character. The others seem like inferior men, the ready agents of more powerful wills, occasionally rising from mediocrity into a stern malevolence of purpose. The contrast between these faces and the glorified serenity and power of the countenance of the good bishop as depicted by Felix Parra is most impressive. The agents who executed the will of Spain with regard to this distant possession, were as a rule willingly obedient to the policy which wrung all the wealth it was possible to exact from an enslaved people, and shipped it to the central government. Every industry that could conflict with the sale here of Spanish goods was strangled in its infancy by any means up to the penalty of death. Never was any land more put upon than was New Spain by the “mother country,”—that misnomer the most empty. It is a satisfaction to read that some of the treasure-laden galleons that made annual voyages in fleets to Cadiz became the prizes of freebooters of the sea, whose title to what was lost to Mexico was as good as that enforced by the Spaniards. The wars of Europe now and again were heard of in the new world, as when England’s Admiral Anson in 1743 captured near Acapulco an East Indian galleon whose cargo was valued at $2,000,000. In time, too, this war stopped the exports of bullion to Spain, and threw Mexico on her own resources, so that the business of this country was developed to a degree that made apparent the possibility of independence, and awoke the causes that led to the dawn of liberty.

By almost these same steps did the selfishness of the Church work its own remedy. A superstitious people had been first coerced, and then diplomatically led, in the fullest outward obedience to Rome. The visit of Cortez to Spain and the pope in 1527 had been fruitful in yielding a crop of bulls of indulgence that made the leader and his soldiers assured heirs of heaven, and local saints had been raised up to satisfy the appetite of the Indians for signs and wonders. Special holy privileges were also constantly on profitable sale. In time, too, the Mexican church welcomed the Inquisition, and indeed demanded it. About 1529 the leading men of the province, religious, military, and civil,—among them Zumarraga, the first bishop, the same bigot who burned the historical records of the Aztecs,—met in council, and resolved as follows:—

“It is most necessary that the Holy Office of the Inquisition shall be extended to this land, because of the commerce with strangers here carried on, and because of the many corsairs abounding on our coasts, which strangers may bring their evil customs among both natives and Castilians, who by the grace of God should be kept free from heresy.”

Thereafter the Holy Office had ample headquarters and the fullest sway, and condemned to roasting heretics and sorcerers, with the utmost zeal and method. One public burning place has since been included in the Alameda, the great Palace of the Inquisition is now a medical college, while in the city of Pueblo the Baptist missionaries control for their gentle uses a similar establishment. The first inquisitorial auto da fe resulted in the death of “221 pestilent Lutherans,” and about the last one, in 1815, condemned to be shot the patriot Morelos, companion of Hidalgo, and his successor in leadership, both parish priests, who inaugurated the war of independence in 1810. For declaring against Spain, the court pronounced Jose Maria Morelos “an unconfessed heretic, an abettor of heretics and a disturber of the ecclesiastical hierarchy; a profaner of sacraments; a traitor to God, to the king, and to the pope.” That was the beginning of the end for the Inquisition and the Church. From 1824 to 1867 it stood straight across the path of liberty, and spared no means to stay progress toward a distinct national life. Holding one half or two thirds of the wealth of the country, it had declined in 1846 to contribute anything to help repel the American invasion. This helped prepare popular sentiment for what followed.

It would be difficult to overdraw the material splendor of the Church, to whose princely revenues all contributed. A tithe of everything produced in Mexico or imported hither went to the clergy. A century of toil had been expended to rear for her occupation in this city the noblest cathedral on the continent, a century and a half had gone to make an edifice only less grand in Guadalajara, and at Puebla and elsewhere were cathedrals of note,—all magnificently adorned with gold and jewels and splendid things. The conventual establishments of the Franciscans and Dominicans were on the largest scale, and were most elaborately appointed. But while the Church absorbed so great a proportion of the wealth of the country, it early rendered back much of it on schools, asylums, and other public institutions. Thomas A. Janvier, who has made a study of these religious foundations, says: “Broadly speaking, the influence of the religious orders upon the colony was beneficial during its first century; neutral during its second; harmful during its third.” With such a hold upon the wealth of the country, and with its practices so deeply rooted in the life of the nation, how is it that without the introduction of any new form of faith the people of Mexico have overturned the old order of things? The revolution was a clear economic necessity, but it involved more than the laws of trade. It exhibits the superficial character of the hold possessed by the Church on this population. When ecclesiasticism came in conflict with the vital spirit of liberty, the weaker went to the wall; freedom and absolutism were incompatible. The practical enslavement of the native population had been accomplished by Spain and the Church, and both logically fell. When the people were groping toward freedom, this sequence was little appreciated; the first guaranties of Mexican independence were “Religion, Union, and Liberty.” Juarez was the apostle of liberty in its broad sense. He drew up the laws of reform proclaimed in 1857 by Comonfort, and he executed them in 1867, upon the downfall of the empire. This was the most radical transformation undertaken by any government of modern times. It confiscated property estimated at $300,000,000, and devoted it to the purposes of the government of independence. The Church was stripped at a blow of all its possessions, its convents and religious houses were closed, its religious societies were abolished, and to-day the Church exists in Mexico only by the sufferance of the government. The clergy were forbidden to wear the garb of their order, religious parades and processions were prohibited, and the civil marriage was declared to be the only legal one.

The retribution which overtook the Church was terrible, however much it had been provoked, and it was carried out with a sternness which was vindictive in its sweeping character. The harvest which came out of the dead past was abundant after its kind. When the Church favored a foreign mission and supported Maximilian, it tried the long-suffering people beyond endurance, and their joy in the humiliation of a great religious system was savage in its final manifestations. Nothing is more impressive in the study of Mexico than the fantastical fanaticism of liberty which has wrought such great and often seemingly untoward results, but which all, as seen in review, fit into a remarkable scheme of progress. No human intelligence foresaw the end from the beginning,—unless Juarez be made the possible exception.—Springfield Republican.

(Concluded next week.)