Such is the term applied by W. H. Osborne, an Episcopal minister, to “a church controlled by, or controlling, the State by the carnal weapons of this world, not the weapons of Christ its founder.” And this is the very abomination which the National Reform Association is laboring to set up in our own country, by such a religious amendment to the Constitution as will “place all the Christian laws, institutions, and usages of the Government on an undeniable legal basis in the fundamental law of the land.” In a discourse on “Christian Methods in Promoting Temperance,” delivered in Music Hall, Springfield, Mo., Mr. O. said many good things concerning the relation of the church to the State, from which we quote the following thoughts. Our readers will find them well worth considering:—
“There is a fascination in many minds for any methods for bettering the condition of our race which are large and grand and magnificent in their scale. We are not content usually to deal with men’s souls one by one, but we propose larger ways of doing things, by which we hope to sweep into heaven whole nations and peoples in one day. So thought that king of the heathen nation to whom Christianity was taught by the missionaries, and who ordered his subjects to the river to be baptized at the point of the bayonets of his soldiers. So thought Philip of Spain when he tried to convert the Netherlands by the military power of the Duke of Alva. So thought Charles IX. when he would make all France Christian according to his ideas, by the massacre of St. Bartholomew. So thought also Elizabeth and Laud in England, when they would enforce uniformity of worship by the power of the civil law and its penalties; so thought also Cromwell and the Puritans when they tried to Christianize England by calling in the aid of the State to enforce Christian commands and compel the practice of what they deemed Christian virtue.
“The great problem of church and State, and the relation which they bear to each other, are brought to the front again in the discussion of Christian methods as distinct from State methods of treating intemperance.”
“Many people are unable to see that the nature of the church and State are different, and that this difference must be recognized in temperance matters. We must not confound the State and church on this question.
“The function of the church is to teach men the gospel of Christ. Its teachers are pre-eminently its ministers, who are stewards of its means of grace. With this stewardship they ought to be content. It is their privilege to preach the word and administer the sacraments; and in doing this, they appeal to the free will of men, and are forbidden to resort to coercion to carry out their purposes. They are not permitted to coerce men into the kingdom of God, even if that were possible. The whole influence which they may exert must be moral and spiritual. Their weapons are not carnal, but spiritual, to tear down the stronghold of sin.
“The constitutional nature of the church and its functions are defined by Christ: ‘My kingdom is not of this world; if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight.’ But forgetful of this saying of Christ against merging church and State, Christians and Christian ministers often have not only affirmed by precept and example that Christ’s kingdom ought to be of this world’s power, but that it is most proper and commendable to fight for this kingdom by invoking civil legislation in its favor. . . .”
“The church as a corporate moral power has no more to do with civil legislation than it has to meet together in this State through its ministers, and enact laws against stealing under penalty of imprisonment, or elect a senator to the United States Senate.
“Consult the pages of our great jurist, Cooley, in his work upon ‘Constitutional Limitations,’ where he says: Consult the pages of American jurists and all jurists and statesmen of this age when men believe in keeping separate the functions of the State and church, and they will all pronounce with one voice that the essential function of a State is to prescribe law as a rule of civil conduct with a penalty as its sanction. The State ever undertakes to coerce men to obedience if they will not obey without; but the church cannot coerce. It can persuade men by the glory and beauty of righteousness, and by the tenderness and pathos and love of Christ. Thus far can she go, and no further. But this boundary of her power makes her omnipotent. Here is the omnipotence of love, which, more than the edicts of monarchs, more potent than the strength of the warrior, and mightier than all magistracies, conquers and wins the human heart to purity and godliness by the ineffable vision and attraction of the majesty of eternal right. . . .”
“I do not oppose prohibition as a State measure. If the citizens of this country think it advisable, effectual, and expedient as a police regulation, Christians, as citizens, may vote for such a State measure. But let it be understood that the church of Christ is opposed to prohibition or civil legislation when they are offered as church measures for regenerating the world. Put prohibition where it belongs—upon the platform of a State measure; but don’t foist it upon the church of Christ as a moral, religious, and Christian measure. Thus the right relation between the function of the State and church will be preserved, and Christianity in its corporate life and action will not be liable to the rebuke of making itself that abomination of all ages, a church controlled by, or controlling the State by, the carnal weapons of this world, not the weapons of Christ, its founder. . . . Let those who have so great expectations of the civil law’s help in putting away this sin, listen to the wise words of John Milton concerning the quality of such legislation:—
“Though you may take from a covetous man all of his treasures, he has one jewel left—you cannot bereave him of his covetousness. Banish all objects of lust, shut up all youth into the severest discipline that can be exercised in any hermitage, you cannot make them chaste that came not hither so. Look how much we expel of sin, so much we expel of virtue. This justifies that high providence of God, who, though he commands us to temperance, justice, and continence, yet pours out before us ever in profusion all desirable things.”
“And if again you are impatient with the slowness of the Christian methods of dealing with this sin, remember, I entreat you, in the midst of your clamor for speedier methods, in your judgment, that he who believeth shall not make haste, and that God does not reap his harvest at every political election time.”