AdventAI

THE DEBATE AT DES MOINES GIVEN UP.

By Dudley Marvin Canright; Uriah Smith

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 41., October 19, 1886

WORD from Iowa recently received brings the information that the proposed discussion between myself and Eld. Dungan, of the Disciple Church, will not come off as was appointed. The facts in brief are these: During our large camp-meeting at Des Moines last June, there was evidently a deep impression made upon the people. The Disciples have a church and a university there. Many people of that denomination were quite stirred over the preaching they heard at the meeting, and proposed a discussion. As we are opposed to debating unless really compelled to do so in defense of the truth, we gave them no encouragement; but this did not satisfy them. They were continually talking and urging it, and, to remove all objections, offered to furnish a house and also to board me. As we have a young mission there, our brethren feared that it would give an impression that we were afraid to defend the truth if we refused to debate. Therefore, finally we told them that, if they would do all they agreed to, they might choose their man, and if we could agree on the terms we would meet them.

The leaders in this were some young men from their university. We did not know what position they occupied or how responsible they were, nor did we stop to inquire. The next day these young men returned to our camp with Prof. Dungan, of their university, Eld. Lucas, the editor of their paper, Eld. Cornell, with whom I had formerly twice debated, and several other of their leading men. Elds. Haskell, Smith, Morrison, McCoy, and myself, and several others of our leading brethren met them. We had a very pleasant though brief interview, and readily agreed on the questions to be discussed, the rules, time, and everything concerning the debate. It was distinctly stated before all that they were to furnish a house free. When they suggested that a small admittance fee might be taken up, we said that we would not allow that, as it would keep away many of the people who might wish to attend. So they dropped the matter without urging it at all.

Under date of Sept. 10, Eld. Dungan wrote me, saying: “I find the party that was to furnish the house for the debate unable to do so. The best offer is the Standard Theater, at $20 a night. Now I will take the chances by raising at least a part of the amount by a door fee, or I will divide the risk and the income with you. But as I am not able to pay for the hall myself, I cannot provide a place for the debate without help.”

Of course we refused to make any such change in the conditions, and wrote Eld. Dungan to that effect. We are now told that the parties who urged on the debate are irresponsible. It seems to us that Eld. Dungan and the responsible men that were present ought to have been aware of that fact at the time, and not have waited till now to tell us so. And further, it seems to us, if their brethren who were to back them failed them, that their leading men who were present and assented to the agreement, should have felt themselves bound to make it good. We certainly would have done so if we had made such an agreement. It is remarkable also that the Oracle, their paper published at Des Moines, and edited by Eld. Lucas, who was their chosen moderator for the debate, came out a few days since with an offer to furnish a hall for a debate between the Adventists and the Spiritualists. It is a little singular that their people could furnish a hall so readily for such a debate, but could not furnish one for their own use, according to agreement.

At last, however, a hall was found that could be had for $7 an evening, or $70 for the entire debate. The students in their university raised $40 of the sum, but found their other brethren unwilling to help at all toward raising the balance needed. At least, so I am informed.

As far as I can see, Eld. Dungan seems to have been willing to do his part to carry out the discussion, and I judge that we would have had an interesting debate. But it seems that his brethren did not think they would gain anything by so doing, and failed to support him; so the matter was dropped.

Expecting the debate to come off, I have tried to post up thoroughly, as I thought it was my duty to do. I feel that the Lord has blessed me in this, and I have obtained many precious ideas and facts on the subjects of the Sabbath, law, and covenants. I shall endeavor to bring these out in some form, so as to preserve them for myself; and that others may have the benefit of them if they so desire.

D. M. CANRIGHT.

Being present at the interview above referred to, I can testify to the correctness of the statements Eld. Canright has made concerning it, and the conditions agreed upon for the debate.

U. SMITH, Editor REVIEW AND HERALD.