"SPIRIT OF PROPHECY" VS. JOHN.
We are asked to harmonize the statement found in “Spirit of Prophecy,” vol. 3, p. 216, concerning the meeting of Christ with his disciples on the evening of the day of the resurrection, with what John says in chapter 20 : 19. The volume speaks about the disciples’ returning from Emmaus after dark and threading their way through the streets of Jerusalem to the disciples’ abode, by the light of the moon. At this hour the first day must have been past, yet John says, “The same day at evening being the first day of the week.” It was not till after the disciples from Emmaus had reached Jerusalem and reported to the other disciples their interview with the Lord, that the Saviour appeared in their midst (Mark 16 : 14); and if this was the same as the meeting mentioned in John 20 : 19, how could it be on the first day of the week, as John declares? In reply it must be noticed that the meeting mentioned in John 20 : 19, is undoubtedly the same as the one mentioned in Mark 16 : 14; and secondly, that the disciples could not have reached Jerusalem much, if any, earlier than represented in “Spirit of Prophecy.” And yet we think there is no discrepancy between them. If we apprehend the meaning of John 20 : 19, it does not affirm that the interview between Jesus and the disciples took place on the first day of the week. This will appear if we give to the verse the time that would naturally be covered by it. Consider for a moment the circumstances. Near the close of that first day, the disciples, like timid doves when devouring hawks are abroad, had gathered together in the place of their common abode, and barred their doors against a possible intrusion of the Jews. Meanwhile, two of the disciples had gone to Emmaus. When they reached the place, the day was “far spent,” and it was “toward evening,” that is, near the beginning of the second day. In the city of Jerusalem the day was also far spent at the same time; and probably at about the same hour when Christ and the two sat down to meat at Emmaus, the disciples at Jerusalem had prepared their evening meal, and had gathered around the board. Some time would be consumed in eating. The two at Emmaus being thoroughly aroused by the wonderful revelation that they were conversing with their Lord, who was made known to them in the breaking of bread, and spurred with a desire to communicate at once the good news to their brethren, arose quickly, and hastened back to Jerusalem. But their footsteps, though winged with new hopes and ardent desires, would require some little time to measure off the seven and a half miles from Emmaus to Jerusalem. Meanwhile, the disciples at Jerusalem, not daring to venture out for fear of the Jews, and having nothing to call them away, would naturally continue reclining at the board, talking over the terrible experiences of the past few days, and the strange rumors of that very day, with which of course their minds would be wholly absorbed. It appears that they did so remain till the disciples from Emmaus arrived. And they still lingered in that position till the two had had time to tell that they had seen the Lord, and the others to say that they did not believe it, when, we may suppose, Jesus immediately appeared himself among them, to upbraid them with their unbelief and hardness of heart because they would not receive such testimony. Thus Mark would say that this was while “they sat at meat,” because, though the meal might have been finished some time before, they still reclined at the table, talking over the events of the day, and discussing these marvelous things. And this must have been at a point some way past the beginning of the second day. To recapitulate, we have John saying that “the same day at evening, being the first day of the week,” the disciples retired to their private common abode, and shut their doors for fear of the Jews. And this, so far as John’s narrative goes, is all that he asserts did take place on that first day. Then his narrative passes on to other events, the occurrence of which may easily have taken place on the second day. Turning to Mark’s narrative, we find that the interview of Jesus with the disciples was after the two had returned from Emmaus, which could hardly have been till after the evening, or dark part of the second day, had fully set in. “Spirit of Prophecy,” vol. 3, calls attention to this particular point in the narrative, and says that it was thus after dark. So the two records very pleasingly agree.