IMAGE TO THE BEAST: A REVIEW OF HORTON

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 14, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 37.

Read the full edition

IMAGE TO THE BEAST: A REVIEW OF HORTON.

BY A. SMITH.
The Third Angel’s Message as brought to view in Rev. 14: 9-11, is doubtless the most solemn warning given to man since his expulsion from Eden. When, therefore, as a matter of prophecy it becomes due in point of time, it would be no marvel if Satan, with his characteristic promptness, should attempt to counterfeit the message, and thus divert attention from the question at issue to a false position; or, to so confuse and disgust the masses as to compel a dismissal of the subject altogether, until the day passes as the chaff, and the fierce anger of the Lord falls upon them. The destruction of souls by all means, whether specious or forbidden, is the prime motive; and the seeds of error thus sown fall upon prolific soil in the hearts of all the semi-christianized, popular religious professors of our day.
Among the various expositions of the symbols of Rev. 13, so inseparable from the message of the third angel, I will, in this article, briefly notice one in particular, it being, perhaps, one of the most feasible and popular of all erroneous expositions of the prophecy under consideration. Rev. Richard Horton, in his “Image of The Beast,” a work of over two hundred pages, defines the ten-horned beast of Rev. 13: 1 as a symbol of the Roman Empire; the two-horned beast of verse 11 as a symbol of the Catholic Church; the image of the beast as symbolizing Free Masonry and its outgrowths; and the mark of the beast, as the signs, tokens, and marks made by that order. (See p. 45.) On the terms “image” and “mark,” Mr. Horton sufficiently refutes his own arguments in the following words:—
“The secret societies of our day are so many images of the beast [Roman Empire], more or less perfectly made, depending on their origin, object, power, and extent; and the members of these fraternities are the very men to make and receive the marks of the beast. Acting in harmony with the prophecy, and observing the true forms of idolatry, they make millions of marks.”—Id., pp. 214, 215.
I have emphasized certain terms in the foregoing quotation to invite particular attention to them. The prophecy does not say anything about images to the beast, but it speaks concerning “one image,” a term usually supposed to be singular in number; neither does the Bible in Rev. 13 and 14 say anything about marks or millions of marks, but it uses the terms “a mark,” “the mark,” “his mark,” etc., all of which we understand to be in the singular number.
Between the symbols of Dan. 7: 7 and Rev. 13: 1, etc., Mr. H. does not appear to draw any line of distinction; yet we learn by comparison of certain data, that the difference is quite specific. It will be noticed by a careful reading of Dan. 7: 7-26 that a great change takes place in the beast of verse 7, a little horn of marvelous pretensions arising among the ten horns, and subduing three of them. This horn is said to continue “until a time and times and the dividing of time,” which Bagster, Croly, Barnes, and Scott say is equal to 1260 years; and which, according to Croly, Barnes, Scott, and Clarke, are identical in point of duration with the forty-two months of Rev. 13: 5. I understand that the symbols of Dan. 7: 7, 8, more strictly represent the civil power of Rome, whether under pagan or papal domination; and the little horn of Dan. 7: 8 and the symbols of Rev. 12: 3 and 13: 1, 2, the religious elements of the same power.
The period of 1260 years represents only the domination of Rome under papal rule, while under the draconic form, it had existed from its founding by Romulus, about 748 B. C., though not noted in prophecy until 161 B. C., when Judea became a province of the empire.
Mr. H. takes the position, as the reader doubtless has noticed, that the ten-horned beast of Rev. 13: 1 is a symbol of the Roman Empire, and that the two-horned beast of verse 11 is a symbol of the Catholic Church. He claims that the 1260 years constitute the period of their united persecution of the saints. This period he dates from A. D. 606, when he says Phocas, the emperor, acknowledged the bishop of Rome to be universal bishop, or pope. But Scott, Bagster, Barnes, and the Cottage Bible claim that the little horn of Dan. 7: 8 symbolizes papal Rome; and its characteristics being like those of the beast of Rev. 13: 1, they must be identical. On this symbol (Rev. 13: 1-10) Scott expresses it as a certainty that the papacy is meant. To this agrees Croly, in his “Apocalypse,” p. 213.
On the period of 1260 years, I would say that though it may be a fact that the emperor Phocas acknowledged the supremacy of the Roman bishop in 606, it is quite certain that that supremacy had been conferred upon him by Justinian about seventy years before, or in A. D. 538. (See “Milman’s Gibbon’s Rome,” vol. 4, chap. 41, pp. 172, 173.) The act of Phocas, therefore, could only have been confirmatory, and not original. That the period of 1260 years is the time of united persecution of the saints by the Roman Empire and the papacy, as Mr. H. claims, is more easily asserted than proved. It is a more reasonable assumption that the period dates from and after the exaltation of the Roman bishop by the dragon of Rev. 13: 2.
It cannot be shown that the period claimed by Mr. H. was marked distinctly from that which preceded and followed it by persecution, much less that the Roman Empire as a civil power under its divided form united with the papacy in the persecution of the saints during that period. Facts to the contrary appear in the noble support which some of the nations of Europe have given to the Protestant cause since the Reformation, thus disproving Mr. Horton’s proposition on that point. In another article, I will give an exposition of the words “image” and “mark,” discussed in this review, more in harmony, I trust, with the Scriptures and facts of history.