BY EUGENE LELAND.
A LITTLE tract of forty-two pages, bearing the above heading, and written by James H. Potts, D. D., was recently scattered about the neighborhood where I had been holding a series of meetings, by the resident Methodist minister. Several notes of commendation were printed in the first part of the tract, and among them was one from Right Rev. Samuel Smith Harris, D. D., LL. D., Bishop of Michigan, containing the following expression concerning the tract:—
“It seems to me to be the most comprehensive and complete answer to Seventh-day Adventists that I have yet seen; while it is, at the same time, a most admirable discussion of the whole Sunday question.”
Although the book contains nothing new either in favor of Sunday or against the Bible Sabbath, yet being considered “the most comprehensive and complete answer to Seventh-day Adventists” met with by a man so distinguished as the Bishop of Michigan, it should receive a passing notice from S. D. Adventists, out of respect to a man who supports so many titles, if for nothing else.
One of the positions taken by our author (I say one of the positions, because it would be a difficult undertaking to defend the Sunday-Sabbath without taking several positions) is the “seventh-part-of-time” theory. I quote from a note by Dr. Raymond:—
“You make clear what, as I see it, is the main, essential thing, and the only thing of divine appointment; viz., in that one seventh of time is to be observed as holy rest.”
The author says: “The words ‘seventh day’ are every time directly connected with six work days. So the Sabbath law is, Work six days, and rest the seventh. One seventh of our time is to be sacred to God.”
Business men usually have regular hours for doing business, and people having business to transact with them expect to find them at their places of business during those hours. A physician advertises his office hours as being from 9 to 12 A. M., at which time you can get a diagnosis of your case. The bank is open from 2 to 4 P. M., and you can get your draft cashed during those hours. The minister keeps his Sabbath during one seventh part of time, and you can go to church then and listen to the sermon. To be sure, that may be a little indefinite to business men who are inclined to be exact about their appointments, but the minister understands it; so it must be all right.
If, as the doctor says, “one seventh of our time is to be sacred to God,” some one must decide which day of the seven shall be regarded as sacred. Now we would like to inquire, Who is to make this decision? If the author of the “Lord’s Day our Sabbath” is to do it, what assurance have we that every one else will be satisfied with his decision? If each is left to decide for himself which day he will regard as sacred, we might possibly have seven Sabbaths during the week. This arrangement might be agreeable to those who find fault with that part of the commandment which says, “Six days shalt thou labor;” but to those who have an honest desire to earn their bread by the sweat of their brow, and to keep the Sabbath “according to the commandment,” the matter might appear a little confused. But if the decision of the question is left to the Author of the Sabbath commandment, those who are sincere in their desire to know the truth will have no trouble in deciding that the seventh day is the Sabbath.
“The whole Christian world,” says our author, “maintains the use and obligation of Sunday on the ground of the law in the decalogue, and the satisfactory evidence in the New Testament that the day was changed to the first day of the week.”
This statement sounds very much as though the Doctor had taken another position; and an ordinary observer can hardly fail to notice that he has changed the time of his appointment somewhat. But this is no more than would naturally be expected from one who would appoint a religious meeting to be held on “one seventh part of time.” Think of the Saviour’s teaching his disciples to pray that their flight should not be in winter, nor on the seventh part of time; or of Paul’s reasoning in the synagogue every seventh part of time, as his manner was.
But we wish to notice the “satisfactory evidence in the New Testament,” spoken of by our author, “that the day was changed [from the seventh part of time] to the first day of the week.” He says:—
“Jesus taught his disciples many things that are not left on record, and his example in reference to the first-day Sabbath has substantially the force of a written commandment. Some people profess to be dissatisfied with the example alone, and ask for the express command; but this requirement is absurd.”
When our Saviour was led into the wilderness to be tempted of the Devil, we find that all the advances made by the arch-fiend were met with a positive “It is written;” and among the things that are written, is the statement that “man shall not live by bread alone, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of God.” Our author, when tempted by the same authority to maintain the observance of an institution which he admits has no written command to sustain it, deems it absurd that he should be called upon to point out the passage where it is written that he should observe the first day of the week, choosing rather to teach for doctrines the commandments of men than to live by every word of God.
But since the Doctor is so willing to rest his faith for the observance of Sunday on the example of our Saviour, it may be well to notice the examples which he has cited. He mentions three meetings which actually occurred, and states that three more first-days passed after the resurrection before the ascension, but does not know whether or not Christ met with his disciples on any or all of these days. Of course we can tell no more about the matter than can the Doctor; so these three “examples” of first-day observance count for nothing. In regard to the three meetings that actually did occur, we notice that the first one was held on the first day of the week. John 20:19. But it was not a religious meeting; for they were assembled “for fear of the Jews.” It was not at all significant that they should so meet; for they abode together. Acts 1:13. They had not met to commemorate Christ’s resurrection, for they did not believe he was risen (Mark 16:12–14); and as Christ said nothing by way of precept to show that they were thenceforth to observe the day as sacred, we conclude that he did not intend his disciples or any one else to consider this meeting as an example of first-day observance.
The second meeting occurred “after eight days” (John 20:26), which the Doctor says was the second first-day after the resurrection. The second first-day would occur on the seventh day after the first meeting was held; but to an ordinary mathematician the expression “after eight days,” without stating how long after, would mean the ninth day, at least, which was Tuesday. If any one can construe the “peace of a divine Sabbath” from such an “example” as this, he possesses a discernment of things that is truly marvelous.
The Doctor is quite brief in his comments on the third meeting to which he refers, merely stating that Christ appeared to his disciples at the Sea of Galilee, and giving the reference, John 21:1–14. He certainly intended to convey the idea that this meeting had some bearing on the question, or he would not have mentioned it; so let us proceed to notice this “example” of first-day observance. The record does not state upon what day of the week this meeting was held; but if it was on the first day, the manner in which the disciples were employed, goes to show that the “examples” of first-day observance which had already been set for them, did not rest with a great deal of weight upon their minds; and instead of rebuking them for disregarding his “examples,” Christ encouraged them in their work; for he commanded them to “cast the net on the right side of the ship.” It would seem that our disregard of these “examples” ought not to be considered absurd, when the disciples so soon forgot them.
But we notice another statement, showing the “satisfactory evidence in the New Testament that the day was changed:”—
“During the entire ministry of Paul, the disciples, following the clearly-indicated will of their Master, came together on the first day of the week to break bread, and to listen to the preaching of the gospel. Acts 20:7. Here we see how this first great Christian missionary, with other distinguished ministers and the church at Troas in A. D.p. 755 60, utterly ignored the seventh-day Sabbath, and kept the Lord’s day.”
In Acts 20:7 is a record of the only religious meeting ever held by the disciples on the first day of the week; and this was a night meeting. All that can be drawn from this passage in favor of first-day observance, is the example of the apostles in meeting together on that day. If that were all that is necessary to make a day sacred, there might possibly be some ground for an inference that this day should be so regarded, provided the apostles had continued the practice; but, so far from this, we find that it was Paul’s custom to meet for public worship on the Sabbath day, Dr. Potts to the contrary notwithstanding. By referring to Acts 13:14, 42, 44; 16:13; 17:1, 2; 18:1–4, 11, it will be seen that Paul met with the churches for public worship on the Sabbath no less than eighty-four times. Yet in the face of this fact, the author of “The Lord’s Day our Sabbath” has the presumption to say that Paul “utterly ignored the seventh-day Sabbath.” Evidently he did not know that these passages are in the Bible, or else thought the people did not know they were there.
Our author gives us a little instruction with reference to the institution of the Sabbath by way of a question and answer. He asks, “How did the seventh-day originate?” and gives the answer thus: “Briefly stated, its history is this: Moses gave it to the Israelites throughout their generations, partly as a sign between God and them, that its observance would mark them off from the idolatrous nations that surrounded them (Ex. 31:13, 14; Eze. 20:12), and partly as a commemoration of their deliverance from Egyptian bondage. Deut. 5:15.”
The commandment which requires the observance of the Sabbath says not one word about its being a sign between God and Israel for any purpose whatever, nor does it say one word to show that the Sabbath commemorated deliverance from Egyptian bondage; yet our author says, “Whether the Sabbath occur on the first day or seventh day, the law of God requires its observance.” And again, “Christians keep the commandments of God without exception. They keep the Sabbath commandment with especially conscientious care.” The fourth commandment contains the only reason found in the Bible for the institution or origin of the Sabbath; viz., “For in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day.”
Now there are just three things which we cannot understand: 1. How Christians can keep a “Sabbath commandment with especially conscientious care” on the first day of the week, when that commandment says as plainly as the English or any other language can make it, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God;” 2. How Christians can understand the same Sabbath commandment to require seventh-part-of-time observance of the patriarchs, seventh-day observance of the Jews, and first-day observance of Christians; 3. If the Sabbath “was for one nation, and one alone,” as our author says, we should like to understand how the command for its observance, given to that “one nation,” has anything to do with people generally, and with Dr. Potts in particular; more especially so when that command enjoins the observance of a different day from the one which the Doctor regards as sacred.
Not to oppose the Doctor on every point, we will agree with him that “the Lord’s day” is “our Sabbath;” but as the Son of man is Lord of the Sabbath day, and as the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord, we must conclude that the Lord’s day is the seventh day.