AdventAI

THE TEN KINGDOMS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 1., January 4, 1887

Of the two lines of prophecy (Daniel 2 and 7) which span entire the four great monarchies of this world,—Babylon, Medo-Persia, Greece, and Rome,—the first plainly intimates, and the second explicitly states, that the fourth and last would break up into ten other kingdoms, which kingdoms would continue in a brittle, divided condition, till the God of heaven should set up upon their ruins, for his own people, that great kingdom which shall never pass away.

As time rolled on, and what were once the anticipations of prophecy crystallized into the events of history, one of the most interesting epochs in the whole series would be that time when these ten kingdoms might be looked for to arise out of the Roman Empire. This point at once engages the attention of the student of prophecy; and no interpretation can show itself entitled to favor which does not make plain the fulfillment of this specification.

When the era of prophetic light dawned upon the world, as the great doctrine of the near coming of the Son of man became present truth, the prophecies were examined as never before, and the pages of history scanned with a thoroughness and minuteness never before given them, in an enthusiastic search for the fulfillments of God’s word. The movement was symbolized by the mighty angel of Rev. 10, coming down to utter his solemn oath by sea and land that time should be no more; and the Spirit of God was wonderfully present to quicken the understandings of the humble seekers after truth, and to lead to new unfoldings of light and knowledge, which were both a surprise and joy.

We cannot doubt that on all the great features of the prophecies the light brought forth by the great Advent movement marked a new epoch in prophetic knowledge. When Adventists came to look for the development of the ten kingdoms, they found that while all who had paid any attention to the subject agreed that ten kingdoms had arisen out of the Roman Empire, there was some variation in the enumeration of these kingdoms by different writers. It can scarcely be a matter of surprise that there should be some differences between persons writing on the prophecies before the age of prophetic light had come, before the book had been unsealed, and the world had reached the time when knowledge was to be increased and the wise to understand.

Sifting all the views suggested, and weighing all the evidence and testimony from their point of view, Adventists speedily came to a unanimous agreement in regard to the ten kingdoms. The ones which they adopted as fulfilling the prophecy were these: 1. The Huns; 2. The Ostrogoths; 3. The Visigoths; 4. The Franks; 5. The Vandals; 6. The Suevi; 7. The Heruli; 8. The Burgundians; 9. The Anglo-Saxons; and, 10. The Lombards.

These were considered the ten kingdoms of the prophecy all through the great Advent movement of 1840–1844, or through the first and second messages. They stood the test of the severest opposition and criticism of that time. And this has been the unanimous view thus far during the third message. Is it now to be shown that a view developed under these circumstances and cherished all these years, has all the while been erroneous and must now be changed? Such a contingency is beginning to be urged. It is claimed that the Huns should not be counted as one of the ten kingdoms, but in their place the Alemanni should be reckoned. It is with reference to this point solely that we wish to speak. As this is the only change proposed, our field of inquiry need not be a very extensive one: it will relate simply to the comparative claims of the Huns and Alemanni to be reckoned among the ten kingdoms that arose at the breaking up of the old Roman Empire. We object most decidedly to the proposed innovation. We think the old prophetic way-mark of now nearly or quite half a century’s standing, is the one still to be entertained.

The differences that are found to exist respecting the enumeration of the ten kingdoms seem to be owing largely to difference of views respecting the territory out of which the ten kingdoms were to be formed, and the era at which they were to arise. A word on these points may therefore first be in place. The ten kingdoms must arise out of the Western Empire. This point is so generally conceded that it is not necessary to argue it here. But this would correct the enumeration of such as would bring in the Eastern Empire, or any part of it, as one or more of the ten kingdoms.

The Roman Empire in its broadest extent embraced all the then civilized world in opposition to that of the numerous tribes of barbarians which surrounded it on the north and east. These nations becoming active and aggressive, the Roman emperors soon discovered the difficulty of defending so extensive frontiers, and began to contract their limits. Hadrian abandoned the provinces east of the Euphrates, and in A. D. 274 Aurelian evacuated Dacia, north of the Danube. From that time the Rhine and the Danube constituted the northern and north-eastern boundaries of that portion of territory which belonged to the Western Empire. For the ten kingdoms, then, we are to look in territory west of Greece, and southwest of the Upper Danube and the Rhine.

The era at which they were to arise is also defined with nearly equal definiteness. They must all be developed by the beginning of the sixth century; for in the early part of that century, A. D. 538, the papal horn had come up among the ten, having previously plucked up three of them to make way for itself. We look, consequently, for the ten kingdoms in Western Europe previous to A. D. 538.

Placing ourselves back, therefore, in imagination in the last days of Roman unity, what do we behold?—The vast empire grown rich, luxurious, corrupt, and so degenerate and ready to decay. On the north and east, like a tumultuous bank of rolling storm-clouds, hover hordes of wild and restless barbarians. The time approaches for the dismemberment of the empire; and according to the prophecy we look for the ten kingdoms to arise out of the disrupted fragments. Our eyes naturally seek for those nations, as fulfilling the prophecy, which become the proximate cause of the division and downfall of Rome to which the prophecy points.

A huge barbaric giant away in the interior of Asia, at length arouses himself, and turns his steps westward, where degenerate Rome invites an easy conquest, and offers unlimited spoil. Other nations succumb to his power, or fly from his presence as the dove flees from the devouring hawk. This giant was the nation of the Huns; and other tribes had no alternative but to be crushed by them, or flee before them. Those who did not yield fled, and thus by the Huns they were precipitated like an all-devastating flood across the boundaries of the Roman Empire. Kœppen, in his “History of the Middle Ages” (i, 58), gives a general view of this revolution in the following words:—

“But the Germanic nations who separately had been vanquished and repelled by Roman discipline, began during the third century to form large confederacies of kindred tribes: the Franks on the lower, and the Alemanni (all men) on the upper, Rhine; the Quadi, Marcomanni, and Boiarii (Bavarians) on the Danube; the Visigoths, Ostrogoths, and Gepidae on the Pontus. Like the waves of the tempestuous ocean against the opposing dikes, they continued their attacks against the weakened and demoralized empire with various success, until, in the year 376, the Huns, from the Volga, subdued all the eastern Germanic and Sclavonic nations, and uniting with them, fell upon the more western tribes, and forced them by a mighty, simultaneous effort to cross the rivers, and to seek new settlements in the civilized provinces of the South. Thus the sudden appearance of the Huns in A. D. 375 is the signal for the general irruption of the Germans and the dismemberment of the Roman Empire.”

It will be quite important to a proper understanding of the subject before us, to learn something of the origin of this nation which gave the signal for, and acted so important a part in, the fulfillment of the prophecy concerning the downfall of Rome. Sheppard, in his work on “The Fall of Rome,” pp. 147, 148, speaking of the barbarian races which surrounded and finally overwhelmed the Roman Empire, says:—

“But beyond the Teuton, beyond the Slave, beyond the limits almost of what was deemed the habitable world, lay another world of barbarism, more wild and terrible still. The steppes of Northern and Central Asia have from immemorial time projected on the West vast hordes of hardy horsemen, attracted by the charms of a softer climate and more fertile land. They belonged to the great Turanian or Mongol family of nations, terms not exactly identical; for Dr. Latham has observed that as a linguistic appellative, the former has a larger range; whereas in anthropology the second is the wider class. . . . Four great divisions of this family have played a conspicuous if not a lasting part upon the theater of the world—conspicuous for devastation and for blood. The Mongols proper, the Fins, the Turks, and the Ugrians, have arisen from time to time as a marvel or a terror to the Western world. Of one of these formidable races, and their still more formidable leader, we shall soon have occasion to speak at length. Attila, king of the Huns, has won for himself a name in history which stands beside that of Cæsar and Napoleon, though unillumined by the light of posthumous glory which gilds the memory of those children of victory. To the ecclesiastical writers of succeeding times, he appeared, as Thierry has called him, as an emissary of Providence, a Messiah of misery and suffering and ruin, sent to chastise the crimes of Rome. In their imaginations, excited by mysticism and suffering, his personality was merged in his mission, and they affixed to him the name of the ‘Scourge of God,’ by which he has ever since been known to the Christian world. Like a destroying angel he came and went from the great wall of China to the Atlantic Ocean; and where that terrible deluge of horsemen had once passed, nothing was left but a confused débris of the civilization it had overwhelmed; no roof tree remained standing; no grass was ever seen to grow; the land was as a howling wilderness, ungladdened by the sight of ‘flocks or herds, or human face divine.’ The hearts of men between the Volga and the Pyrenees quailed for generations after his death at the thought of Attila the destroyer, and three separate streams of tradition have brought down to modern Europe the terrors of that memorable name. The Huns will serve for us as an ethnological type of all those tribes of Turanian stock—Avars, Bulgarians, Turks—who appeared each with more appalling aspect than the other from behind the Ural Mountains and the Caspian Sea, on the frontiers of the falling empire.”

On page 173, Mr. Sheppard again says:—

“Our purpose does not require that we should particularize every incident in the relations of Rome to the external world between the final subjugation of Britain by Agricola (A. D. 85), when she may be regarded as most strong, and the passage of the Danube by the Visigoths (A. D. 376), when she was already on the brink of ruin. During this long period, the barbarian world, like a cauldron, seething and foaming with its waters in a strange agitation, dashed race against race, throwing up some to the surface, and overwhelming others in a vortex of strife. The Alans appear in the East and assail the Parthian Empire, which calls upon its ancient rival for aid. The Da-p. 10cians cross the Danube, and are bought off by the gold of Domitian. Far in the depths of Central Asia the Huns begin to stir and divide into two great hordes. On the shores of the Baltic the ocean quits its bed, and produces a physical convulsion, which results in a like disturbance and displacement of the surrounding tribes. Sarmatians, Marcomanni, Quadi, Vandals, are forced southward, and, spreading far and wide, overleap the natural barriers which guard the sacred soil of Italy, and appear under the walls of Aquileia. Marcus Aurelius dies combatting the last-named tribe. Soon the Franks are seen for the first time on the Rhine. In the year 241 A. D., the great Aurelian, the future conqueror of the East, overthrows them at Mayence. . . . About the middle of the third century the terrible Goths are for the first time seen in force upon the frontier. . . . In 271 A. D., Aurelian allows the Goths to settle in trans-Danubian Dacia, and the name of Roman Dacia is henceforward confined to part of Moesia, south of the great river. The assaults of barbarism come thick and fast. The Alemanni, a Teuton tribe, force their way into Italy and overrun the Umbrian plains. The danger becomes too obvious to be neglected, and the emperor, Probus, constructs that gigantic but ineffectual rampart described in a previous lecture.”*

Speaking of the timid policy of Probus, in granting the Franks land in Gaul, as Aurelian had granted to the Goths in Dacia, he brings us down to A. D. 358, when a body of the Frankish confederation, receding before the barbarous Quadi, crossed the Rhine, and obtained a location in Brabant, and then adds:—

“We have now reached the period when historians universally agree that the first great and permanent impulse toward its downfall was given by barbarism to the fabric of Roman power. Before this era there had been irruptions, settlements, and conflicts; but they were partial, of a more local character, without any large and lasting influence upon the destinies of the empire. . . . But the passage of the Danube by the west Goths, in the year 376 A. D., was an event of a different character; for, from that time Rome never recovered her imperial prestige; while the barbarian nations steadily advanced to the position of powerful and independent kingdoms.

“At the period of which we are writing . . . the north-east of Europe, all the great Russian steppes to the foot of the Ural Mountains, were occupied by the Turanian tribes, known as Fins or Zoumi, who were unceasingly recruited by exhaustless hordes sweeping ever onward from the wilds of Tartary. . . . Of the existence of these outermost barbarians the Romans had some small notion in the first century, but little more. A few vague words of Tacitus describe the Fenni or Fins as a race of marvelous ferocity, utterly destitute of all that constitutes the wealth of civilized life, clad in skins, feeding on the grass of the field, and living by the use of arrows which they pointed with fish bones for want of iron. Yet it was one of these wild races which proximately caused the fall of Rome. As early as the second century of our era, the geographer Ptolemy mentions the appearance of the Χοῦνοι, or, as the Latins called them, the Hunni, among the Slavic populations on the banks of the Dnieper; and another writer speaks of them as camping between the Caucasus and the Caspian Sea, from which inaccessible locality they extended their plundering raids into Asia Minor. This federation of Nomad robbers appears to have gathered strength and consistency during the next hundred and fifty years. In the fourth century we find them on both slopes of the Ural chain, extending nearly from the north pole to the Caspian, and ravaging at their will Europe on the one side and Asia on the other. Jornandes, the Gothic historian of this period, or, more correctly, the abridger of the great work of Cassiodorus upon the annals of his countrymen, tells us in his characteristic style that the stem of the Hunnic stock ‘budded forth into two infuriated branches.’ Of these, the eastern branch, much less hideous than the other, say the Greek historians, gave to themselves the appellation of White Huns. Their locality was the neighborhood of the Caspian Sea. The western, or Black Huns, turned toward Europe. M. Thierry, unwilling to plunge into the labyrinth of doubt and conjecture in which modern learning has lost itself more than once upon this subject, states, nevertheless, his conviction that the ‘domination Hunnique’ included the Turkish tribes toward the east, the Fins on the west and a sovereign Mongol race much more decidedly Asiatic in its attributes than the Fins. It is at least, as we have already seen, under an exaggerated form of the Mongol type that contemporary history describes Attila and his formidable horsemen.”

Kœppen (“History of the Middle Ages,” pp. 73, 74) gives the following account of the origin and first movements of the Huns:—

“The empire of the Huns—Hunni—had not yet obtained at the time we here describe [middle of the fourth century], the immense extent which it acquired afterward; but almost immediately on the appearance of the Hunnish monsters on the Volga, one nation sank before them after the other; they overran the greater part of Sarmatia and Scythia, and penetrated into the heart of Gaul. Some have held the Huns to be the Chinese tribe Hiong-nu; but this is erroneous. They were a mighty nomadic people of Mongol race, quite different from the inhabitants of Southern Asia (Tartars) and Europe (Pelasgi). They were Chunni (Hunni), of Ugrian race, kindred to the Hungarians from Mount Oural. The Ugri are of Finnish or Chudish descent, and so are both the Huns and the Hungarians, with the difference, however, that the Huns have an admixture of the Mongol or Calmuco, while the Magyars have more Turkish blood in their veins. . . . The Black Huns, the true Ugrians from Mount Oural, starting from their dreary table lands (Siberia) in 374, suddenly appeared on the Volga, where they overthrew the Alani, and, in a single battle on the banks of the Thanais, destroyed the mighty empire of the Ostrogoths. The Goths are subdued; the chiefs of the proud and princely race of Amali serve the Hunnish conqueror; all the lands east of the Theiss and the Danube are devastated. A general panic has taken possession of the many Sarmatic, Turkish, Chudish, and Germanic tribes on the plains of Sarmatia; many flee Westward to the Rhine. Alani, Suevi, Vandals, and Burgundians form their immense camps on the Upper Danube; the terrified Visigoths have already crossed that river and inhabit Moesia; and thus the Huns in 380 roam victoriously over those immense regions, and live on the spoils of the Gepidae, Scyri, Heruli, and other Germanic nations who follow their banner. The borders of their empire under King Balamir, seem to have been the river Tibiscus (Theiss) on the West; how far it extended north is not to be decided. On the south it was bounded by Mount Caucasus, the Black Sea, and the Danube; on the east it stretched away far into the interior of Siberia.”

On p. 78, he speaks of the “Magyars, the Ugri, and Hungari or Hungarians, all Finno-Turkish tribes on the north-western slope of Mount Oural.” The reader is requested to note these facts, as they have a bearing on the subsequent development of the prophecy.

The first movement of the Huns toward the empire is thus stated by Sheppard, p. 183:—

“The Huns first came in contact [374 A. D.] with the Alans, a pastoral people who inhabited the steppe between the Volga and the Don. Incapable of offering any effectual resistance, the Alans united themselves to the immense hordes which formed the invading army, and then this ‘tempest of nations,’ as Jornandes calls them, burst upon the Ostrogoth Empire. The old king, unable to sustain the ignominy of defeat, stabbed himself to the heart: the nation were compelled to submit. It was next the turn of the Visigoths.” Then follows an account of the fleeing of the Visigoths across the Danube into Roman territory, which it is not necessary here to quote.

This passage of the Danube by the Visigoths has already been spoken of as a shock to the imperial prestige of Rome from which she never recovered; and the cause of this event is easily gathered from the foregoing statements. This, however, is more directly stated by Sheppard on p. 189 of his work:—

“It was, as we have seen, the inroad of the Hunnish hordes which precipitated the Ostrogoths upon the Visigoths, and the latter upon the Eastern empire.”

But this movement of the Huns had its effect in the West as well as in the East. On p. 190 Mr. S. further says:—

“But though they did not directly turn their own arms against Italy or Constantinople, their advent was the indirect cause of formidable and permanent encroachments upon the imperial territory. The tribes whom they displaced, appear to have gathered, as it were, into two great bodies, and projected themselves by different routes upon those regions of the civilized world where they hoped to win subsistence by their swords. One immense army, consisting of 200,000 warriors, crossed the Tyrolese Alps under Radagaisus, and made straight for the gates of Florence. Sitting down before the city, they attempted to besiege it, but from want of strategic skill were soon themselves cut off and beleaguered by the forces of Stilicho. . . . The fortunes of the other division were more prosperous. A great multitude, composed of Burgundians, Vandals, Alans, and Suevi, burst over the Rhine, easily overcoming the feeble resistance offered by the Ripuarian Franks. They speedily made the whole country the prey of their bow and spear, and after dividing it among themselves, crossed the Pyrenees and founded the first barbarian kingdom in the Iberian Peninsula. This is the invasion of which Gibbon declares that it sealed the fate of Roman civilization, because the tribes composing it never retraced their steps.”

And let it ever be borne in mind that of all these movements, the Huns were the immediate and exciting cause. Their connection with Rome soon became more intimate and direct. Pannonia, as we have seen, was one of the eastern provinces of Western Rome. The territory was that which forms a portion of modern Hungary west of the Danube. This province came into possession of the Huns, and was for some years the seat of their kingdom. Sheppard, p. 189, thus speaks of this event:—

“Aëtius, the Roman patrician, in an evil hour availed himself of the aid of the Hunnish chieftain Rona, in the confusion which ensued in the West upon the death of Honorius. The Huns were not actually engaged in any conflict, but they claimed Pannonia as their reward, nor did Aëtius dare to refuse. Along with the province, he conferred upon the Hun the title of ‘General of the Roman armies,’ and disguised the degradation of a large yearly tribute under the name of ‘military pay.’ Hence the connection in their early life between Attila, the nephew of Rona, and the Roman Aëtius, and the anomaly that Attila, the most terrible adversary of Rome, should have been a titular commander of her forces.” See also Gibbon, who speaks of them as the founders of a formidable empire (iii, 16), and declares that they “urged the rapid downfall of the Roman Empire.”—Id., p. 386.

(To be continued.)

Notes

  1. *This was a wall commencing at Ratisbon on the Danube, and continuing over hill, valley, river, and morass, for two hundred miles, till it touched the Rhine. The remains of it are still known as “The Devil’s Wall.” ↩