A PROPHET’S SUCCESSION LOST.
‘A VERY comical exposure of “Eddyism,” or of what is ambitiously called, by its votaries, “Christian Science,” is found in the Religio-Philosophical Journal, a paper which concerns itself with matters which crystallize along the junction planes of religion, superstition, and fraud, and where the claims and exposures of Spiritualism all have equal record. Our readers will recall that the prophetess of the new Christian Science, which regards disease as sin, and heals sickness by faith; is Mrs. Eddy, of Boston, now over seventy years old. The Rev. William I. Gill, formerly a Methodist minister in New Jersey, a man of a good deal of ability, and a writer on philosophical subjects, not very long ago went over to a semi-Unitarianism, and became a resident of the vicinity of Boston. We next hear of him as attracted by this Christian Science, and petted by Mrs. Eddy, and made pastor of the “Church of Christ” (Advent, Scientist and Eddyite) in Boston. Here he was brought into close contact with Mrs. Eddy, and his first impression of her and her followers was exceedingly favorable, as he says in a long statement in the Religio-Philosophical Journal. She teaches her disciples to believe all ailments to be unnecessary violations of law, and that by divine grace they can be removed. They are made as little of as possible, and are not to be talked about. Mr. Gill soon found in the upper circle of the body, with all their cheerfulness and spirituality, an under-current of the world in the scheming for the succession to Mrs. Eddy. She herself said she had been anxiously looking for a man to be her successor. Many good ministers had been invited into her class in the hopes that they would turn out to be divinely anointed to the office, but they had all failed. At last Mr. Gill himself was taken up as a hopeful candidate for her mantle. He was told that the position of the second in founding a great church, was a great honor; that he could prepare Mrs. Eddy’s memoir, and have the profits; that her book, so she confidentially told him, was now yielding her $12,000 a year, and all would be his as chief of the great cause; that he would be head of “the college” and of the whole growing community. He was now put under close espionage, and all reports of his doings and sayings were carried to the college, where he was subject to inquiry and correction. He was now editor of the Christian Science Journal, and defender of the theories. During this time, he says, he was a full believer in Mrs. Eddy, and published things under this influence, which he then believed, but which he now sees were cruel and slanderous. He had all along been disturbed by the fanaticism of her followers; but now he found that he was not regarded as sufficiently servile in preaching Mrs. Eddy, and that she herself wished and expected profound flattery and homage. She had quarreled with every one of the very many editors of her paper, because they were not willing enough to comply with her demands for flattery, and for the most virulent abuse of others. What Mr. Gill says first awoke him to an understanding of the case, were the signs of blind and malicious bigotry, and their “systematic depreciation of everything in God’s universe before their time and outside of their influence.” Meanwhile Mr. Gill published a book, “Philosophical Realism,” which did not give satisfaction, and the suspicion of it grew to open hostility when Mr. Gill showed one of Mrs. Eddy’s devoted disciples a letter he had received from an esteemed correspondent, who said that this book would be of great benefit to Christian Science, and that he “had received from two weeks’ study of it more benefit than from eighteen months’ study of Mrs. Eddy’s book.” Of course this was repeated to Mrs. Eddy, and she was turned against the book. She argued with him against the book, told him it was philosophically wrong, and begged him, when she could not convince him, to take her word for it. He declined to be thus dictated to, and they parted, she writing him a letter demanding absolute submission of intellect and conscience, and saying: “Yours is human philosophy. Mine is divine philosophy, without a human taint, that cannot be misguided.” Here Mr. Gill, who had swallowed so much, refused to gulp further, and gave up the hope of being the successor of the prophetess, and of her magnificent income. He now thinks that “the Olympian summit” of the Christian Scientist’s divine fervor “has an interior connection direct with Tartarus,” and his disenchantment is complete. We only wonder how a man of sense could ever be so deluded; but we remember that skepticism is the fertile mother of the grossest delusions.—The Independent.