Having now noticed Mr. Ward’s attempt to do away with the original Sabbath, we next have to look at the manoeuvers by which he would put into its place a new institution, which he calls the Christian Sabbath. We have seen that the results of his efforts to tear down the Sabbath have been in every possible way, and at every turn, to either pervert or nullify the sacred record. In the still harder job of trying to erect a new Sabbath, the reader must have a curiosity to witness the fantastic tricks he will play before high heaven.
We will not stop to notice such misstatements as that it was the moral law that was “added . . . till the seed should come.” The coming of the seed did not change the relation of the moral law in any respect. Nor do we need to pause at such quibbles as that Christ did not come to “destroy” the law; but he did come to “fulfill” it; and fulfilling it was “taking it out of the way,” or destroying it. Men may write as much nonsense of their own as they choose; but we implore them not to make such nonsense of the words of Christ.
The idea of creation is so inseparably associated with the Sabbath, that there must be something of this sort provided for the first-day Sabbath; and this is the way Mr. W. seeks to find it. He says that man lost the image of God in the fall; that it is Christ’s work to restore this; and this is “called a new creation”! and now, without any further argument, comes the profound conclusion that “the first-day Sabbath is as fitting a memorial of finished creation as was the day that God blessed at the close of the creative week”! But hold! did Christ finish the work of restoring the lost image on the cross? We are referred to Col. 3:9, 10 and Eph. 4:24, as testimony for this “new creation;” but we had supposed that this work—the work of God’s grace on the hearts of sinners—had been going on ever since Christ’s day, and that it was still going on. If so, then the work of this creation is not yet finished, and hence cannot yet have any memorial. But what does he mean by the “close of the creative week”? for he has told us that the seventh day is not yet ended; that God is still resting, and will rest, till he begins some other creation. But the week cannot end till this seventh day has ended. He may say that the work of creation has ended; but this is not the end of the “week,” unless the week is confined to the time of the actual work of creation, and then we have a week of only six days; but the impression everywhere prevails that the week consists of seven days.
He evidently thinks he has struck a brilliant idea here, and so he expatiates upon it further, as follows:—
“During the work of the ‘new creation’ darkness reigned from the sixth to the ninth hour, as at creation’s morn; and when the work was finished, ‘he rested from his work as God did from his.’ So the Christian Sabbath is the rest of the new creation.”
A number of queries are suggested by this singular statement:—
1. How long was Christ engaged in the work of this “new creation”? Was it only during the time that he hung upon the cross, from the third hour till somewhere past the ninth hour? And how long was this rest after his work was finished? We must know these particulars, or we cannot tell what proportion the “rest” bears to the “work,” and hence cannot tell what proportion of time we should rest in commemoration thereof. If his work was only six hours, from the third to the ninth hour, to keep the right proportion between labor and rest, he should have rested only one hour, and we should do the same! We are left all in the fog here, in regard to the proportion of time we should rest under this new arrangement. But—
2. At what time was his rest taken? He finished the work, did he not, according to Mr. W.’s view, on the cross? He spent considerably more than one full day in the tomb; but Mr. W. will not have it that he began to rest till his resurrection on the first day of the week! What about that intervening time, during which he was resting in the tomb? The question is left again in a bad muddle here.
How does it happen that we are to keep just one day to commemorate this work? Did Christ rest just that Sunday on which he arose? Was that day any different from many others of the forty days before his ascension? If this was a rest, were not they? and why, then, should we confine the new Sabbath to just one day? Thus we find nothing but chaos in this whole attempted argument.
As another supposed pillar for first-day observance, we are treated to this assertion:—
“The sheaf of the wave offering (Lev. 23:11) was waved before the Lord, on the first day of the week, a day of holy convocation.”
Does he mean to say that the first day of the week, as such, was ever regarded as a holy day among the Jews? Such is his assertion; but any one knows that it is not true. Does he mean to say that that festival of the wave sheaf came every year on the same day of the week? So he asserts; but every one knows that that is not, and cannot be, so. Does it not say, it will perhaps be asked, that the sheaf was to be waved on “the morrow after the sabbath”?—Yes; but what Sabbath?—The passover sabbath, which always came on the 15th day of the month, without regard to the day of the week. And on the morrow after that sabbath, that is, on the 16th day of the month, without regard to the day of the week, the sheaf was waved.
Following out the same error, he makes the day of Pentecost come always on the first day of the week; but there is not a word of truth in it. Such a blunder should bring the blush to the cheek of any man, much more to one who has set himself up as a teacher on Biblical questions.
Again he says: “When redemption’s work was done, the priesthood and the law were changed, ‘for the priesthood being changed, there is made of necessity a change also of the law.’ Heb. 7:12.”
By the work of redemption being done, he means the work of Christ on the cross; and we have often tried to imagine what kind of a state a man’s mind must be in, what ideas he must have of the work of Christ, and what sort of a view he must take of the plan of salvation, to betray him into the thought and the assertion that redemption was finished on the cross. How crude and limited must be the ideas of such a mind. What does redemption embrace?—The bestowal of immortality upon all the saved to the very last one, and the redemption of the purchased possession, or the bringing in of the new earth to be the everlasting abode of the righteous. Eph. 1:14; 2 Pet. 3:13; Rev. 21:5. And since redemption is not yet completed, all this talk about redemption’s work being done, commemorating redemption’s completed work, etc., betrays a most lamentable ignorance of God’s word and his purposes, and is the supremest folly.
At length Mr. W. finds the expression “change of the law,” in Heb. 7:12; and he falls into such glee over it that he loses his wits entirely. He says:—
“Notice, a change of the priesthood necessitated a change also of the law.”
Then, as if there was no law but the Sabbath law, and no change to be made except in that, he proceeds almost in the same breath to add:—
“The law of the Sabbath under the Mosaic was the seventh day with the sacrifice of lambs, but the law was changed.”
We also will ask the reader to notice something in this connection, and that is that Paul in Heb. 7 is talking about the priesthood and that alone; but the law of the priesthood was not the moral law of ten commandments. What had that law to do with the question of the priesthood?—Nothing whatever. But what was the law regulating the priesthood?—It was that the earthly priesthood should be confined to the order of Levi. Heb. 7:11. How, then, could our Lord be a priest, since he did not belong to the tribe of Levi? Answer: That law might be changed; and before the Levitical priesthood could give place to the priesthood of our Lord after the order of Melchisedec, that law must be changed; and for that purpose it was changed. Let any one read the three verses, 12, 13, and 14, of Heb. 7, and risk, if he dare, his reputation for common intelligence by denying this proposition: “For the priesthood being changed, there is made of necessity a change also of the law; for he [Christ] of whom these things are spoken pertaineth to another tribe [than that of Levi], of which no man gave attendance at the altar. For it is evident that our Lord sprang out of Judah; of which tribe Moses spake nothing concerning priesthood.”
Thus he shows how our Lord can legitimately act as priest, though he was from the tribe of Judah—it was because the law confining the priesthood to Levi had been changed. But what had this change in the law of the priesthood to do with the Sabbath?—Not the least shadow of anything.
But the reader don’t yet begin to comprehend the changes which, according to Mr. W., then took place. In the light of the fact that Paul says it was only a change in the law of the priesthood, look at the following ridiculous list of changes which our theologian assures us then took place. He says:—
“The day was changed, the worship was changed, the covenant was changed, the mediator was changed, time was changed in its reckoning from A. M. to A. D., the day from evening and morning to morning and evening or midnight to midnight (Mark 16:9).”
We should be glad to have Mr. W. receive the truth and adopt legitimate and reasonable expositions of scripture; but if he is determined not to do this, it is much better for the cause of truth that he should go to such lengths as to make himself utterly ridiculous, as he does in the foregoing quotation. He says the reckoning of time was changed from A. M. to A. D.; but there was no reckoning of time by A. M. before that to be changed; and the reckoning by A. D. was not invented till in the sixth century after Christ, and was not adopted till in the eighth century! and the reckoning of the day from midnight to midnight was in use in the old pagan Roman Empire long anterior to the days of Christ. See Hale’s “Analysis of Chronology.” But Mr. W. has all these changes made at the cross, and made, forsooth, because the law of the Jewish priesthood was changed! If any man claiming to be in his right mind, ever penned anything more utterly destitute of the first principles of common sense, we should be pleased to see it.
But perhaps we are a little too fast; for here comes another argument which may, perhaps, be set down as equal, if possible, to the other. He argues that because the change from the Levitical to the Melchisedec priesthood occasioned a change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week, the original change from the Melchisedec to the Levitical priesthood in the days of Moses, must have been the occasion of a change from the first to the seventh day. We know this will seem to the reader like a misrepresentation, hence it is necessary to quote the sentence. He says:—
“If a change of the priesthood from the Levitical to the order of the Melchisedec necessitated a change of the law, did not the change of the original Melchisedec to the Levitical necessitate a change also of the law?”
He does not say that this change was from the first day back to the seventh, but it must be so or there is no point to the suggestion, and so with that adroit insinuation he leaves it; for his next sentence reads:—
“Then we establish the fact that the first day of the week has been the Sabbath of the world from Adam until now, except the fifteen hundred years of the Mosaic dispensation.”
A more groundless assumption was never invented than the idea that the Sabbath was changed from the first day of the week back to the seventh day. The commandment that God uttered from Sinai, in accordance with which the Israelites kept the seventh day, made that day identical with the day which God sanctified in the beginning. To deny this, and claim that the days were different, is to deny point blank the fourth commandment, and is more wicked than it is idiotic, in a professedly Christian teacher.
He falls into the common error of asserting that “the atonement was finished on the sixth day,” that is, on the cross. Then Universalism is true; for Christ bore the sins of the whole world on the cross. He ought to examine the subject of the priesthood enough to learn that the atonement is the last work of the priest, not the first.
Again he says: “He [Christ] laid [1] in the tomb the seventh day. The seventh-day Sabbath ended that day.” Page 20. But we have always been taught, and he himself teaches (p. 22), that the Sabbath ended at the cross,—was among the things nailed to it, and taken out of the way; and, indeed, if it has ended at all it ended there; but now he doesn’t have it end till the day following. How is this? On this point he is very careful not to quote Luke 23:55, 56, which states positively that the holy women, Christ’sp. 153 intimate disciples, knew that the seventh-day Sabbath had not ended then, but kept it “according to the commandment.”
He next resorts to the Greek dodge, claiming that the Greek of the New Testament calls the first day of the week the Sabbath, or the “first of the Sabbaths.” This has been so often examined that it need not be repeated here. The reader is referred to a little tract, “A Greek Falsehood,” published at this Office, which contains a full exposure of the ignorance or dishonesty of those who try to use the Greek in that way.
And lastly he reiterates the old, stale falsehoods about the testimony of the Fathers. Pliny says that on a “stated day” the Christians assembled and sang hymns to Christ as God, etc. Mr. W. here slips in, in marks of parenthesis, “Sunday.” But Pliny says nothing about Sunday. This Sunday-keepers have to put in for themselves, thus assuming the very point to be proved. In reference to other testimony we will simply remind the reader that Mr. Ward knows the facts in the case; for he has had Andrews’ “History of the Sabbath,” in which the points are all proved, and references given. And what, then, does he know? He knows that Ignatius never wrote anything about Sunday calling it the Lord’s day; he knows that Irenæus never gave any such testimony; he knows that Dionysius never testified to anything in regard to Sunday; he knows that Melito of Sardis never did; he knows that Clement does not apply the term “Lord’s day” to Sunday, but to the heavenly state; and he knows that Origen, in the third century, only applies the term “Lord’s day” to the “eighth day,” making it as a national day, simply a festival like the passover and Pentecost, and as a mystic day referring to the whole Christian life. And these are all the writers ever quoted on this subject, except Justin Martyr, who does not use the term “Lord’s day” at all, and Theophilus, who utters not a single word of what is attributed to him in reference to Sunday. Yet Mr. W. says that all the ones he names, and “a host of others,” declare that the resurrection day was the day they kept as a “day of worship,” and was “the Sabbath of the Lord Jesus Christ.”
What shall we think of a man who in the very face of the testimony, will deliberately falsify in order to deceive those whom he presumes are not prepared to dispute his assertions? If he has no regard for his own reputation, has he no regard at all for truth? We pass no judgment upon him, but leave him to study for himself the words of the Lord by the prophet Ezekiel, in chap. 13:8, 19: “Therefore thus saith the Lord God; because ye have spoken vanity, and seen lies, therefore, behold, I am against you, saith the Lord God.” “And will ye pollute me among my people, . . . by your lying to my people that hear your lies?” The reader would do well to take his concordance and look up, in this connection, the whole testimony of the Bible on the subject of lying. It is directly applicable to this case.