BY ELD. A. O. TAFT.
One of the cloaks underneath which much error is hiding now-a-days, is the idea that a man has a right to believe as he pleases. We certainly have a right to search for evidence, and believe anything for which there is a sound reason upon which to base our belief; but to take some pet notion, and, just because we desire to have it so, say that we believe it and therefore it is “true to us if we are only sincere in our belief,” is a fatal delusion. A reason for our sincere belief in any theory is the first and necessary thing, and is much more important than our sincerity. God says, “Let us reason together” (Isa. 1:18); and those who are deluded into the idea that they can believe just what they please regardless of reason, will have to meet this statement in the Judgment. Then they may be terrified to see that their greatest object in this life was to gratify their own desires, and to move in the popular current; and that in order to stifle the promptings of conscience, they tried to hide behind the excuse that “only to believe is all that is necessary,” and that “we have a right to believe as we please.”
We have no right to believe contrary to fact and evidence. A man living in a red house has no right to believe it is white. If one man has a white horse worth two hundred dollars, and another has a black one worth fifty, the man owning the fifty-dollar horse has no right to shut his eyes and say he believes the two-hundred-dollar horse is black and the fifty-dollar one is white, and so take the two-hundred-dollar horse. If he should act in this silly manner, and the matter should be brought to trial, the court would surely decide that his eyes were intended for use, and that he had no reason for believing anything so palpably false. Yet men will talk and act just as foolishly about matters of spiritual discernment, and fancy they will come out all right in the Judgment.
We should not say we believe or disbelieve anything till we have first informed ourselves upon the subject, and then we can not only say we believe, but tell why we believe. Many of those who boast so much of their right to believe certain things in regard to the Bible, are almost wholly ignorant of its contents; and if they do chance to be enlightened, their bigotry and prejudice still hold them, and they again break forth in the refrain, “I have a right to believe as I please.” Let us remember that there is One who can weigh thoughts and motives, and that these flimsy excuses are all to pass beneath his searching eye.