SPECIAL NOTICE.— Please observe carefully the following directions for the guidance of those who send queries to this department. 1. Always accompany the questions with your name and post-office address. 2. Always inclose a stamp for reply, for it is necessary to answer a large majority of the queries by mail instead of in the REVIEW. 3. If the questions are sent with a letter pertaining to other business at this Office, write the matter designed for this department on a separate sheet of paper, and in so doing do not neglect directions 1 and 2. By observing these simple directions, parties will be much more certain of receiving satisfactory information than if they neglect them. Those who have not sufficient interest to regard these directions, are hardly entitled to the work of this department, and they must not think strange if they never hear from their questions.
SCRIPTURE QUESTIONS.
ANSWERS BY G. W. MORSE.
580.—TRAVELING ON THE SABBATH TO ATTEND MEETING.
Is it right to travel any considerable distance on the Sabbath, by rail or boat, to attend meeting? J. B.
The duty of assembling on the Sabbath for worship to God, is plainly taught in the Scriptures; and in the absence of any explicit testimony with regard to how far or by what means one may travel on the Sabbath to accomplish that purpose, we are left to judge on general principles, and by what seems consistent with proper Sabbath observance. It is impossible to state a rule in this matter that will cover all circumstances. On general principles, we should say that it would not be consistent to occupy a longer time in traveling to and from the place of meeting, than is occupied in attending such service. As to the mode of travel, we fail to see any objection to going by public conveyance, provided the ticket is procured before the Sabbath.
581.—DISFELLOWSHIPPING CHURCH MEMBERS—CHURCH MEETINGS ON THE SABBATH.
- Should a church take action in the matter of disfellowshipping a member without having duly notified such person of the time and place when and where such action would be taken?
- Is it necessary in such cases to notify all the members of the church that such a person’s case is to be considered at such a time and place?
- Is it right to disfellowship a member when only one half of the members of the church are present?
- Should meetings for such actions be held on the Sabbath?
- Is it right to drop a member’s name from the church book simply upon his request, or what course should be taken in such cases?
- No. Such a course would be less just, merciful, and humane than the practice of civil courts.
- No. A general notice of the time and place of a church business meeting is all that is necessary, except as before specified.
- While such action might stand the test of legality (provided that a quorum was present), it might not be advisable; it would depend somewhat upon circumstances.
- No.
- No. There are only three ways by which a person may cease to be a member of an individual church; viz., (1.) by death, (2.) by being disfellowshipped because of apostasy or disorderly walk, and (3.) by being transferred to some other church by a letter of recommendation. The mere request of an individual to have his or her name dropped, does not constitute a sufficient cause of action. In such cases suitable labor should be bestowed upon the individual, and if he still persists in refusing to be amenable to the church, and ignores the same, he may, after a sufficient time has elapsed, be disfellowshipped for disorderly walk. Six months or a year, might be regarded as a sufficient time to test one’s intentions in such cases, or developments on his own part might make a shorter time sufficient to warrant the church in taking action.
582.—SESSIONS OF THE ROMAN SENATE.
What portion of the year was the Roman Senate in session, and what were the dates of their sessions? A. McA.
The stated times for the Roman Senate to convene were the first day of every month, also upon the nones and ides of each month. The nones came upon the fifth day of January, February, April, June, August, September, November, and December, and upon the seventh day of the other months; the ides came upon the fifteenth day of March, May, July, and October, and upon the thirteenth day of the other months. The length of the sessions varied according to circumstances.
583.—UNBELIEVERS AS SABBATH-SCHOOL WORKERS.
Should a person who is not a Christian act as organist in the Sabbath-school?
As bearing on this question we quote a resolution that was adopted at the last meeting of the International Sabbath-school Association, which reads as follows:— “Resolved, That in securing officers and teachers for Sabbath-schools, great care should be exercised to get persons who are sound in the faith, and earnest, consistent Christians.”
The same rule would certainly apply with regard to all Sabbath-school helpers. In some cases it may be quite difficult to completely equip a school with helpers whose characters correspond with the above resolution, and it may be admissible to procure others; but in all such cases, only persons of irreproachable character and exemplary lives should be so employed.
To A. A. C.—The subject of your query was considered in the REVIEW a few months ago, and it does not seem necessary to repeat it now. Furnish us your name and address, and we will send you a copy of the paper containing the article referred to.
584.—BIBLE HOLINESS.
How do you explain 1 John 3: 8, 9 and 5: 18 so as to avoid the conclusions reached by the “Holiness” people? J. H. M.
The argument of the texts referred to is given to show the distinction between the sources of righteousness and unrighteousness; to show that the practice of right-doing is the consequence of being in harmony with God, and wrong-doing, in harmony with the Devil. One cannot perform an act that is at the same time in harmony with God and the Devil; that is morally impossible. When one is in the condition represented by the phrase “born of God,” that is, when his motives and acts are perfectly conformable to the Spirit of God, it is manifest that he does not sin; for the moment he does sin, he is not in that condition. It is absolutely impossible for him to practice wrong-doing, and at the same time be in perfect harmony with God. To sin is to depart from God, and to do right is to depart from the Devil. The word from which “born” is translated, as used in the texts under consideration, is gennao, which in the sense as here used, is defined by Robinson to mean “to spring from;” “the source or manner.” The word translated “seed” is sperma in the original, which Mr. Robinson translates as meaning “the germ or principle of divine life,” as here used. Hence it is admissible to paraphrase verse 9 of the third chapter, thus: “Whosoever lives in harmony with a principle that springs from God, doth not commit sin; for the principle of divine life remaineth in him: and he cannot sin because the principle that guides him springs from God.” This is self-evident, and can be comprehended by a child.
In his “New Testament for English Readers,” Dean Alford gives a similar explanation, and adds, “The abiding force of this divine generation in a man, excludes sin; where sin enters, that force does not abide.” The same interpretation applies to chapter 5: 18. The doctrine of holiness or sanctification as held by many people at the present time; viz., that they are beyond the possibility of sinning, not only has no foundation in reason or Scripture, but is directly opposed to the Bible. Take the case of Adam and Eve. Before their fall they were in a state of perfection beyond that which any person can hope to obtain in this life, and yet they committed sin. Moses was a man greatly beloved of God; and, judging from the most remarkable manner in which the Lord used him in bringing the children of Israel out of Egypt, and the wonderful privileges accorded to him in being permitted to commune with the Lord upon Mount Sinai and at other times, we must conclude that he lived a life of holiness far exceeding any examples of the present day; and yet he sinned, and was thereby prohibited from conducting the children of Israel into the promised land. See Num. 20: 10-12; Deut. 3: 26, 27. When David was anointed, it is said that “the Spirit of the Lord came upon David from that day forward.” 1 Sam. 16: 13. According to our “holiness” friends, there was no danger of his sinning after that; but the history of his life and his own confessions show that he did sin grievously. Coming to the New Testament, take the case of Peter, our Saviour’s disciple. We must conclude that he was a humble, devoted, and acceptable follower of Christ before the latter’s betrayal; and yet we find Peter committing a grievous sin by denying his Lord. If the doctrine of “holiness,” as advocated by the class of extremists before referred to, be true, then there is no meaning to the parable of the prodigal son; for there is represented the return to God of one who had fallen from grace,—the return of a backslider. If that doctrine be true, it would be very inconsistent for a believer in it to pray as Jesus taught his disciples. He would have no occasion to pray for the forgiveness of sin, or not to be led into temptation; for if he has reached a position beyond the possibility of sinning, he has no need to fear temptations.
The following scripture is directly opposed to the claims of our “Holiness” friends: “There is no man that sinneth not” (1 Kings 8: 46); “A just man falleth seven times, and riseth up again” (Prov. 24: 16); “There is not a just man upon earth, that doeth good and sinneth not” (Eccl. 7: 20); “For the flesh lusteth against the Spirit, . . . so that ye cannot do the things that ye would” (Gal. 5: 17); “If we say that we have no sin, we deceive ourselves, and the truth is not in us.” 1 John 1: 8. There are also many other passages of similar import. In Jer. 3: 22 we find this language: “Return, ye backsliding children, and I will heal your backslidings.” This proves the possibility of falling from grace. See also Mal. 3: 7; Deut. 30: 2; 1 Sam. 7: 3; Hos. 14: 1.
There is not a text in the Bible that, when properly understood, teaches the doctrine under consideration; and when we add to this the further fact that the Bible is full of the most positive evidence to the contrary, it is quite difficult to understand how any one can claim to believe it.