AdventAI

THE TEN KINGDOMS.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 3., January 18, 1887

(Continued.)

Gibbon himself (iii. 387) makes a remark which, though implying his own doubt in the matter, nevertheless acknowledges that the Hungarians of modern Europe claim to be descendants of that stock to which Attila belonged. He says: “The Hungarians, who ambitiously insert the name of Attila among their native kings, many affirm with truth that the hordes which were subject to his uncle Roas, or Rugilas, had formed their encampments within the limits of modern Hungary, in a fertile country which liberally supplied the wants of a nation of hunters and shepherds.” A foot-note says: “Hungary has been successively occupied by three Scythian colonies. 1. The Huns of Attila; 2. The Abares [Avars], in the sixth century; and, 3. The Turks or Magiars, A. D. 889; the immediate and genuine ancestors of the modern Hungarians, whose connection with the two former is extremely faint and remote.” But an additional note by Milman states this important fact: “Mailath (in his ‘Geschichte der Magyaren’) considers the question of the origin of the Magyars as still undecided. The old Hungarian chronicles unanimously derived them from the Huns of Attila.”

The sum of this testimony seems to be this: Gibbon recognizes the fact that the Hungarians claim Attila as among their native kings. He recognizes the fact that three Scythian tribes have successively occupied Hungary, the last of whom, as would necessarily be the case, are the immediate ancestors of the present inhabitants; and he thinks the connection of these last, the Magyars, with the two former, very faint and remote. But inasmuch as they were all Scythians, as he acknowledges they were, it seems to us that the connection between them need not necessarily be considered so faint and remote as his language would imply. And finally Mailath, in his work on the Magyars, considers the question of their origin undecided, but testifies that the old Hungarian chronicles unanimously derived them from the Huns of Attila.

Another proof that the Magyars were descended from the Huns is found in Koeppen’s “Atlas of the Middle Ages.” This work, “republished from the great ‘Historico-Geographical Hand Atlas’ of Doctor Charles Spruner, Major of Engineers in the Kingdom of Bavaria,” describing its fourth map, speaks thus of the Magyars: “The Magyars—Hungarian Huns—as they are called by contemporary chroniclers, have taken the same direction as the Bulgarians and Avars, from Mount Oural, southward,” etc.

A most excellent testimony as to the connection between the Huns and Magyars is furnished in the “Story of Hungary,” by Arminius Vambéry, who is called “the very latest authority on the subject.” Speaking of the contention of Aladar and Csaba, two sons of Attila, for the possession of the kingdom on the death of their father, he says: “All the followers of Aladar perished; Csaba, however, succeeded in escaping from the destroying arms of the neighboring nations, who had fallen on the quarrelling brothers, with about fifteen thousand men, to the territories of the Greek Empire. . . . He returned afterward, with the remainder of his people, to the home of his ancestors, on the banks of the Don, where up to the time of his death he never tired of inciting the Magyars to emigrate to Pannonia, and to revenge themselves on their enemies by reconquering the empire of Attila.”

The reader is requested to notice the facts here stated. What people were living in the land of the ancestors of the son of Attila?—The Magyars. Who, then, were the Magyars?—A people of the same race with Attila. And whom would they revenge by reconquering the empire of Attila?—Themselves. In this the reader will see a confirmation of Thierry’s statement that from the days of the Huns before the time of Attila, when Pannonia was struck off from the Roman Empire, the country has witnessed an uninterrupted succession of Hunnish tribes perpetuating the traditions of Attila; that the dynasty founded by the Magyars “is still a living link to bind us to that history of the past;” and that the old Hungarian chroniclers have reason for the claim that the Magyars were descended from the Huns of Attila. Thosep. 41 Hungarian chronicles are certainly entitled to some weight. It would naturally be supposed that the writers of those times would know as much about their own ancestors as Americans, a thousand years from their time and some five thousand miles from the scene of action, would be able to tell them.

As quotations to some length have been given from “Sheppard’s Fall of Rome,” the reader may desire to know something of the character of the work. The author in his preface says: “With regard to the text-books to be employed in the study of that particular portion of history of which these pages treat, there is nothing which can be placed in comparison with the great work of Gibbon. Subsequent writers have hewn their materials from the gigantic quarry of the ‘Decline and Fall,’ as the medieval Romans built their palaces with the stones of the Flavian Amphitheater. Yet the student of our own age will feel deeply the need of some corrective to the tone of a work which, with all its learning and eloquence, embodies so much of the spirit of another century. . . . In the meantime let me exhort him [the student] to the study of the original authorities. My own imperfect acquaintance with them convinces me that much may be gathered from their pages which has escaped Gibbon, or even the best and ablest of his successors, M. Amédée Thierry. Some I have very carefully examined,—‘Ammianus Marcellinus,’ ‘Jornandes de rebus Geticis,’ the ‘Gothic and Vandal Wars of Procopius,’ ‘Claudian,’ ‘Prudentius,’ and, above all, the letters and poems of Sidonius Apollinaris, without a knowledge of which it is not too much to say that no one can thoroughly understand the age.”

All this evidence certainly sustains Machiavelli, when in his “History of Florence,” in enumerating the kingdoms into which Rome broke up, he places “the Huns, in Hungary;” and it is sufficient to show that, whatever other kingdoms enter into the list, the Huns certainly cannot be omitted.

An effort is made to destroy the force of the testimony of Machiavelli in regard to the Huns, which, as it is directly calculated to mislead, deserves a word of notice. The matter is set forth as follows: “From a casual reading, some have supposed that Machiavelli himself named the ten kingdoms as such. This, however, is not the case, as appears from Bishop Newton’s words. He says: ‘Machiavel, little thinking what he was doing (as Bishop Chandler observes), hath given us their names.’ It is plain, therefore, that the responsibility for Bishop Chandler’s list lies not with Machiavelli, but with Bishop Chandler himself.”

The only effect which such a statement as this can have, is to convey the impression that because Machiavelli does not name the ten kingdoms “as such,” that is, is not giving an exposition of the prophecy of Daniel, as nobody claims that he was, therefore his statements are of no value as historical facts; whereas they are of much more value than they would have been if he had been laboring to show a fulfillment of prophecy; for then the skeptic might have cast upon him the suspicion of straining the testimony of history to make out a case. It is a fact that Machiavelli, speaking of the breaking up of Rome, does name ten nations by whom its dissolution was accomplished; and among these, and as bearing at least an equal part with the others, he names the Huns. The student of prophecy noting the fact that ten kingdoms were predicated to arise out of Rome, lays the unconscious testimony of the historian alongside the prophecy; and if his statements are sound, as history, he finds in them a fulfillment of the prediction, all the more impressive if the historian “little thought” that the facts he was recording were the counterpart of prophecies uttered long before. It was Machiavelli, not Bishop Chandler, who said that the Huns were one of the nations which destroyed Rome. All that Bishop Chandler is responsible for is the opinion that inasmuch as the Huns were one of the nations that destroyed Rome, as Machiavelli states, they were therefore one of the ten kingdoms which were symbolized by the ten horns; and he had just as much reason for calling them one, as any of the others which Machiavelli names, and he names the whole ten.

But it is said further that the Huns cannot be one of the ten because shortly after the death of Attila the Huns were driven back to territory east of the Danube, so that for a certain time there were no Huns in Pannonia. But this is altogether too limited and narrow a view to take of the subject. By the same method of reasoning we can strike out three others of the ten beyond hope of recovery, as we shall presently show. And we do not confine ourselves to the same limitations in the exposition of other prophecies. As already stated, it would be nothing strange, if, in the violent ebullitions of those times, the rapid ebb and flow of tribes and races, the whirling torrents of nations in constant motion, a nation should occupy for a time a certain territory, and then other nations should come in and temporarily occupy the same; and whoever makes an identification of the ten kingdoms depend upon the permanent occupation of a particular territory by said kingdoms, and the ability to show an uninterrupted succession from that day to this, will very shortly find himself obliged either to abandon his position or abandon the prophecy. The expositor must look for the great salient events of history, those which have exercised a molding and decisive influence upon epochs and eras, and fix his lines to these, regardless of the minor eddies that circle around them, if he would find the true points of contact between the declarations of prophecy and the world’s great experiences. He should not limit his vision by the walls of a seven-by-nine room, when it should be bounded by nothing short of the horizon itself.

As before remarked, we do not treat other prophecies in the limited manner suggested. For instance, we apply the little horn of Daniel 8 to Rome. When introduced into the prophecy, and for long years after, it was pagan in its religion, and political in its dominion. But the time came when Rome went through a complete metamorphosis; its civil dominion was lost; its territory was divided up among other nations; its paganism was baptized into popery; its power changed from political to spiritual, and through other channels and by other methods it spread its sway over the nations; it met a change which in some other prophecies necessitated a complete change of symbols; but there is no change here, and we say that Rome, notwithstanding all these radical changes, is the same horn still. So we place the beginning of papal supremacy in 538, when the Goths were driven from Rome by Belisarius. But a few years later we see Rome again in possession of the Goths, and Totila ravaging the city at his will. Recovered by Belisarius, it was again taken by the Goths, and was not entirely relieved from the incubus of their presence till the annihilation of Totila and the Gothic nation, by Narses, in 552. Why, then, do we date papal supremacy from 538?—Because the expulsion of the Goths from the gates of Rome in that year was really the fatal blow to their dominion; it was the turning-point, the decisive event in that movement which took them out of the way of the papacy. The same principle is illustrated by the case of the “king of the North,” in Daniel 11. At first it was Lysimachus, with his dominions in Thrace and Asia Minor; then the Syrian nation, with Seleucus at their head; but when it finally comes to the front again, from 1798 to the end, it is another people entirely—the modern Turks—whose connection with Seleucus and his ancient Syrians is much less than “extremely faint and remote;” yet it is the “king of the North” still; why?—Because the people occupy the original territory of that division of Alexander’s empire.

So with the Huns. They struck off a province from the Roman Empire. They were for the time being, at least, a kingdom, including in their territory a province of Western Rome. From the time that Aetius ceded to Rona, the uncle of Attila, the province of Pannonia, till the death of Attila, they certainly fulfilled every conceivable condition necessary to constitute them one of the horns out of the Roman beast. Now the fact that other nations, in the political cyclones of those days, as the Heruli and the Gepidae, were for the time being whirled into the same territory, and the Huns whirled out, does not materially affect the revolution so far as it relates to the breaking up of Rome. The career of Attila may be likened to the spray which is thrown high in air from the crests of contending waves, and falls back again upon the bosom of the flood. But the subsidence of the spray is not the disappearance of the waters themselves. The ceaseless undercurrents are all there, to make their strong pulsations still felt and heard. As in the strange phenomena of the tidal wave, the waters at first retire far away from the shore, only to roll in again with redoubled fury, so the Huns, after commencing the disruption of Rome, were temporarily repulsed to their ancestral seats, only to return with a more devastating flood, in the sixth century, to cover and hold the same territory. The tide ebbed again in the days of Charlemagne, but in the ninth century rolled in once more in the persons of a nation of kindred blood,—the Magyars, the immediate ancestors of the present Hungarians. So M. A. Thierry, who has made a specialty of the study of this nation, “little thinking what he was doing,” speaks of “an uninterrupted succession of Hunnish tribes perpetuating the traditions of Attila, in the central and lower valleys of the Danube,” and enables us to trace this Hunnish horn in Central Europe from about the middle of the fourth century to the present time.

(Concluded next week.)