ANSWERS BY G. W. MORSE.
545.—BUSINESS CO-PARTNERSHIP WITH UNBELIEVERS—LETTING SUGAR PLACES, ETC.
1. Is it right for a Sabbath-keeper to go into partnership with an unbeliever to carry on the business of hiring teams and men by the day, who are engaged in cutting and hauling logs, the business being done on Sabbath the same as other days of the week?
2. Is it allowable for a Sabbath-keeper to let a sugar place, to be operated by an unbeliever who will carry on the business on the Sabbath, the owner of the same to receive a share of the product.
3. Is it right for a Sabbath-keeper to give persons the privilege of unloading logs upon his premises upon the Sabbath, the same being placed upon the river bank preparatory to being rafted in the spring.
S. H. P.
1. No.
2. If it be right to let out one’s farm on shares to an unbeliever who would carry on business on the Sabbath, we see no reason why a sugar place could not be disposed of in the same manner. The objection to letting a farm on shares to one who carries on business on the Sabbath, is that the owner of the farm thereby becomes interested in the work that is done on the Sabbath, and receives a share of the products of such labor, which it is thought is avoided when the farm is disposed of for a cash rental. The only difference that appears is that in the former case the owner of the farm must himself market the produce in order to realize cash, whereas in the latter case the one who carries on the farm does the marketing and turns the cash over to the owner. In either case, the amount received by the owner of the land comes partly from Sabbath labor. In case a farm is let for a cash rental, the renter might market a load of produce on the Sabbath, and pay the proceeds of such sale directly to the owner, and no objection could be raised. The question turns on the difference between such a transaction and that of delivering the produce directly to the owner before being marketed. When a farm is let for a cash rental, the owner is interested that the renter may raise good crops in order that he may be able to pay his rent; he is also interested in the manner in which the renter cultivates the land and takes care of the premises, as such matters affect the value of the farm. His financial interests are materially affected by all that the renter does, whether such labor is performed upon the Sabbath or upon other days. In case a farm is let upon shares, the interests of the owner are the same as in the former case, with this slight exception: he is not able to make as accurate an estimate beforehand of the proceeds of the same. Whether or not this furnishes a sufficient reason for declining to let a farm on shares but accepting a cash rental for the same, is rather a fine point to decide. We are inclined to the opinion that if one system is admissible, the other also is admissible; and that the person who rents a farm or a sugar place is, for the time of his lease, the proprietor of the same, whether he pays a cash rental or gives a share of the proceeds. We confess, however, to a degree of doubt with reference to the propriety of renting or leasing a farm on any terms to an unbeliever, unless a condition be inserted in the contract that he shall do no work on the Sabbath in connection with carrying on the farm.
3. In case such work would not in any manner disturb or interfere with the proper observance of the Sabbath on the part of the owner of the land or any others who wished to observe it, we do not see that any serious objection could be raised against granting such a privilege as an act of neighborly kindness. In case such work interferes with the proper observance of the Sabbath, it would certainly be within the province of the owner of the land to decline granting such a privilege, and no fair-minded person would object to complying with such a decision.