AdventAI

Checks to Adventism.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 11., March 15, 1887

Having followed Mr. Ward through his futile efforts to overthrow the original Sabbath, and his still more futile attempts to establish a new one in its place, it remains that we say a few words about “Part 2” of his book which he names “Checks to Adventist Theories.” We give him credit for here using the correct word “Adventist;” for he usually speaks of this people as “Advents.”

His first attempt here is to show that the law as expressed in the decalogue was not applicable to Adam in Eden; for he says, Was Adam brought out of Egypt? But we are talking about commandments and obligations, not about mere declarations of facts. What God said to Israel, “I am the Lord thy God which have brought thee out of the land of Egypt,” was a reminder to them of a fact in their history, but was no commandment, and had nothing to do with the universal application of the first or any other precept of the decalogue. Will Mr. W. say that any one who was not brought out of Egypt, might have had other gods before the Lord? That is just what his argument leads to; and that would confine the command not merely to the Jewish people, but to that single generation of the Jews who were delivered personally from Egyptian bondage. Will he say that Adam might have had other gods before the Lord?

Referring to the command to honor father and mother, he asks who Adam’s mother was. He is very careful not to ask who Adam’s father was; for then the evangelist Luke would have met him with the declaration that Adam “was the son of God.” Luke 3:38. He asks further what neighbor Adam had “whose wife he was liable to covet;” just as though a wise lawgiver would make no provision for circumstances which were sure to exist in the near future, according to the arrangement which he had then and there ordained. According to this theory, any person who has not a wife, sons, daughters, and cattle, as many persons have not, might say, I am under no obligation to keep any part of the decalogue; for there are some of its commands which cannot apply to me. Whose wife would any woman be liable to covet? Is therefore the decalogue not binding upon women?

The only command which Adam had, he says, was the command not to eat of the forbidden tree. This measured the whole extent of his obligation. (Page 27.) According to this, Adam might have raved around there in the garden, a veritable heathen, blaspheming God, worshiping idols, and abusing Eve, and been guiltless so long as he just refrained from that tree! Those may believe this who choose. We respectfully ask to be excused.

He says the seventh day of Ex. 20:10, is not the same as the seventh day of Gen. 2:3. Let us look at the record in Ex. 20: “Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work: but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work,” etc. None will deny that the natural twenty-four-hour day is here referred to; six of these we are to use in our own work, the seventh to devote to God in holy service. Why devote this seventh twenty-four-hour period to rest and worship?—Because it “is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” “Sabbath” means rest; it is the rest day of the Lord thy God. How did it become such?—By the act of God in resting at the beginning. What kind of a day, therefore, was that on which God rested?—It must have been the very same kind as that mentioned in the commandment; for if he rested a long period, and is resting still, as Mr. W. asserts, then the seventh day of the commandment was not his rest day a particle more than any and all of the other six; but the commandment says it was his rest day, in distinction from the others which were not his rest days.

The same reasoning will apply to the sanctification of the day. According to the fourth commandment this seventh twenty-four-hour period is hallowed or sanctified time, that is, set apart to a holy and sacred use. Why?—Because God sanctified it in the beginning And there is no other act of blessing or sanctification performed with reference to any other time except that recorded in Gen. 2:3. The only time he ever blessed or sanctified was the day upon which he had rested. And if this was a long period, as is asserted, covering many such periods as our ordinary day, then the seventh day of Ex. 20:10, which is just such a day, was no more sanctified time than the other six days composing the brief period of the week; and hence the commandment, calling the seventh day in this weekly period God’s rest day and sanctified time, is a misrepresentation of the facts in the case. They assume a fearful responsibility who presume thus to deal with that sacred code which Jehovah uttered with his own voice, and wrote with his own finger upon the tables of stone.

But, he reasons, the first four days in Genesis “could not have been solar time; for the sun was not made until the fourth day.” Here he misapprehends the record. (See Dr. Clarke.) The sun, like the earth, was created in the beginning, but was not made the “light-bearer” till the fourth day. Those who accept the record, cannot deny that after the fourth day, when the sun was appointed to rule the day, the remaining days of the creative week ruled over by the sun, were the same as the sun gives us at the present time. But the light itself performed the same functions before that event as after it; for God made a division between the light and darkness, and the light was day, and the absence of it—the darkness—was night; and there was evening and morning just the same as after the sun was made the light-bearer. There is no contradiction, therefore, between Genesis 1 and 2 and the fourth commandment of Ex. 20. The time he spends showing that “day” is sometimes used in an indefinite sense, covering a period of time, is all wasted; for nobody disputes it.

On the record in Ex. 16, he contends that Israel having come into the wilderness of Sin on the 15th day of the second month, the manna began to fall on the 16th. We say that there is no evidence that the manna began to fall on the 16th, and the expression “the sixth day” does not apply to the sixth day in numerical order from the time the manna began to fall, but to the sixth day of the week. But Mr. W. grows very pathetic over our having some two million Israelites held “a day or two in starvation, in order to remove the Sabbath further away from the 15th day.” How long it would take them to starve, according to his idea, we do not know; but as this was the second month, we would ask what they had lived on thus far since leaving Egypt. Is it probable that they left every scrap of food, all of a sudden, in Elim, and came to Sinai with nothing?—Not at all. And the very fact that they had time to grow dissatisfied and murmur, shows that some time must have elapsed. When the manna fell, it fell in the night, and was gathered in the morning. According to Mr. W., it fell the night following their arrival at Sin on the 15th; for he says they gathered it on the 16th. Then they must have run entirely out of provision and begun to starve (!) in a marvelously short space of time. No; Mr. W. may save his tears for more deserving subjects.

According to the record, one day, at least, must have elapsed before the manna could have been gathered by them. Look at the facts: They began to murmur, and this came to the ears of Moses and Aaron. Then the Lord communed with Moses, and promised the manna. Moses and Aaron then said to the congregation (verses 6 and 7), “At even, then ye shall know that the Lord hath brought you out from the land of Egypt: and in the morning, then ye shall see the glory of the Lord.”

There is no probability at all that this was spoken on the 15th, the very day they came into the wilderness of Sin; but for the sake of the argument we will admit that it was; and it certainly could not have been any earlier than that. Then we ask when, according to the promise of verse 7, they were to see the glory of the Lord?—“In the morning,” and this “morning” could not be earlier than the next coming morning, which would be the morning of the 16th.

Verse 10 records the fulfillment of this promise to see the glory of the Lord “in the morning.” The verse reads: “And it came to pass, as Aaron spake unto the whole congregation of the children of Israel, that they looked toward the wilderness, and, behold, the glory of the Lord appeared in the cloud.”

It is not possible to place this earlier than the morning of the 16th; and what did the Lord then say? Verse 12: “I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel; speak unto them, saying, At even ye shall eat flesh, and in the morning ye shall be filled with bread.” What morning? A morning still to follow the morning of the 16th when this was spoken; which could not be earlier than the morning of the 17th. Therefore by no possibility can we place the falling of the manna, or rather the gathering of the manna, earlier than the morning of the 17th; but this is one day too late for Mr. Ward, and entirely spoils his little scheme for a change of the Sabbath at this point.

He says we claim two covenants made at Sinai. In this he mistakes our position entirely. There was but one covenant made at Sinai. But this was not the moral law. That law antedated the Mosaic covenant (Ex. 19) by all the distance back to creation. The two laws are not identical with the two covenants; but God’s law is the basis on God’s part of both the covenants, old and new, inasmuch as God can do nothing for any one who will not be obedient to him.

Again, he quotes Rom. 8:2, applying the expression, “law of sin and death,” to the moral law; whereas neither that expression, nor the corresponding one, “the law of the Spirit of life in Christ Jesus,” has any reference to moral or ceremonial law; but the first of these expressions signifies the carnal disposition which we have by nature, prompting us to sin, which will end in death; and the second refers to that new and spiritual nature which we receive through Christ, which prompts us to love and obedience, which will end in eternal life.

Referring to the pagan origin of Sunday, as a day devoted to the honor of the sun, he says that Saturday was named from the god Saturn, and he is not sure but the Sun is as beautiful a god as Saturn. This may all be true; and if the Sabbath had come into prominence because it was the “venerable day of Saturn,” as Sunday has because it was the “venerable day of the Sun,” as Constantine calls it in his laws, there would be some force in his allusions. But our regard for the Sabbath rests upon the word of God alone, without being influenced at all by the fact that pagans dedicated it to one of their deities.

In regard to Paul’s preaching on the seventh day, he says: “Ah! do not Advents preach in orthodox pulpits on Sunday, when they can get a chance? And would not that fact by the same rule prove them Sunday-keepers?” But we reply, “Advents,” that is, Seventh-day “Advents,” never call Sunday the Sabbath, as Paul called the seventh day.

We need not carry this examination further. If in any degree the strictures we have offered have seemed severe, we assure the reader that nothing has been uttered through unkindness or ill will. But it does seem to us that on this solemn and important subject, and within this highest and most sacred realm of Christian duty, involving no less than the question of our obedience or disobedience to the Judge of all the earth, in whose presence we must soon give account of the deeds done in the body, men are being misled by methods and arguments which are most reprehensible, and deserve the plainest dealing.

Especially on the subject of church history and the Fathers does the present case seem to be an aggravated one; for the author of the pamphlet under review confesses to a knowledge of the contents of Andrews’s “History of the Sabbath.” That work fully exposes the deceptions which have long been palmed off upon the world in this direction, by evidence which cannot be overthrown. References are given to author, chapter, and verse to verify its testimony. No candid person has ever replied, or will ever attempt to reply, to its statements. And when men with a knowledge of these facts before them, will turn it off with a sneer, and deliberately reiterate the exploded forgeries as though they were veritable truth, we confess we do not know how to characterize such a course by its right name, and use any milder terms than those we have felt compelled to employ. If the reader thinks they imply too much of censure, he can substitute others.

The way of truth is plain and simple. Its course is straightforward and undeviating from paradise lost to paradise regained. It requires no twisting and turning to follow its testimony. It honors God and harmonizes all his word. We earnestly commend it to the reader, with the grace that is in our Lord Jesus Christ.