BY F. S. HAFFORD.
In an article having the above title, published in the Western Christian Advocate, is an argument for the eternal torment of the wicked, though just what the author means by the heading is somewhat obscure. His opening paragraphs imply that a Bible reader left to himself to interpret the language of Scripture in accordance with the usual signification of terms, must inevitably conclude that eternal torment is the doom of the ungodly. Further on he proves that his ideal hell consists in bad men’s being left to themselves. I wish to review a few of his arguments, but in a single article many of them must necessarily remain unnoticed.
After the usual stress upon the text, “These shall go away into everlasting punishment,” which has so often been commented upon that I need not add more, he has this paragraph:—
“Take the following passages: ‘But the wicked shall perish,’ ‘But rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell,’ and, ‘They that forsake the Lord shall be consumed,’ which are claimed by the soul-sleepers to teach the future extinction of aliens from God. In regard to ‘perish,’ take these words: ‘They shall perish, but thou remainest: and they shall wax old as doth a garment. As a vesture shalt thou fold them up, and they shall be changed.’ Here ‘perish’ means change. Concerning ‘destroy,’ take these words; ‘And shouldest destroy them which destroy the earth.’ Is the earth being literally destroyed by wicked men? With reference to ‘consumed,’ take this passage: ‘Take heed that ye be not consumed one of another.’ Do quarrelsome people actually consume one another, or do they live to grapple with one another in days to come?”
In this paragraph the author makes no attempt to tell how we should understand these words in the passages where they are used in connection with the destruction of the wicked, and where their supposed figurative meaning is not made obvious by the context, as in the passages quoted. He merely ridicules the idea that the reader should take them literally, and then he is “left to himself” to put any figurative meaning to them that may suit his fancy.
As not every one’s fancy is able to give good figurative meanings to some passages, it would have been pleasing to his readers if he had suggested some for “stubble” and “ashes,” in Mal. 4:1, 3; for “smoke,” in Ps. 37:20 and Rev. 14:11; for the expression, “Never shalt thou be any more,” in Eze. 28:19. There are many others, but I will only notice one more: Obad. 16: “All the heathen shall be as though they had not been.” In all the arguments I ever heard or read, produced by so-called orthodox believers, in regard to the final disposition of the heathen, I never yet saw this text quoted or commented upon. Yet there it is, a literal translation—not a supplied word in it—and a plain “thus saith the Lord God.” If “left to himself,” the reader is at a loss to know how to figure it away.
The ability of the author of the article being reviewed, in this direction, may be clearly seen in five distinct phases of punishment which constitute his figurative eternal death:—
“1. A sense of shame.
“2. Fixedness of the thoughts, feelings, and purposes of life.
“3. Non-gratification of unholy passions. Drunkards will spend eternity in an ever-consuming thirst.
“4. Power to multiply. Wicked man in hell will be punished not only for what he has done, but for what he still does.
“5. Association. The flames of hell will throw out lurid tongues of flame from the roofs of a thousand houses not homes. Keeping on uttering hot hissing words is hell.”
“God does not put men into hell; he permits them to go where their inclination leads them. It is a mark of God’s benevolence that he makes such a place to match their state.”
“This last statement is probably a figurative rendering for Matt. 13:41, 42 or Rev. 14:10, 11.”
Comment on such speculations is useless. They furnish striking evidence of the almost unlimited extent to which a man will suffer his imagination to run, and still believe he is on scriptural ground; and as to the almost impenetrable darkness into which Satan sometimes succeeds in plunging those who will cling to error. The author closes the article with the following observations on probation after death, which are truly excellent:—
“Heathendom will be judged in accordance with its light. These earnest cries for a million for missions mean very largely an inspiration to pagans to consume what light they have. The tendency of men everywhere is to live below their light, and thus the light possessed can be turned into a consuming fire. The demand for another probation is more a trial for God than man. God is satisfied with one offer of salvation to the ages. Redemption is too costly to be repeated. Now or never, O man!”
Pennville, Mich.