THE TEN KINGDOMS

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 25, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 4.

Read the full edition

THE TEN KINGDOMS.

(Concluded.)
We come now to the book of Revelation, the complement of the book of Daniel. The view generally held by Adventists is that the four trumpets of chapter 8, give us a view of the more prominent agents and movements connected with that revolution which dismembered Rome and developed the ten horns of the fourth beast of Daniel 7. Thus the first trumpet was fulfilled by the Goths under Alaric, the second by the Vandals under Genseric, the third by the Huns under Attila, and the fourth by the Heruli, under Odoacer, supplemented by the work of Belisarius and Narses.
It will be noticed that the prophet uses the same language concerning each of these trumpets with reference to its effect upon the Roman Empire. Thus, under the first, the third part of the trees was burnt up; under the second, the third part of the sea became blood; under the third, the third part of the rivers and fountains of waters was made wormwood; under the fourth, the third part of the sun, moon, and stars was darkened, these expressions all signifying that the judgments respectively designated by them fell upon one division of the triparted Roman dominion. But they signify judgments of equal extent and severity. Now the nation brought to view by the first trumpet, we say, answers to one of the horns that arose out of the Roman beast, and the second is another, and the fourth is another; but the third, we are told, cannot be a horn at all, notwithstanding the prophecy gives it the same relation to the empire as that of the other three. And even Gibbon, that historical deity by which alone some seem willing to swear, speaking of Genseric, assigns also to Attila, the king of the Huns, his proper rank. He says, “The terrible Genseric, a name which in the destruction of the Roman Empire has deserved an equal rank with the names of Alaric and Attila.” None question that the Goths and the Vandals were two of the ten horns. To deny a like position to the Huns appears to us to be in accordance with neither logic, history, nor Scripture. And if the Huns were not one of the ten horns, the prophecy of Revelation 8 must be readjusted.
And who were these Alemanni, in whose behalf we are asked to tear up a position supposed to be so well founded, and to entertain whom we must recast the long-established views of such prophecies as Revelation 8? Answer: One of a number of German tribes, or rather a confederation of the more wild and reckless portions of several tribes, associated together for purposes of conquest and plunder, who spent their time in making raids into the provinces of the Roman Empire, and who, as often as they did so, were scourged back by the Romans to their primitive forests beyond the Rhine. If the reader has a copy of Gibbon, we ask him to look in the index, under “Alemanni,” where he will find the following:—
“Alemanni, the origin and warlike spirit of. Are driven out of Italy by the Senate and people. Invade the empire in the reign of Aurelian. Are totally routed. Gaul delivered from their depredations by Constantius Chlorus. Invade and establish themselves in Gaul. Are defeated at Strasburgh by Julian. Are reduced by Julian in his expedition beyond the Rhine. Invade Gaul under the emperor Valentinian. Are reduced by Jovinus, and chastised by Valentinian. Are subdued by Clovis, king of the Franks.”
Then turn to the volumes and pages to which the index refers, and read in full the record of this constant series of defeats. Remember that the Rhine was the boundary of the Roman Empire, and that both Julian and Valentinian drove the Alemanni far into their native forests beyond the Rhine. After their chastisement by Valentinian, Gibbon has but little to say about them till Clovis dropped his extinguisher upon them in A. D. 496.
The Suevi are reckoned as one of the ten kingdoms; and it appears to be a question whether the Alemanni were not a fragment of the same people. Thus in Gibbon (i. 302) we read: “In the reign of the emperor Caracalla, an innumerable swarm of Suevi appeared on the banks of the Mein, and in the neighborhood of the Roman provinces, in quest either of food, of plunder, or of glory. The hasty army of volunteers gradually coalesced into a great and permanent nation, and as it was composed from so many different tribes, assumed the name of Alemanni, or Allmen, to denote at once their various lineage and their common bravery. The latter was soon felt by the Romans in many a hostile inroad.”
Milman appends to this passage a note reading as follows: “The nation of the Alemanni was not originally formed by the Suevi properly so-called; these have always preserved their own name. Shortly afterward they made (357) an irruption into Rhoetia, and it was not long after that they were reunited with the Alemanni. Still they have always been a distinct people; at the present day, the people who inhabit the northwest of the Black Forest call themselves Schwaben, Suabians, Sueves; while those who inhabit near the Rhine, in Ortenau, the Brisgaw, the Margraviate of Baden, do not consider themselves Suabians, and are, by origin, Alemanni. The Teucteri, and the Usipetae, inhabitants of the interior and of the north of Westphalia, formed, says Gatterer, the nucleus of the Alemannic nation; they occupied the country where the name of the Alemanni first appears as conquered in 213 by Caracalla. They were well trained to fight on horseback, and Aurelius Victor gives the same praise to the Alemanni; finally, they never made a part of the Frankish league. The Alemanni became subsequently a center around which gathered a multitude of German tribes. The question whether the Suevi was a generic name comprehending the clans which peopled Central Germany, is rather hastily decided by M. Guizot. Mr. Greenwood, who has studied the modern German writers on their own origin, supposes the Suevi, Alemanni, and Marcomanni one people under different appellations.”
Haydn’s “Dictionary of Dates” speaks of them as follows: “Alemanni, or All-men (i. e., men of all nations), hence Allemand, German. A body of Suevi who took this name. Were defeated by Caracalla 214. After several repulses they invaded the empire under Aurelian, who subdued them in three battles, 270. They were again vanquished by Julian, 356, 357. They were defeated and subjugated by Clovis, at Tolbiac (or Zulpich), 496. The Suabians are their descendants.”
Koeppen (i. 65) speaks thus of them: “The Alemanni, in the southwestern angle of Germany, on the Upper Rhine (in Baden, Würtemberg, and Switzerland), were the ancient people of the Suevi, or Suabians, who in the time of Caracalla (A. D. 211) had formed another confederacy with their neighbors, the Turoni, Hermanduri, and other tribes, and calling themselves Alemanni, or All-men, invaded the territory behind the Hadrian Wall, where they afterward obtained permanent seats. This was the most exposed part of the empire, between the Upper Rhine and the springs of the Danube.” On page 107, he says again: “The kingdom of the Suevi, or Alemanni , as they sometimes are called, was founded in A. D. 409 in the ancient Gallicia, which this people in the beginning divided with their companions, the Vandals, and some bands of Alani, who had escaped the Huns, and joined the large Germanic armies on the Rhine.”
It appears from all these statements that the Suevi were the principal stock, the main element, at least, in the Alemannic confederation. But the Suevi, under their own name, are already counted as one of the ten horns. We must be careful that we be not misled, by change of name, to make another horn out of the same people.
We suppose the Suevi proper, the ones represented by one of the ten horns, were those who established their kingdom in the north-western portion of Spain. But if the chief element in the Alemannic confederation were a portion of the Suevic stock, it would certainly be improper to form another horn from them.
The nature of the Alemannic government is revealed to us by some expressions found in Gibbon. In vol. ii., p. 237, we read: “As soon as they were delivered from the fears of invasion, the Alemanni prepared to chastise the Roman youth, who presumed to dispute the possession of that country which they claimed as their own by the right of conquest and of treaties. They employed three days and as many nights in transporting over the Rhine their military powers. The fierce Chnodomar, shaking the ponderous javelin which he had victoriously wielded against the brother of Magnentius, led the van of the barbarians, and moderated by his experience the martial ardor which his example inspired. He was followed by six other kings, by ten princes of regal extraction, by a long train of high-spirited nobles, and by thirty-five thousand of the bravest warriors of the tribes of Germany.”
This was at the time of their conflict with Julian, A. D. 357, and the facts revealed by an analysis of the statement are simply these: The Alemanni were in their own country the other side of the Rhine. They were trembling with fear lest Julian should invade their native territory. Relieved of this, they prepared for a raid into territory the other side of the Rhine, which they claimed, but the Romans disputed. There were seven contemporary kings among them, Chnodomar and six others. The historian then goes on to narrate the terrible defeat they suffered at the hands of Julian; and on page 242 we read: “Without repeating the uniform and disgusting tale of slaughter and devastation, it is sufficient to observe that Julian dictated his own conditions of peace to six of the haughtiest kings of the Alemanni, three of whom were permitted to view the severe discipline and martial pomp of a Roman camp.”
A confederation in which there were seven kings reigning at the same time, without, as it appears, any common head or capital or court, might be called, perhaps, a nation, as Gibbon calls them; but they could be in no proper sense a kingdom; hence we never read of the empire or kingdom of the Alemanni. Koeppen’s “Historico-Geographical Atlas of the Middle Ages,” before referred to, delineating the states and provinces of Europe from the fourth to the sixth century, places the Alemanni simply as one of the subordinate tribes of Germany. Labberton’s “Historical Atlas” does the same. In neither Lyman’s “Historical Chart” nor the great “Historical Chart” of Adams do they receive any mention whatever.
Much stress is laid upon a statement of Gibbon concerning the Alemanni; that “they were the first who removed the veil that covered the feeble majesty of Italy.” But this expression, in a search for facts which fulfill the prophecy of the ten kingdoms, is entitled to no weight. A thousand circumstances might exist in connection with their inroads into the Romish provinces, to reveal the fact that the empire had become degenerate, and was intrinsically weak. This is not the point at all. The question is, What nations did actually break up the Roman Empire, separating its provinces so that they were never united again to the original government? The Alemanni did not do this. Their raids were chiefly across the Rhine into Gaul; but Gaul was the home of the Franks, considered the “guests” and allies of Rome, and ever esteemed by the Romans as the most formidable of the barbarians in that quarter. Gibbon, ii. 239. The career of Clovis is assigned to the years 481-511. As already stated, he subjugated and swallowed up the Alemanni in 496. But it was not till twenty-five years after Clovis that the provincials were absolved from their allegiance and the independence of Gaul acknowledged by Justinian. Gibbon, iii. 587. It is therefore idle to claim that the Alemanni established and maintained a kingdom there, at least to any such extent as to be fitly represented by one of the ten horns of the Roman beast.
As to the objection to the Huns that their empire was of too short continuance to be one of the ten horns, we inquire, Who can tell just how many years it was necessary for a kingdom to continue to constitute a horn? Even if we limit the Hunnish Empire to the period between the cession of Pannonia by Aëtius to the uncle of Attila, 424, to the death of Attila, 453, which, as we have shown, should by no means be done, still we have a period of twenty-nine years, during which that kingdom stood complete before the world with a dismembered portion of the Roman Empire absorbed into itself.
But how was it with the Alemanni? A recent article written to prove that the Alemanni should be put in place of the Huns as one of the ten kingdoms, places the beginning of the Alemannic kingdom in A. D. 351, and cites certain chapters and paragraphs in Gibbon in proof of this claim. The first reference is to chapter 10, paragraph 26. But this relates to the time of the Emperor Caracalla, when they were driven out of Italy, 268 A. D., 83 years before the date named. The next reference is to chap. 12, par. 20. But this refers to the time of Probus, when the barbarians were driven out of Gaul, 277 A. D., 74 years before the date assigned. The next reference is to chap. 19, par. 20. This refers to the campaign against them by Julian, when they were driven entirely out of Gaul, and beyond the Rhine, 357, 358, and 359 A. D. 6, 7, and 8, years after the date assigned. Next, chap. 36, par. 5. This relates to the time of the Emperor Maximus. “The deaths of Ætius and Valentinian,” says Gibbon, “had relaxed the ties which held the barbarians of Gaul in peace and subordination,” and, “the Alemanni and the Franks advanced from the Rhine,” etc. Then they were at this time beyond the Rhine, and had to cross it to invade Gaul. But this was in 455 A. D., 104 years after the date assigned. Lastly, we are referred to chap. 49, par. 22, which covers the time of the successors of Charlemagne, 814-887 A. D., and does not mention the Alemanni at all.
In all this testimony we find not the least particle of evidence for placing the beginning of the kingdom of the Alemanni in A. D. 351, nor any evidence that they ever established a kingdom at all. Let the reader again be reminded that Clovis extinguished the Alemannic confederacy at Tolbiac (Zulpich), a few miles from the Rhine, in A. D. 496.
And of the nations which certainly have a place among the ten kingdoms, some were not of very long continuance. Thus the Burgundians were overthrown by the Franks in 534; the Vandals were destroyed by Belisarius in the same year; and the Ostrogoths were utterly annihilated by Narses in 553.
Of those who have written on the subject, Machiavelli speaks, as we have seen, as a historian, and names the Huns as one of the nations principally concerned in the division of Rome; while among those who have written with reference to the prophecy, may be mentioned Berengaud, in the 9th century, Mede, 1586-1638, Bossuet, 1627-1704, Lloyd, 1627-1717, Sir Isaac Newton, 1642-1727, Bishop Newton, 1704-1782, Hales, —1821, Faber, 1773-1854. Of these nine authorities, eight take the position that the Huns were one of the ten kingdoms. Of these eight, only two, Bossuet and Bishop Newton, followed by Dr. Clarke, have both the Alemanni and the Huns. Only one, Mede, omits the Huns and takes the Alemanni. Thus we have eight for the Huns, to three for the Alemanni. Scott and Barnes in their commentaries, and Oswald in his “Kingdom that shall not be Destroyed,” take the kingdoms enumerated by Machiavelli.
In the light of all these facts, we consider it altogether erroneous to go back to the position of Mede against the uniform testimony of all later writers.