My attention has been called to the fact that some persons may make a wrong use of an expression found on page fourteen of the little pamphlet entitled “Social Purity,” in which reference is made to a certain popular novel as having been the means of doing much good, and not likely to do any one any harm. At the time the remarks were made, I had not given the work mentioned a careful examination. More than twenty years ago I gave it a hasty perusal; but my commendation of the work was based wholly upon the recommendations of those in whose judgment I had confidence. Facts have since been brought to my notice which lead me to believe that so indiscriminate a commendation is by no means safe, and I hasten to call attention to the matter, and to expunge the paragraph from the book.
In this age of haste and bustle, when all classes of society seem to have joined in a mad rush after diversion and excitement, what is needed is not such literature as will further inflame the emotions and the sentiments, but such as will calm and quiet the turbulent passions, and afford wholesome food to promote a stable and healthy mental and moral growth. Novel-reading I believe to be in the highest degree pernicious to mind and body; and I have serious doubts whether there can be found a single one among the thousands of popular novels, which has not done, in the aggregate, vastly more harm than good. There is an abundance of good and wholesome reading, well suited to all classes of minds.
The fact that a novel is “founded on facts” does not in the slightest degree mitigate its evil tendency. The harm arising from the perusal of these books is not so much in the acts described, either imaginary or real, but in the highly colored manner in which they are portrayed. While vice may be condemned, it is often pictured in such a fascinating way as to make it appear in anything but a repulsive light, so that the barriers against wrong-doing are weakened rather than strengthened. The weak, namby-pamby chatter of the “religious novels” and most of the story books of the day, renders them little better than the novel proper; and it is the candid opinion of the writer that the less one reads of this sort of stuff the better for both mind and morals.
J. H. KELLOGG.