PROVING ERROR BY ERROR

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 1, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 9.

Read the full edition

PROVING ERROR BY ERROR.

BY J. E. CALDWELL.
It is said that if one tells a lie, a dozen more must be told to support it, and these in the end lead to their own exposure. Just so would it seem that God has disposed the doctrinal truths of his word. If violence is done to one truth, violence must also be done to many others in order to justify the first. The following well illustrates the above-mentioned principle: Among leading thinkers who oppose the true Sabbath, the effort to show a “thus saith the Lord” for the change from the seventh to the first day Sabbath is abandoned, as well it might be. But what do they offer in its stead? How do they justify themselves in the change? There is a great lack of unanimity among them on the subject, but among the excuses heard from them are these: “We make the change from the seventh to the first day Sabbath for expediency’s sake;” “It is especially fitting that the resurrection from the grave of our Saviour should be commemorated by a weekly rest,” etc.
But one of the most specious arguments used by this class was stated to me by a highly intellectual and apparently honest minister of an orthodox church, as follows: “The highest possible service that can be rendered by the creature to the Creator, or by the saved to his Saviour, springs from love.” With this we find no fault. “A self-suggested offering or sacrifice (free-will offering), prompted by love, is an infinitely higher service than the same offering, or sacrifice, rendered in compliance with a demand or a commandment.” This sounds well, indeed! Man is going to surprise his Creator by being better than the law demands! But let us look at his application: “Hence it is that the entire system of government of the Old Testament, with its laws, ceremonial and general, having been [not exactly abrogated, but] fulfilled, or rendered inoperative by the death of the Saviour and the ushering in of the new dispensation, Christendom unites in rendering to Christ a free-will offering of the seventh part of time, in commemoration of his resurrection from the tomb on the first day of the week.” When cross-questioned, this same brother stated that all Old Testament laws are void since the time of Christ, and that the Christian Sabbath itself is not obligatory upon any from a scriptural stand-point.
But this same man is a zealous advocate of Sunday laws and their enforcement. Here is where the absurdity of his position is seen. The idea that the direct command of God should be ignored by Christendom, and unwilling men be compelled by secular law to render a free-will offering to God of the seventh part of time, as the above class of religionists seek to have brought about, is too absurd to demand a reply. A man compelled to give a free-will offering, indeed! Let religionists give as many free-will offerings of their own time as may please them, but let no man or set of men give a free-will offering of that which belongs to another, whether it be time, or money, or means of any sort.
In reply to the statement, that a sacrifice rendered as a free-will offering is a higher service than when the same sacrifice is made in obedience to a command from God, we might add that it is not true if the free-will offering in question is in the least degree at variance with the expressed will of God. In proof of this we find that the Lord pronounced a curse upon Saul through Samuel for his purposing to make an offering of the fat oxen and sheep taken from the Amalekites, when God had told him to totally destroy them; adding the question, “Hath the Lord as great delight in burnt-offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the Lord?” 1 Sam. 15:22.
But if the free-will offering is not at variance with the expressed will of God, can a man give, or withhold, and be equally guiltless in either case, as the above quotation from the minister implies?—I think not. In Malachi 3:8 the people are accused of sin in that they have robbed God of tithes and offerings. Then very plainly we see that one sins in withholding free-will offerings, and the amount to be given is limited by one’s ability. See Acts 11:29. Hence, if God demand the seventh part of time (and there is abundant evidence that he does, and that he has designated which seventh he requires), men sin in withholding it. If he does not demand it, he will not accept it as an offering from any one. In Ex. 20:10 the Lord claims one seventh of each week, i. e., the seventh day, as his own. How, then, can any one render to him a free-will offering of that which is his already?
Minter, Wash. Ter.