MORE AUTHORITY FOR THE CHRISTIAN SABBATH

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 1, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 9.

Read the full edition

MORE AUTHORITY FOR THE CHRISTIAN SABBATH.

Following Mr. Ward’s argument to another point, we find that he contradicts the record in Genesis, in not having the Sabbath provided till after the fall of man. He says:—
“In this holy estate [that is, before man sinned] no secular labor was known; secular labor would have ruined Eden. Secular labor is the result of the fall.”
The object of these statements is to show that Adam could not have engaged in labor for six days, and so could not have rested on the Sabbath; hence there was no Sabbath then possible. Then speaking of the command laid upon him not to eat of the tree of knowledge, he further says:—
“He violated it, was driven out of the garden; he was cursed and compelled to ‘eat his bread by the sweat of his face.’ Now servile work was instituted, and a rest day was necessary to the real wants of man. And God has ever provided for the wants of his people—and no doubt gave to Adam and his race a Sabbath. Though there is no specific record of one during the first 2,500 years of time, from Adam to Moses, we believe and claim with all Christian churches that there was a patriarchal Sabbath all these years. Now in the absence of any specific record of a positive precept, it is reasonable to believe that God chose the day he blessed at finished creation.”
Such magnanimity is marvelous. Why has he “no doubt” that God gave to Adam and his race a Sabbath? To be sure the record says that God gave him one; but Mr. W. seems to care nothing for the record, hence we wonder where he gets his evidence which so frees him from doubt in the matter. He thinks God “chose the day he blessed at finished creation.” Thus he admits that God did bless a day when he finished the creation. But the first seventh day was past when God blessed the day. Hence the blessing had reference to seventh days which were to come. Now what difference did that make between this and other days? In other words, what was the effect of that blessing? We are glad to find him admitting so much in regard to the blessing. But it was “sanctified” at the same time it was blessed; and, as already explained, the sanctifying of the day was the setting it apart to be used in a religious manner by man. This shows that his assertions about there being no “specific record of a positive precept,” are all entirely false, so we may dismiss them without any further notice. But what about the institution of the Sabbath after the fall? Nothing, only in this, as in many other points, he is directly contradicted by the record; for that places the institution of the Sabbath immovably prior to the fall. The curse upon Adam was not that he should work, however much of a curse Mr. W. may consider that commodity, but only that his toil should be wearing and painful till it reduced him to dust. Adam was to dress the garden and keep it—a pleasant and delightful employment, had he never sinned. The nonsensical clap-trap about “keeping it with obedience and dressing it with praise” (p. 8), may be taken for what it is worth by those who prefer sound to sense.
Next, Mr. W., like many of his predecessors, vaults over to the 16th of Exodus, and endeavors to work mischief by means of the manna. One little fact will prick and collapse the bubble of deceit which he tries to blow up here. He would have us understand that on the 16th day of the second month, the very next day after they came into the wilderness of Sin, which was the 15th, the manna began to fall. But this is all assumption. There is nothing to intimate that it was the next day. We do not know but several days intervened before the manna began to fall. Secondly, he claims that after the manna began to fall, it fell six consecutive days before the Sabbath came. Here is more assumption again. There is not a particle of proof of this. For when the record says (Ex. 16:5), “And it shall come to pass, that on the sixth day they shall prepare that which they bring in; and it shall be twice as much as they gather daily,” reference is made not to the sixth day from the falling of the manna, as Mr. W. would have us believe, but only to the well-known and established designation of the sixth day of the week.
This is susceptible of the clearest proof; for the record does not relate merely to a single instance, but to one which was to be repeated during their forty years of wandering in the wilderness; and it was to be on the sixth day of each week that they were to gather a double portion, and keep a quantity sufficient for their needs over the seventh day. But let us see the difficulty they would be in according to Mr. W. He says the “sixth day” of Ex. 16:5 relates only to the sixth day in numerical order after the manna began to fall, and then they were to gather a double portion, and the next day was the Sabbath. Now on this ground can any one tell us when they would next gather a double portion of manna? He will have to say on the seventh day from that first sixth; but the record says nothing of the kind; that has nothing about gathering on the next seventh day, and so on every seven days. No; it only says “on the sixth day.” That is the one sole direction that it gives. But the act was to be repeated, or nothing can be drawn from it in any respect in regard to the Sabbath. Was it then on every sixth day that they were to gather a double portion of manna? It certainly was if the word “sixth” there refers only to the sixth in order from the falling of the manna, or else there was only one occasion when they were to gather a double portion of manna, which would have had no bearing on the Sabbath at all. Then it follows that there was a week given to the Israelites which was only six days in length! Such is another absurdity into which this theory runs; and it is impossible for Mr. W. to extricate himself from it. We submit to every candid reader if it is not better to take the word “sixth” in its obvious and natural sense as meaning simply the sixth day of the week without regard to the time when the manna began to fall, and let it mean every sixth day, and thus avoid the groundless assumptions above noticed, make consistency and harmony in the narrative, and save ourselves from vitiating the sacred record.
As usual when he is about to attempt some outrageous perversion of Scripture, he says, “Please read with care;” and in his comment on verses 22–26, we have it in these words: “This is the first place in the Scriptures in which a command is found to keep the seventh day.” If now the reader will look at that passage, even if it is not with much care, he will discover that there is no command whatever there. Let us read it: “And it came to pass that on the sixth day they gathered twice as much bread, two omers for one man; and all the rulers of the congregation came and told Moses.” Why did the rulers come to Moses to say to him that the congregation had gathered enough manna for two days instead of one?—Because they suddenly found themselves in a dilemma. The rule was as announced in verse 19, that no one should keep any of it over “till the morning.” Some had disregarded that direction, and tried to keep some over, and they found that it bred worms and spoiled. Now the whole congregation had gathered a double quantity, which had been miraculously supplied them, with the evident purpose of keeping it over. Why should they be so directed and the manna be so supplied to them, if none of it could be kept through the following day? And not yet understanding that God had arranged to preserve it in a miraculous manner over the Sabbath, they referred the case to Moses.
In reply Moses said (verse 23), “This is that which the Lord hath said.” What had the Lord said? The only things the Lord had said on this matter, so far as the record shows, was that they should gather a certain quantity every day except on the sixth day, when they should gather a double quantity. Verses 4, 5, 16. So when this was done, and the rulers reported the matter to Moses, he replied, This is all right; this is what the Lord has said that they should do. Then he made an announcement to them, saying, “To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord; bake that which ye will bake to-day, and seethe that ye will seethe; and that which remaineth over lay up for you to be kept until the morning. And they laid it up till the morning, as Moses bade; and it did not stink, neither was there any worm therein.” In verses 25 and 26 it is further stated that Moses again announced to them that that day was the Sabbath, and on the Sabbath no manna should be found in the field.
Thus it was explained to them why a double portion was to be gathered on the sixth day, and how it would be preserved over the Sabbath. But we see that there was here not the first act toward the institution of the Sabbath nor the promulgation of any law telling how it should be observed, but simply an announcement by Moses that the seventh day was the Sabbath, that there would be no fresh manna given on that day, but that what was gathered the day before would be preserved fit for use during that day.
Notwithstanding all this, some went out to search for the manna on the Sabbath, and the Lord sharply upbraided them in the following language: “How long refuse ye to keep my commandments and my laws?” How would this sound in reference to a law made, as Mr. W. declares, only the day before? Then the Lord continues (verse 29), “See, for that the Lord hath given you the Sabbath.” He does not say the Lord giveth, or now gives you, the Sabbath, but “hath given,” referring to the past. “Therefore,” he adds, “he giveth you on the sixth day the bread of two days.” Not every sixth day from the time the manna began to fall, but the sixth day of every week. Every scholar knows that the Jews designated the days of the week by the numerals, first, second, third, and so on; hence “the sixth day” without qualification, can refer to nothing else but the day of the week.
There was a command which had its origin at that time and place, and that was in reference to laying up a pot of manna before the Lord. Now mark how this is expressed (verse 32): “And Moses said, this is the thing which the Lord commandeth;” not which the Lord hath said or hath commanded, as is said in reference to the Sabbath.
On p. 11 of Mr. Ward’s book, he exhorts the reader to examine the 34th chapter of Exodus “with care,” so we are put on our guard against another sophistical attempt. We find it in verses 27, 28, which he quotes as follows: “And the Lord said unto Moses, Write thou these words: for after the tenor of these words I have made a covenant with thee and with Israel. And he wrote upon the tables the words of the covenant, the ten commandments.”
In this quotation he gives no sign of any change of subject or the omission of any words. But if the reader will turn to the passage, he will find that more than half of verse 28 has been omitted, which brings in Moses’ whole sojourn of forty days in the mount, and introduces the Lord as the antecedent of the pronoun “he” and as the one who wrote upon the tables. The ten commandments are called “the words of the covenant,” because they were on God’s part the basis and conditions of the blessings he proposed to bestow upon Israel in the covenant he made with them. And these were in existence before the Hebrew covenant; for in the very beginning of the negotiations to form that covenant God said, as the indispensable condition on his part, “Now therefore, if ye will obey my voice indeed, and keep my covenant.” Then God had a covenant already existing, and that was the ten commandments which he afterward spoke in their hearing with his own voice. Ex. 19:5. And when the new covenant was predicted (Jer. 31:33), God said that he would take these very laws which, as the basis of the first covenant, were written on the tables of stone, and write them in the hearts of his people, as the basis of the new covenant. Heb. 8:10. This brings the entire moral code unchanged into this dispensation, and perpetuates it until the end of time.
He concludes his misapplication of the question of the covenants by a reference to a part of the subject which is very unfortunate for his theory. He says:—
“Our Advent friends deny the spirituality of the new covenant, and say, ‘Therefore the law in the ark in heaven before which Christ ministers must be word for word, letter for letter, jot for jot, tittle for tittle the same as the law that was deposited in the typical ark here upon the earth.’ (See ‘Sanctuary and its Cleansing,’ pp. 264–267.)”
After quoting this, his next sentence shows the dilemma in which his position involves him. It is this:—
“So according to this, Jesus, the mediator of the ‘new and everlasting covenant,’ is in heaven administering the ‘old covenant,’ which he abolished by his own death upon the cross.”
His own false view of the covenants, making the ten commandments the old covenant (which they were not, for they were in existence 2,500 years before that covenant was formed), is what leads him to the absurdity that Christ is now administering the old covenant in heaven. Nevertheless the fact remains, and we would like to have all people of Mr. Ward’s school candidly look at it, that there is a sanctuary above, in heaven, in which Christ, at the right hand of God, is a minister (Heb. 8:1, 2); that the sanctuary of Moses, with all its sacred vessels, among which was the ark, was a type or figure of these more perfect things in heaven (Heb. 8:5); and that the ministry which the Levitical priest performed in the earthly sanctuary, was an example and shadow of the ministry which Christ performs in his sanctuary on high. Verse 5. Now John says that he saw the ark in the temple (sanctuary) in heaven; and we ask them in all earnestness to consider what that ark contains. While the ark here on earth, which was only a type, contained the ten sacred words written by God, does the great antitype, the ark in heaven, contain nothing? Is that a mere empty shell?—Preposterous. The ark here was constructed purposely to receive the law, the ten commandments, alone. Can the ark above contain anything but the same? Moreover, the ministry of the Levitical priests was performed with reference to that law in the ark, the transgression of which made them sinners. Their ministry was a shadow of Christ’s ministry as our high priest above. Now with reference to what law does he minister? Will any man in his right mind affirm that it is or can be, as above quoted, different in one jot or tittle from the law which Moses took from the hand of God and put into the earthly ark? No man can do it. It isn’t possible that there should be any difference. If there is,—if the priests on earth ministered with reference to one thing, and Christ ministers with reference to another,—then their ministry was in no sense a shadow and type of his; then the whole record is falsified, and the plan of salvation is destroyed at a blow. We ask that this point may be fully considered. It is absolutely decisive on the perpetuity of the ten commandments. Theological teachers have lost themselves in the fog over the priesthood of our Lord, or they would not take positions that are so utterly subversive of the gospel of Christ, as to say that the law, the violations of which are atoned for by Christ in fact, differs in a jot or tittle from that law the violations of which were atoned for by the sons of Levi in figure, while they were serving unto the example and shadow of the greater and more perfect work of Christ himself.
Chapter 2 of Mr. W.’s book is headed “Authority of the Christian Sabbath.” An examination of this we must defer to our next.