AdventAI

The text reads: “But his flesh upon him shall have pain, and his soul within him shall mourn.” A correspondent asks for light on this text with reference to its bearing upon the question of the state of the dead. This testimony of the 14th chapter of Job is very positive and very explicit in regard to the state of the dead. The patriarch first states that like a flower man is soon cut down; that he fleeth like a shadow and continueth not. Verse 2. In verse 10, he asks this direct question: “But man dieth, and wasteth away: yea, man giveth up the ghost, and where is he?” The answer immediately follows: “As the waters fail from the sea, and the flood decayeth and drieth up; so man lieth down, and riseth not: till the heavens be no more, they shall not awake, nor be raised out of their sleep.”

This testimony is very clear that the dead are in a condition which in its main features resembles sleep; and that they are not to be awakened or raised out of that condition till the heavens be no more. By no possibility can such language be harmonized with the idea that the dead are in a state of consciousness and activity, more keenly sensitive, and having infinitely greater knowledge than when in life.

In verses 14 and 15 man’s hope of the future through the resurrection is set forth. Man will live again, but it will not be till that time when God shall call him again from the grave. In verse 21 he makes another statement showing the unconscious condition of the dead: “His sons come to honor, and he knoweth it not; and they are brought low, but he perceiveth it not of them.” Thus after death he has no knowledge of the circumstances of this life, even those which would most concern and interest him.

Then come the words of verse 22, first quoted, the only question in regard to which is their seeming contradiction of the preceding testimony of the same chapter. No believer in the Bible should be willing to put upon them a construction which involves them in a contradiction with other portions of the chapter. But, strange to say, some who desire to sustain the dogma of the immortality of the soul, do not hesitate to quote the verse in behalf of a position which the preceding verse, and verses 10–12, 14 and 15, utterly disprove.

The decisive question in reference to the text is, To what time in a person’s experience does it refer? The class above referred to apply it to the person after death, in what is called the disembodied state. But a difficulty at once suggests itself in the way of this view; namely, “his flesh upon him shall have pain.” Do disembodied immortal souls have flesh that can have pain, while “his soul within him,” that is another soul within the disembodied immortal soul, mourns? This would go beyond the wildest immortal soul conceptions we have ever heard of, and is at best utterly absurd. Therefore the text cannot refer to the dead in their supposed conscious condition between death and the resurrection, even provided there is any such condition; hence it is no proof for the popular view. And inasmuch as it refers to a time when the person is clothed with flesh, and his soul (mind) within him, may be depressed and suffer feelings of sorrow, it must refer to this present state of being.

In this we simply have another instance, so common in the Scriptures, in which the writer having completed one idea, goes back to other times and conditions. In verse 21 Job takes man through to the state of death in which he has no knowledge of scenes transpiring in this life; then in verse 22 goes back and states his general condition while in this life; he has pain of body and anxiety and distress of mind, just as stated in verse 1: “Man that is born of a woman is of few days, and full of trouble.”