BY W. A. COLCORD.
WHEN two or more disagree upon some question, it is proof positive that all but one must be wrong; one may be right. But the fact that they disagree does not of necessity imply that even one is correct; all may be wrong.
Thus it was in the case of condemning the Saviour. In giving testimony against him, some testified to one thing, and some to another. Thus Mark bears record: "And the chief priests and all the council sought for witness against Jesus to put him to death; and found none. For many bare false witness against him, but their witness agreed not together." Chap. 14:55, 56. It thus appears that there was no lack of witnesses; but their testimony could not be accepted as valid, because of their lack of agreement. The testimony of one destroyed that of another. But it is a fact worthy of notice that, notwithstanding the disagreement in the testimony of these many witnesses, they all agreed to one thing, and had but one object in view, and that was to crucify the Saviour. Through a prevailing custom they were granted the release of a prisoner at the feast of the passover, but it must not be Jesus, though a robber and a murderer be let loose among them instead. "And they cried out all at once, saying, Away with this man, and release unto us Barabbas." Luke 23:18.
A strikingly similar course has been taken by the opposers of God's Sabbath and advocates of the first day of the week. Should we put some of them upon the stand, we would have testimony something like the following:—
1. The Catholics.—There is no authority whatever in the Scriptures for observing the first day of the week, or Sunday. But the pope can dispense above and in contradiction to the law of God, and even to the precepts of Christ. We are commanded to hear the Church, and the Church says, "Keep Sunday;" therefore we keep Sunday.
2. The Methodists.—The law of God has not been abolished, but Christ so changed the fourth precept of that law that we now are to observe Sunday as the Sabbath; therefore we keep Sunday.
3. The Presbyterians.—The law of God has neither been changed nor abolished, but a seventh part of time is all the fourth commandment requires, and Sunday is a seventh part of time; therefore we keep Sunday.
4. The Disciples.—The law of God has been abolished, and we now have no Sabbath; but we are to observe "Lord's day," and Sunday is Lord's day; therefore we keep Sunday.
The cases might be multiplied, but these are sufficient to illustrate the point. It will be readily noticed that notwithstanding the diverse and contradictory positions taken in reference to the law of God, the conclusion arrived at is the same in each instance. All bring in a verdict in favor of Sunday-keeping; all are unanimous in condemning the Sabbath; and although the methods resorted to are so divergent and incoherent, all unite in saying of the Sabbath, "Crucify it; but as for this Sunday, though a robber and a murderer, release it unto us."
As in the trial of the Saviour the want of agreement among the witnesses proved their testimony fraudulent, so of these we may likewise say, They are false witnesses, because they agree not together.
But we are led to inquire into the cause of this. Why are such arguments resorted to in defense of Sunday-keeping? It certainly cannot be the result of defending the truth, for truth never drives its adherents into inconsistent and untenable positions. Truth is consistent with itself, and ever moves in a straight line. But we think the case is not difficult of solution. In the first place, it might be stated that such arguments are resorted to because there are no better. But the real reason is this: when one finds himself in error, the first and most natural thing for him to do is to begin to excuse himself. It is so much easier than to make a frank confession of having been in the wrong, and begin the work of reformation. This is forcibly illustrated in the fall of our first parents. Each, when questioned, offered an excuse. Adam, when asked if he had eaten of the forbidden fruit, said: "The woman whom thou gavest to be with me, she gave me of the tree, and I did eat." And coming to Eve a similar answer was received, "The serpent beguiled me, and I did eat." Thus we see, each to justify a sinful course, offered an excuse. And their children, it seems, have not forgotten the foible.
But the Bible, which all these claim to follow, says: "Put not thine hand with the wicked to be an unrighteous witness." The change of the Sabbath has been brought about by wicked hands. The masses have been led into error. But we have the command, "Thou shalt not follow a multitude to do evil." When shown our faults, how much better to take the advice of Pope, "A man should never be ashamed to own he has been in the wrong, which is but saying in other words, that he is wiser to-day than he was yesterday." Truth is the abiding religion; all else must sooner or later fall.
Des Moines, Iowa.