AdventAI

“THE BURNING QUESTION.”

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 18., May 3, 1887

Such was the title of a discourse preached in the Park Street Church, Boston, Mass., April 24, 1887, by David Gregg, on the Sabbath question. The full title of the discourse, according to the Boston Herald of April 25, in which a synopsis was given, was this: “The Burning Question before Our Legislature; or, Sabbath Observance.”

Although the effort was in behalf of Sunday, the text, strange to say, was from Leviticus: “Ye shall keep my Sabbaths and reverence my sanctuary. I am the Lord.” The report begins:—

“After explaining the origin of his sermon, which he delivered in compliance with general solicitation, Mr. Gregg described the question of Sabbath observance as one of the most important now before the people, and said that it was a subject in regard to which the church of God should be outspoken, explicit, and aggressive.”

Our mind readily goes back to the time when through all the land, and through all the world, there was apparent quiet on the Sabbath question. Nothing in any unusual or special sense was said about it, and no particular importance, above many other subjects was attached to it. Yet all this while there was one class of people predicting that the Sabbath question was destined to come to the front; that movements “outspoken, explicit, and aggressive” were in store; and that it would be a leading, testing question in the land. And they gave utterance to these expectations not on their own authority or calculations, but because the terminal links of certain lines of prophecy—lines whose preliminary and intermediate stages had already passed into the unchangeable fulfillments of history—because these terminal links which alone remained to be accomplished, pointed inevitably to the conclusion that under the name of the Sabbath, Sunday-keeping would be enforced by all the influence of preponderating numbers, and the strength of national law.

That this expectation was based wholly on the testimony of the prophecy is evident from the fact that only those who took the view of the prophecy above referred to, gave utterance to any such anticipations. No others were predicting or expecting any movement of this kind, any more than men are now predicting that the question of blasphemy or the crime of theft is to become the leading and all-absorbing religious and political question of the near future.

But mark the change: the quiet on the Sunday question is suddenly broken; the apathy has passed away; throughout all our own land and in most of the nations of Europe, individuals, churches, governments are moving in the matter; under the name of Sabbath societies and Sabbath committees, organizations are formed to urge forward a better Sunday observance, and to secure it by the sanctions of law. Pulpit and press are everywhere proclaiming in the language of Mr. Gregg, above quoted, that “the question of Sabbath [Sunday] observance” is “one of the most important now before the people.”

How has all this come about? Why has this question so suddenly assumed such importance in the eyes of the people? Can any other reason be assigned than that the time has come so long ago discerned by the prophetic eye, and these events are now fulfilling the inspired word? And can we who have so long looked for such movements as these be indifferent as we now see them taking place before our eyes?

Returning to the discourse in question, the most of its utterance will be a genuine surprise to any one instructed on the Sabbath question. Please read carefully the extracts presented below, remembering all the while that they are calculated to be utterances in behalf of Sunday:—

“It must first be remembered that God was the sole law-giver of the universe, and that true legislation consisted in the plain and simple enunciation of his law upon every subject. Concerning everything propounded in our legislative halls, as well as in home and State life, the first and paramount question should be, Has God said anything upon this? And when we had found his law in any matter, we should allow its authority and be guided by it. Whenever a legislature legislated inside or short of God’s law, it was guilty of high treason and of usurpation. It was true that man claimed the right to make laws, but he no more had the function of law-making for the nation than he had such a function for the trees of the forest. What man had to do in both cases was to obey the law already made. When he disobeyed the laws God had laid down, the nation died and perished. That was history. And, for the same reason, no law of God could ever become a dead letter. God’s justice made it a living voice, uttering sentence of condemnation against sinners and transgressors. They must look upon the laws of God as mechanics looked upon the laws of matter—as laws that existed eternally, that could not be violated with impunity, that must be obeyed.”

We agree with all this exactly as an enunciation of correct principles. But how a person who had ever studied the Bible could utter them in an argument for Sunday is the mystery. We have asked long and earnestly, “Has God said anything upon this” matter of Sunday-keeping? And we cannot find that he has said anything about that day, except that God worked upon it (Gen. 1:1–5), that the holy women in the time of Christ worked upon it (Luke 23:56; 24:1), that the apostles worked upon it (Acts 20:7–13), and that they taught the disciples to work upon it. 1 Cor. 16:2. And having “found his law” which says that the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord our God, upon whom our hopes of everlasting life depend, we propose to “allow its authority and be guided by it,” even to the keeping of the seventh day and working on the first. And we think those legislatures which have been enacting laws for Sunday, which are “inside or short of God’s law,” are indeed “guilty of high treason and of usurpation.” We agree that what we are to do is to “obey the law already made,” which is the law for the seventh day, and that no law of God, given to regulate moral obligation, can ever become a dead letter, but is a “living voice” that must be obeyed. The report continues:—

“The preacher went on to say that, by the senators who were preparing to vote upon the question of Sabbath observance, the present hour should be spent with the open Bible in their hands—spent in a search for the teachings of God. Their debates, again, on the floor of the Senate should be based on this question: What saith the Lord? Their aim should be to level the law up to God’s ideal of Sabbath worship, and not to level it down to the ideal of the barkeeper, the Sunday newspaper, and the profane pleasure-seeker. The higher law should be opened in the Senate chamber next Tuesday, and the law of men made to square with the law of God.”

So we also say, Open your Bibles and “search for the teachings of God.” But you will not find that the Bible has ever said anything about Sunday sabbatizing. “The law of men should be made to square with the law of God.” Good again. But if it is, we shall hear no more about Sunday legislation.

Following this comes a powerful appeal to the office-seeker:—

“Those who helped to do that would gain undying reputation in the commonwealth. There was yet enough character in the old Bay State to make such heroes popular for life; there was enough left of the spirit of Plymouth rock to give such men a firm and immovable stand among us; enough of patriotism to place them in our legislative halls as many times as they might be willing to accept position at the hands of the people.”

This will be a potent argument with many. But the next paragraph is aimed to touch another string by more than hinting to the Christian who already holds office that he will lose it if he suffers Sunday to be secularized:—

“The people demanded a God-ordained Sabbath as a public acknowledgment of the nation’s obligations to the Supreme Law-giver. It was said that Sabbath observance would be a violation of the conscience. Yes, the conscience of the Sabbath-breaker, of the infidel and atheist, and of every one opposed to Christianity; but not the conscience of the Christian. Secularize our Sabbath, open our public departments on that day, make Sunday a day of labor, and constitute it also the day of election, as in France, and they would disfranchise every conscientious Christian in the land, and exclude him from the offices of the country. Destroy the Sabbath, and they would make Christian citizenship an impossibility.”

The closing part of the discourse was a defense of the enforcement of the Sunday by law, and an appeal to the superstitious fears of the people to avoid God’s judgments by strictly keeping the first day, as if doing so would be to pass “righteous” Sabbath laws, and not to do so would be to oppose themselves to God and go out of existence. It reads:—

“The preacher next met the argument that to enforce Sabbath observance would be un-American, by pointing out that the Republic was founded by Sabbatarians, and that the institution of Sabbath was as American as the Republic itself. That cry mostly came from foreigners, who wished to foreignize America. He did not propose to be foreignized, and he proposed that every man who came to this country should be Americanized. Let the knowledge go abroad of the true source of America’s greatness. Pass righteous Sabbath laws, and they proclaimed to the world would tell that God was our refuge and truth, and that it was he who had guided them in their national life.

“Finally they demanded Sabbath observance as a nation to protect them from the judgments of Almighty God. If they would save America from the thunderbolts of the righteous God, then they must keep themselves in true allegiance to him. Nations had their judgments like men. ‘I say to America to-day,’ said Mr. Gregg, in closing, ‘do not oppose yourself to the God of the whole world, and go out of existence, but maintain your loyalty to the Sabbath, and maintain the worship of the Pilgrim Fathers,p. 281 and you shall have the blessing of God forever and ever.’”

If all these utterances are honest, as we have no reason to question, they reveal to Sabbath-keepers the work they have to do: it is not only to teach those who do not profess to have learned what the Scriptures say on this question, but to teach the teachers themselves what the doctrine of the Bible is, and to unteach the people what they have been falsely taught. For to disobey is to die and perish. “That is history.”