There are at present remarkable indications of prosperity in the popular churches of our land. No one who has been at all conversant with their work for the past few years can have failed to notice this fact. The religious papers have been full of it. In their summaries of the work in different parts of the land nothing strikes the eye more frequently than paragraphs like the following: “The Methodist church at ——, Ohio, has been blessed with a powerful revival effort under the direction of Rev. ——, and scores have professed faith in Christ as the result.” “Over one hundred persons have been added to the Baptist church at ——, Wis., as the result of a three weeks’ series of meetings just concluded in that place, etc.”
The N. Y. Independent gives in tabulated form the gains of each of the principal churches of this country for the year 1886. The M. E. Church heads the list, with a net gain of 175,000; next comes the Baptist, with a gain of 160,332; next the Lutheran, with 37,628; then the Presbyterian, with 17,784; the Congregational, with 17,815; the Episcopal, with 19,541, and others with smaller numbers, making a grand total of 481,637 in the United States for Christendom as a whole. Such are some of the results which the churches contemplate with much satisfaction and accept as an evidence of the divine power which dwells within their borders.
In the mind of every believer in present truth, the query must necessarily arise, What does all this mean? For it needs no argument to prove that between them and us there lies somewhere a great mistake. If God is with the popular churches, he is not with us, and the indications of his guiding hand which have seemed to attend our work from its beginning are only imaginary. If he is with us, he has not been with the popular churches in any marked manner since they rejected the Advent message of 1843–4, and they are congratulating themselves over delusive appearances, and a prosperity which has no existence in fact. The hand of God cannot direct two movements so antagonistic in nature.
From our stand-point, either of these alternatives is bad enough. The first we cannot accept so long as the pillars of our faith in the revealed word remain unmoved. Faith is superior to and independent of appearances, and the basis of our faith is the word of God. If the Bible means anything to us, it means that the messages of Revelation 14 are now being given to the world, and that those engaged in this work constitute the remnant Church which “keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.” If it does not mean this, we may at once abandon all hope of ever knowing what it does mean.
We are aware that to assume that this revival work, so unquestionably accepted by all the churches, is not genuine, will cause the hands of Christendom to be raised in holy horror at our seeming narrow-mindedness and want of charity, and only the strong evidences to which we cannot shut our eyes lead us to take such a position. And yet this would not be the first instance of such a thing in the history of the Christian Church. The history of the fourth and fifth centuries after Christ furnishes most remarkable instances of wholesale conversions to the Church, which progressed until almost the entire pagan empire of Rome became professors of Christianity. Doubtless such a result occasioned great satisfaction and rejoicing at that time among the mass of professors, but we know now that that work was not genuine, and led directly to the great apostasy of the Dark Ages. And we have been expecting just such manifestations as we now see, and are at no loss to account for them. On this point we quote from “Vol. IV.,” pp. 295, 296:—
“Notwithstanding the wide-spread declension of faith and piety in the churches, the Lord still has honest children among them; and before his judgments shall be visited upon the earth, many ministers and lay members will separate from these bodies, and gladly receive the special truths for this time. The enemy of souls designs to hinder this work, and before the time shall come for such a movement, he will arouse what appears to be great religious interest in the churches. They will exult that God is working marvelously for them, when the work is that of another spirit. Under a religious guise, Satan will spread his influence over the land. He hopes to deceive many by leading them to think that God is still with the churches.”
The inquiry then arises, What is the nature of this work? Did it bear intrinsic evidence of a genuine work of conversion, it would indeed be difficult of explanation; but, alas! it is only too manifest that such evidence does not exist. Here we could do no better than to quote again from the same chapter, words which no intelligent observer will be likely to deny:—
“In a genuine revival, when the Spirit of God convicts the conscience, the earnest, anxious inquiry will be heard, ‘What must I do to be saved?’ And this is not merely for a day. With every truly converted soul the relation to God and to eternal things will be the great topic of life. But where, in the popular churches of to-day, is the deep conviction of sin? where is the spirit of consecration to God? The spirit that controls the world rules in the Church. Religion has become the sport of infidels and skeptics because so many who bear its name are ignorant of its principles. The power of godliness has well-nigh departed from the churches. Heart union with Christ is a rare thing now. The majority of church-members know no tie but that which joins them to an organized body of professed Christians. Love of pleasure and thirst for excitement are everywhere prevalent. Picnics, church theatricals, church fairs, fine houses, personal display, have banished thoughts of God. Lands and goods and worldly occupations engross the mind, and things of eternal interest receive hardly a passing notice.”
“The apostle Paul, in relating his experience, presents an important truth concerning the work to be wrought in conversion. He says: ‘I was alive without the law once,’—he felt no condemnation; ‘but when the commandment came,’ when the law of God was urged upon his conscience, ‘sin revived, and I died.’ Then he saw himself a sinner, condemned by the divine law. . . . He says further, ‘I had not known sin, but by the law; for I had not known lust, except the law had said, Thou shalt not covet.’ . . . ‘Wherefore, he says,’ ‘the law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good.’”
How many of those whom modern revivals bring into the church have anything resembling this experience of Paul’s?—Very few, it is safe to assert. And how much use is made of the law of God as a factor in these conversions? If it has been so used at all, the fact has been carefully concealed from public notice. Between these revivals and those of fifty years ago, there is a marked contrast, which the most enthusiastic popular professor of to-day cannot deny. How is this contrast accounted for? These are questions which those who have spoken so confidently of this work might well pause to consider.
We would not go so far as to say that there have been no good features in connection with these efforts of the churches, or even that much good, in the aggregate, has not been accomplished; but that God has blessed and prospered these churches in the striking manner which the events of the past year or two seem to indicate, cannot be harmonized with the facts we have presented. Let none be deceived by these appearances into the belief that he is thus pouring out his Spirit upon those who neglect the warnings of his word and so largely ignore the claims of his law. L. A. S.