Ever since the day when our first parents learned hypocrisy and deceit by taking of the forbidden fruit, the world has been full to the brim of fraud and imposture of every magnitude and description; and it is safe to say that never has there been more of this in the world than at the present time. Being familiar with this fact, men are constantly on the lookout for it, and ready to label anything “Fraud” which cannot give the most indubitable proofs of its genuineness. But as human judgment is erring and short-sighted, it very often happens that what is genuine is labeled fraud, and vice versa. If, however, they would avail themselves of all the resources at their command, they would make fewer mistakes in this direction than they do.
A committee of learned men from the University of Pennsylvania, after several years of careful study and investigation, have applied this label to the phenomena of modern Spiritualism, and their verdict has gone before the public. They secured the services of a professional juggler, and attended séances conducted by a large number of mediums, professional and non-professional, many of whom, however, they found to be averse to giving exhibitions for such a purpose as the commission had in view. “As soon,” say the commission, “as investigation worthy of the name begun, all manifestations of spiritualistic power ceased. The juggler in their employ performed all the feats witnessed at any of the séances, and with greater skill than the ‘spirit,’ and the commission therefore reported that Spiritualism ‘presented the melancholy spectacle of gross fraud imposed upon an uncritical portion of the community.’”
If this report be correct, it strikes us that there is not only a melancholy spectacle presented here, but a very singular one as well. We have the spectacle of something which is a mere sham, a piece of mere human trickery, rising in the United States and spreading with unparalleled rapidity to all parts of the world, and in a few years numbering its converts by millions, not of the “uncritical” and credulous, but of the learned and great men of the earth. We see this flimsy fraud going before kings and potentates, such as Queen Victoria, Napoleon III., Pius IX., Alexander II., and others, and making them believers in its claims. We see several learned journals published in the interests of this imposture, and we see it to-day, after forty years of existence, stronger than ever before, although it has not shunned publicity, and rapidly working its way up to the position of a recognized form of the Christian religion. Is not this one of the most wonderful and long-lived examples of mere fraud which has ever been palmed off upon the inhabitants of this fallen world? We should say that it was. History furnishes no record of its parallel.
And further, if we are to accept the testimony of science upon this subject, we must accept a testimony which contradicts itself. Only a few years before an equally reliable commission of professors from Heidelberg University, Germany, after as thorough a canvass of the subject, rendered a verdict which, while not in harmony with the claims of Spiritualism, was wholly contrary to the report of the Pennsylvania commission. Which one of these reports shall we believe? For there is no evidence that one is not just as reliable as the other. The safer way in such cases is to be very slow about accepting either.
There is a better source than science to which we may appeal for information on this question. In the word of God are revealed things which science cannot fathom. Had either of these commissions carefully studied the teachings of this word, instead of appealing to science, they would have obtained far greater light on the subject, and would not have returned reports which were contradictory.
They would have found first that the phenomena of modern Spiritualism are not by any means peculiar to the nineteenth century, but have been known from very early times. They would have found that persons who consulted familiar spirits, which is exactly what modern Spiritualists claim to do, were common in the days of the children of Israel, and that God gave strict directions to the rulers of Israel that all such persons should be put to death; that the heathen nations driven out before the children of Israel were largely given over to these practices; that King Saul just before his death went to consult a woman who claimed to hold communion with the dead, as did also some of the subsequent kings of Israel, and that there were persons of like character in the days of the apostles, who exercised their supernatural power in seeking to resist the truth; and further, that the Bible never speaks of these manifestations as a fraud, but always ascribes to them a genuine character. Are we then to believe that these things which flourished in past ages of the world, have suddenly gone out of existence,—that in this age of the world there are no wizards, witches, necromancers, and consulters with familiar spirits? Can any one tell why such persons should not exist now as well as formerly? Perhaps some of our orthodox friends who are so positive that the manifestations of Spiritualism are mere humbug, will be willing to explain to us how this is.
The Scriptures also tell us that “by their fruits ye shall know them;” and there is nothing which in its character and teachings so plainly bears the imprint of cloven hoofs as does modern Spiritualism. Why should a mere humbug have this feature connected with it? In what way is that which is mere human trickery aided by denying the atonement, the Bible, the divinity of Christ, the sacredness of marriage, and giving license to almost every evil? These are some things which the commission failed to investigate. Certainly from the nature of Spiritualism, if not from its manifestations, we may know there is something more behind it than humbug and jugglery.
Altogether, if Spiritualism be a fraud such as the commission from Pennsylvania have reported, it is a most singular and remarkable fraud indeed.
L. A. S.