APPARENT CONTRADICTIONS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 19, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 29.

Read the full edition

APPARENT CONTRADICTIONS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT

THE BIBLE.—NO. 9.

BY ELD. J. P. HENDERSON.

APPARENT CONTRADICTIONS OF THE NEW TESTAMENT.

In order to understand the Bible thoroughly, or any other book written in ancient times, it is necessary to have some knowledge of the times in which it was written. We must know something of the manners and customs of the people, the nature and lay of the country, their commercial intercourse and relationship with other nations, and the language and dialects in use.
To understand the teachings of the New Testament, we must associate ourselves with Christ and the writers of it. We must follow them in their journeyings among the rocks and mountains of Palestine. We must go with them in the desert places, or walk with them by the sea-side, or cross the turbulent waters. We behold the multitudes gathering about Christ, eager and anxious to receive whatever ministering gift he has to bestow upon them. We behold the miraculous healing of the blind man, the curing of the maniac, the raising of the widow’s son, and the many wonderful things that were done.
Besides this, we hear the plain and simple, yet forcible, language used, often expressed in a figurative way, yet not to be misunderstood. To the poor fishermen Christ says, “Follow me, and I will make you fishers of men.” To his disciples he says, “Behold, I send you forth as sheep in the midst of wolves.” In his illustrations he says, “I am the vine, ye are the branches;” “I am the good shepherd, and know my sheep;” “I am the door: by me if any man enter in, he shall be saved, and shall go in and out, and find pasture.” All such expressions were well understood by the people, and could mislead no one.
Skeptics endeavor to involve some of these sayings in “absurdities” or make out of them what they are pleased to call “contradictions.” Before noting some of these “contradictions,” it will be well to reflect that the four evangelists of the New Testament—Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John—have each given us a separate memoir of Christ’s life and teaching, one not knowing of the writings of the other. Yet so harmonious are these writings that it requires the closest scrutiny of the Bible’s bitterest enemies to find even “apparent contradictions.” It is a rare thing that two separate writers have ever given the biography of a single individual, and we might say an impossibility for them to do so, and not have some contradictory statements. Yet here we have a precedent unequaled, of four writers independent of each other, working in perfect harmony.
Of the so-called “contradictions,” we will notice first—

THE GENEALOGY OF CHRIST.

Matt. 1: 1–18 gives forty-two generations, beginning with Abraham and ending with Joseph, the husband of Mary; while Luke 3: 23–38 makes it fifty-six generations. The record in Matthew makes Jacob the father of Joseph, while that of Luke gives Heli as his father.
Dr. Bloomfield, in his Greek Testament, says this difficulty is explained “by supposing that Matthew gives the genealogy of Joseph, and Luke that of Mary; and therefore the former, who wrote principally for the Jews, traces the pedigree from Abraham to David, and so through Solomon’s line to Joseph, the legal father of Jesus. It must be remembered that among the Jews legal descent is always reckoned in the male line. While Luke, who wrote for the Gentiles, traces the pedigree upward from Heli, the father of Mary, to David and Abraham, and thence to Adam, the common father of all mankind.”
The Jews never permitted women to enter into their genealogical tables, as we are informed by various writers; and if the youngest member of the family happened to be a daughter, the name of her husband was inserted instead of her name, and he was reckoned as the son of one who was in reality only his father-in-law. According to the Talmud, Heli was the father of Mary the mother of Christ, and she was his only child and heiress; consequently, when Joseph married her, he became the only son and heir of Heli. The generations of Heli happened to be more than those of Jacob, the father of Joseph direct, which does no violence to the record.

LENGTH OF TIME CHRIST LAY IN THE TOMB.

“For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.” Matt. 12: 40. “And it was the third hour, and they crucified him. . . . It was the preparation, that is, the day before the Sabbath. . . . Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week.” Mark 15: 25, 42; 16: 9.
The expression used in Matt. 12: 40 is what is known as a synecdoche; that is, a phrase in which a part is spoken of as the whole. Similar modes of expression are used in our day. For instance, “I was in the city all day,” when it may have lacked several hours of it. Three days of grace are allowed on bills of exchange, yet if the bill is due on the third day of the month, say Monday, it is collectible on the fifth day, or Wednesday. So that it is actually only one whole day and a part of two days, instead of three whole days of twenty-four hours each.
“Day and night” was a common term among the Jews, who applied it to any part of the time reckoned as a day or night. In fact, we find that the scriptural method of computing time is to “reckon a part as the whole.” In Jer. 25: 1, the 33d month of Jehoiakim’s reign is reckoned as belonging to his fourth year, when it was but two full years and the fragments of two others, not quite three years in all. So in Esther 4: 16 and 5: 1 a transaction is mentioned that proves that the expression “day and night” means only what we call a day. Esther and the Jews were to fast three days and three nights, and as the day on which the command was given is included, and the third day was the day of the banquet, also included, in reality there were but one whole day and two nights and a part of two other days, yet the expression covers three days and three nights. In Gen. 1 “the evening and the morning” reckoned as one day, occurs no less than six times. In Gen. 7: 17 the term “forty days” is used for forty days and forty nights. In like manner the expression in Matt. 12: 40 may be explained. As Jonah was three days and three nights in the fish, so the Son of man was to be in the earth; that is, simply three days, and not necessarily seventy-two hours.
“Three days and three nights” was the Hebrew form of expression, meaning the same as the term “day” when used by us. See 1 Sam. 30: 12, 13. Jonah was swallowed by the fish one day (day and night), and was discharged from it the third day (day and night); so, also, Christ was crucified, and rose again the third day (day and night).

THE HOUR OF THE CRUCIFIXION.

“And it was the third hour, and they crucified him.” Mark 25: 25. “And it was . . . about the sixth hour: and he saith unto the Jews, . . . Shall I crucify your King?” John 19: 14, 15.
According to Dr. Clarke and others, the true reading of John 19: 14 should be trite, the third, instead of hekte, the sixth, a mistake in copying which might readily have occurred, as the Greek letter gamma, used to denote three, might easily be mistaken for sigmata, which signifies six, the two characters being very much alike. This is more apparent from the fact that some ancient manuscripts read trite, third, instead of hekte, six.

TIME OF MARY’S VISIT TO THE TOMB.

“And very early in the morning, the first day of the week, they came unto the sepulcher at the rising of the sun.” Mark 16: 2. “The first day of the week cometh Mary Magdalene, early, while it was yet dark, unto the sepulcher.” John 20: 1.
The grammar of the language gives the solution. John says, “While it was yet dark cometh Mary Magdalene,” etc., which shows that she was on her way coming to the sepulcher while it was yet dark; and according to Mark they did not reach it until the rising of the sun.
Wakefield’s translation fully sustains this position. He renders John 20: 1, “Now upon the first day of the week Mary Magdalene setteth out early in the morning, while it was yet dark, toward the tomb.”
The word rendered cometh in our version, is from the Greek word erchetai, and is the present tense of the verb erchomai, which is defined thus: “To issue, come forth, arise from,” etc. Hence the literal reading of John 20: 1 would be that Mary was coming forth, or arising from her home to go toward the sepulcher.
In Matt. 28: 1, compared with the above texts, we have also an apparent contradiction, which is easily harmonized in the same way. Our version reads: “In the end of the Sabbath, as it began to dawn toward the first day of the week, came Mary Magdalene,” etc. Wilson’s Emphatic Diaglott renders it: “Now after the Sabbath, as it was dawning to the first day of the week, Mary . . . went to see the tomb.” It is probable that the entire night was spent in anxious preparation for the anointing of the body (Luke 23: 56) and in coming to the tomb, which they would scarcely dare to approach until broad daylight. The writers, knowing these facts, have clothed their expressions so as to include the work of the entire night.
The following, condensed from Mrs. H. V. Reed’s writings, and credited to Dr. Horn, gives some of the reasons why these discrepancies occur:—
1. The different sources from whence the inspired writers draw their narratives. Thus, the twelve apostles were absent from Christ at various times, and all did not witness the events they record, but learned of them from others.
2. The different designs in writing; e. g., Matthew wrote the genealogy of Christ for the benefit of the Jews. Luke gave it for the benefit of the Gentiles.
3. The same persons and places sometimes had several names, and one writer would use one and another, another. Thus he who was nominated for the apostle is called Justus, Joseph, and Barsabas. Acts 1: 23. Joses and Barnabas are the names of the same apostle. “En-mishpat” and “Kadesh,” in Gen. 14: 7 are rendered Magdala in Matt. 15: 39, and Dalmanutha in Mark 8: 10. The country of the Gergesenes, in Matt. 8: 28, is called Gadarenes in Mark 5: 1.
4. Several persons and places sometimes had the same name. Thus there was one Bethlehem in the tribe of Zebulun (Josh. 19: 15), and another in Judea. Matt. 2: 6. There were two towns called Cana. Josh. 19: 28; John 2: 1. There were several Zechariahs, and Herods, etc.
5. Things were often related in different orders.
6. Sacred writers sometimes speak in general or round numbers, as we do to-day, and are not specific.
7. The writers sometimes quote from the Septuagint, and sometimes from the Hebrew text.
8. Some events are referred to by the writers of the New Testament which are not noticed in the Old Testament, and which were undoubtedly found in books now extant.
While we are willing to admit that there are apparent contradictions, we positively deny that there is a single one in the entire Bible that cannot be accounted for.
“Ho, every one that thirsteth, come ye to the waters, and he that hath no money; come ye, buy, and eat. . . . Wherefore do ye spend money for that which is not bread? and your labor for that which satisfieth not? hearken diligently unto me, and eat ye that which is good, and let your soul delight itself in fatness. . . . Hear and your soul shall live.”