AdventAI

ORTHODOXY AND HETERODOXY.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 29., July 19, 1887

DECLINE OF ONE AND INCREASE OF THE OTHER IN NEW YORK.

On the above subject the St. Louis Globe Democrat of July 3, contains the following:—

“Orthodox persons often deplore the limited attendance at the churches, many of which are seldom, if ever, half full. There is room enough, it is said, in the 650 odd churches here, for at least seven or eight times as many persons as visit them, and yet their number is continually increasing. On the other hand, the regular attendance is reported to be slowly, though steadily, declining, despite the earnest efforts of the evangelical to counteract the decline. In the days before the war, it used to be said that strangers who went to church were frequently allowed to stand during service, and that thus the cause of religion was injured. If this were true then, it is true no longer. Now any decently dressed man or woman—and people in New York are always particular about their clothes—is certain to be shown to a seat by a polite sexton or some of his assistants. The churches, even the most fashionable, are glad to encourage visitors, and members rarely neglect to show them any attention and courtesy. If the ecclesiastic edifices exhibit a dispiriting number of empty pews, their conductors are not to be blamed therefor; they certainly do their best to make it otherwise.

“VERY LIBERAL THEOLOGY.”

“A few of the Protestant churches that are considered fashionable draw well. Among these are Grace (Episcopal), Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Tabernacle (Congregational), Fourth Avenue Presbyterian, Madison Avenue Presbyterian, St. Paul’s Methodist. But the bulk of Protestant churches look so very empty, Sunday after Sunday, that I do not wonder that the devout among their congregations grieve.

“The most liberal churches, such as All Souls (Unitarian), the Messiah (Unitarian), and the Fourth Universalist, are numerously frequented. Prof. Felix Adler, the lecturer of the Ethical Society, so crowds Chickering Hall—its seating capacity is 2,000—every Sunday morning that the doors are closed promptly at 11 o’clock. As a rule, the more liberal the clergyman, the larger his congregation. But scarcely any preacher here of the least prominence can be accused of narrowness. Sermons have ceased to be dogmatic or doctrinal. They contain almost no theology; they are substantially moral lectures, and, whether Episcopal, Presbyterian, Baptist or Methodist, are marked by very little difference. The tendency of the time to relinquish sectarianism is particularly observable in the metropolis, where every man, whatever his denomination, has his own opinion on evangelicalp. 455 matters, and has no hesitation in expressing it either. A Brooklyn pastor of the true-blue type recently declared that the New York churches are so lax in faith and discipline as to indicate that they are rapidly going to the Devil.

“Fast as creeds are liberalizing, the people are liberalizing so much faster that those cannot keep pace with these. A very large class of the intelligent and thoughtful have no sympathy with ecclesiastic organizations. Many who were wont to go to church have given up going, though many more still go, for the sake of appearances, who have wholly discarded theology. Agnosticism has been accepted, within ten years, by hundreds, perhaps by thousands, who formerly assumed to adhere to the ordinary interpretation of the Bible. This new term has proved very convenient and gratifying to a host of doubters. It includes latitudinarians, rationalists, skeptics, deists, infidels, atheists. Men are often more alarmed at names than at what the names represent. I am acquainted with dozens of folk who would feel affronted to be called infidels or atheists, who have not the slightest objection to agnostic. Its significance is somewhat indefinite. Being Greek, it sounds learned, and denotes a degree of intellectuality. Oddly enough, I hear inquiries every few days as to the exact meaning of agnostic, which shows that the educated public has no very clear idea regarding it.

“AGNOSTICISM.”

“Lately, in conversation with a well-known and able man—you would recognize him at once if I should mention his name—who was enlarging on the new movement, as he styled it, the subject of agnosticism was broached. He said that very few persons had any conception of its prevalence, in this city particularly; that any number of men and women believed in it thoroughly, but made no reference to it, unless the topic were introduced. He defined it to be not necessarily hostile to theology, but independent of it. It is religion, without supernaturalism, the religion of nature and actual life. There is not, nor can there be, sin or evil in belief or disbelief, which are conditions of the mind, having no relation to morals. An intelligent, independent man should believe nothing that cannot be proved. The end of life is not the pursuit of happiness, which is mere selfishness, but the discharge of duty. Utility, broadly and accurately considered, is the standard of right, which is best attained by the greatest freedom of thought and criticism. Nothing can be known of the truth or falsity of theology in this life, and, therefore, we should waste no time in thinking about it. Agnosticism provides a rule of conduct established by experience, sympathy, and the investigations of science. If we follow that rule, we do not need any religion in the accepted sense. That will enable us to live honestly, act nobly, help our fellows. If there be another life, of which we can never know anything here, we shall deserve it by the performance of duty. If there be no other life, we shall have acted wisely, and have done our best in this life by regulating our own conduct and striving to benefit our fellows.

“I have heard a great many talk on this theme, and this is pretty nearly their form of belief. It is said to be the practical religion to which thoughtful minds are tending here and throughout civilization.”