AdventAI

SUNDAY-SCHOOL LESSONS VS. BIBLE.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 22., May 31, 1887

In the International S. S. lesson for June 12, we find the following comments on the fourth commandment, under the heading, “Helps over Hard Places.” The effort is to make the Sunday Sabbath fit that commandment; and it is indeed one of the “hard places” to get over, and one where every unsophisticated student needs a good deal of “help.” The writer says:—

“8. The Sabbath: the word means ‘rest.’ 9. Six days . . . labor: it is our duty to work and be active on the six days. 10. The seventh: every seventh day, as our present Sunday is. . . . 11. In six days: not our days of twenty-four hours, but God’s days; the periods of creation which are exactly like days. Rested: stopped creating. Nothing new on earth has been created since man. The seventh day: since man was created is God’s seventh day, in which he is caring for the spiritual wants of man.”

That which first arrests attention in the foregoing “helps over hard places,” is the expression, “every seventh day as our present Sunday is.” This purports to be an explanation of the words of the commandment, “The seventh day” is the Sabbath, etc. But why say “every seventh day”? The commandment does not say so; all it says is “the seventh.” Men seem to feel the necessity of changing the phraseology before they can make it appear that the Sabbath is movable to the first day of the week. Hence they say “a seventh,” or “any seventh,” or “every seventh.” How they dare to take such unwarrantable liberties with the words of Jehovah must be left for them to explain. And why say, “as our present Sunday is.” Let them begin to talk the next moment about the resurrection of Christ, and we will hear them exclaiming, “Oh! in honor of the resurrection of Christ, we keep every first day, as our present Sunday is.” Can Sunday be both the seventh day and the first? Have we any week or have we not? And is there any one in the land so profoundly wise that he is able to tell the days of the week?

Confusion and contradiction characterize the arguments urged in behalf of Sunday-keeping; but in no one thing do its advocates seem to be more unanimous than in the position set forth in the foregoing commandment, that the commandment does not point out any definite day, but any seventh day after six of labor, or every seventh day, as above stated. And thus about the first dodge made by theological teachers when we quote to them the fourth commandment in behalf of the seventh day, is, “Oh! it don’t say the seventh day of the week.” In reference to this we wish to offer a few thoughts to those who are disposed to consider the subject of the Sabbath with any feelings of candor and moral responsibility:—

1. There is a division of time called a week, consisting of just seven days.

2. This division of time does not originate from anything in nature; that is, it does not arise like the day, from the revolution of the earth on its axis, nor like the seasons and the year, from the motion of the earth around the sun, nor like the lunar cycles, from the motions of the moon, etc. It can be attributed to only one thing, and that is the creation of the world. The six days during which God labored and the one he devoted to rest, give us the requisite period of seven days; and when God then and there sanctified the seventh day to holy uses (Gen. 2: 2, 3) in distinction from the other days which were left for secular purposes, it necessarily and inevitably threw all coming time into periods of sevens, and gave us the week.

If any should be disposed to deny this origin of the week, they would have to admit, unless they should deny the record in Genesis, (1) that circumstances existed in the beginning which would necessarily give rise to such a division of time, but they did not; and (2) that we now have such a division, coeval with history and co-extensive with civilization, for the origin of which no reason can be assigned.

3. The fourth commandment refers solely and exclusively to this division of time. This must be admitted by all who appeal to that commandment in behalf of a weekly Sabbath. For if it does not refer to the week, then there is no proof whatever therein that a Sabbath should be observed every week. But all who contend for a Sabbath at all, have it come weekly.

4. Such being the origin of the week, and such the nature of the fourth commandment, does it not inevitably follow beyond all shadow of controversy, that any numerical adjective applied to the Sabbath assigning to it its position in the order of its number as related to other days, must refer to this division of time which originated with the Sabbath, namely, the week. Such numeral would therefore assign the Sabbath its position in the week; and when the commandment says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath,” it is just the same as if it said, “The seventh day of the week is the Sabbath;” for it can refer to nothing else.

It is scarcely necessary to add that the week at the present time synchronizes in its order of days, with the New Testament week; and it was the seventh day of that week which God designated at Sinai and pointed out by the miracle of the manna for forty years as the Sabbath, and which Christ recognized, kept, and vindicated as the Sabbath of the law in his day.

The next effort to help the student over a “hard place” in the foregoing commandment, helps him into a much harder place than it helps him over. The days, it says, were “not our days of twenty-four hours,” but periods of creation. The conclusion follows that we are still in the seventh period. “Since man was created is God’s seventh day, in which he is caring,” etc. This throws upon the student the necessity of explaining how this can be, and yet the record in Genesis be true. That just as positively asserts that the seventh day (or period, if it was a period) has come to an end as that any others of the seven have ended. God blessed and sanctified the day, we read, because that in it he had rested. But if he is still passing his seventh day, his rest is not yet completed, and the statement that he blessed and sanctified it because he had rested upon it, is not only not the work of inspiration, but is the work of man, and as much worse than that of ordinary men, as ap. 345 falsifier and deceiver is worse than one who tells the truth.

Two things about such an exposition are surprising: the first is, that any one should so carelessly contradict the record in Genesis; and the second is, that he could suppose that anything is to be gained by such a construction of that passage, so long as the record remains of what God spoke from Sinai, twenty-five hundred years later. The connection between Ex. 20: 8-11 and Gen. 1: 1-31; 2: 1-3, is too close to be broken. No one will dispute that at Sinai the days of which the record speaks were “our days of twenty-four hours.” Seven of these constituted a week. The seventh of these was to be remembered and observed as the Sabbath. For in six just such days the Lord made heaven and earth, and on just such a seventh day rested, and, having rested, blessed and sanctified it. The days of Ex. 20: 11 upon which God worked, are the same as those of verse 9 on which men were required to work. How would it sound to read it: “Six days shalt thou labor, but on the seventh, which is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God, thou shalt rest; for in six great periods the Lord made heaven and earth, and rested the seventh great period, wherefore the Lord blessed the seventh great period and hallowed it.”

So expressed, or so understood, the time man is required to keep bears no relation to the time blessed and hallowed, and there is no connection whatever between the command and the reason assigned therefor.

Take the record as it reads, humbly perform the duties it enjoins, and there are no “hard places” to be “helped over.” All the hard places are manufactured by efforts to make the word uphold an unscriptural practice. It can never be done; and the sooner the attempt is abandoned the better.