IS IT FAIR?

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 31, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 22.

Read the full edition

IS IT FAIR?

It is enough to stir feelings of pity in the heart of a stone to witness the embarrassment of grave doctors of divinity over the records of the Evangelists in reference to the first day of the week as the Sabbath, and to see them tug and toil to expand the meager testimony into an array of proofs which will make anything like a respectable showing, that the Sabbath has been changed from the seventh to the first day of the week. With all the gravity they can command they will seize upon a statement which is at best but incidental, turn it over on this side and that, hammer it till it is thinner than gold leaf and more transparent than tissue paper, link with it what few other like statements they can find, stretch it till every fiber is in danger of parting asunder, and then exclaim, There! see what an array of testimony there is to show that the new order of things introduced by Christ is a new creation, and the first day of the week has been ordained as a Sabbath to commemorate it! It is as if a man should try to pitch a tent with one strip of cloth; so erecting a frame which will support one end of the strip, he takes the observer around where he can look upon the broad side of it, and says, “Behold the spacious tent.” But walking around where we can look at it from the other side, we find that it has neither sides nor end, neither length, breadth, nor circumference, and as a tent does not amount to any particular sum. Just so with the New Testament records as proof for Sunday-keeping.
We have before us two works, one called, “The Lord’s Day the First day of the Week, not the Seventh,” by H. C. Benson, D. D.; the other, “The Lord’s Day Our Sabbath,” by James H. Potts, D. D.; in both of which the effort above referred to is a prominent feature. The fact that Christ appeared to his disciples on the first day of the week is the material they have to work with, and out of which they undertake to manufacture a first-day Sabbath. Mr. Benson says: “On the morning of that glorious first day the Sun of righteousness poured a flood of light upon the sin-cursed world.” “‘On the first day of the week,’ the risen Lord appeared, first to the women, and next to them to the disciples.” “The last interview of that momentous day is recorded in John 20: 19–22: ‘Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.’” “He was not seen again till the week had passed—no revelation of himself on the seventh day; but again on the ‘first day,’ as he evidently had signified his purpose to meet with his disciples when assembled for worship, he came. See John 20: 26: ‘And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them; then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.’ These Sunday evening interviews occurred where Christians were assembled for worship. Had they not been divinely guided, they doubtless would have met on the seventh day. But so far as we can learn from the Gospels, Jesus never once appeared to the Jews or any other worshiping congregation on the seventh day. He gave no shadow of approval to the Jewish Sabbath. It was dead, utterly abolished forever.”
Having spoken of these two days, he skips some very interesting occasions which he might have mentioned, and passes over to the Pentecost. He says: “The next notable event in the record, bearing on this question, was the Pentecost,” etc., pp. 35–37.
Any careful student of the Bible will agree with us that here is a wonderful structure made out of a very little material. In the first place there is not a worshiping assembly mentioned or even intimated in the whole record. Wonderful worshiping assembly, was it not, on that first evening when the disciples were “at meat,” taking their supper, and Christ appeared and “upbraided them for their unbelief,” because they would not believe he was risen, even on the testimony of those who had seen him? Mark 16: 14. And this was the interview mentioned in John 20: 19. “On four separate occasions,” says Mr. Benson, “he appeared to his disciples on that day.” P. 39. Were each of these “worshiping assemblies?” The next meeting was “after eight days,” which would be more than a week; but granting that it was just a week, the record simply states that the disciples were again within; and the word “again” necessarily implies that it was on a like occasion when they were gathered for their evening meal. And the occasion is mentioned simply because Thomas, who was conspicuously absent before (John 20: 24), was now present. Verse 26. But there was no worshiping assembly about it.
The third occasion Mr. Benson strangely skips. It is mentioned in John 21: 1–14. We have sometimes wondered why our Sunday friends did not claim that this was on the seventh day; for the disciples were out fishing. Wouldn’t it be capital if it could be shown that the disciples had turned the seventh day into a fishing day! That would clinch the argument. Only if they admit that Christ met with them on any other day but the first, it destroys entirely the significance of his meeting with them on that day. But if this fishing occasion was on the first day of the week, it was at least two weeks from the resurrection of Christ, and shows that he had not yet taught them, and they had not yet learned, that that day was the Sabbath.
And now we come to perhaps as strange a statement as was ever penned even by a doctor of divinity. On p. 39 Mr. Benson says: “The word gives no account of his [Christ’s] visit to any people, after his resurrection, to impart any spiritual gift, on any other day than the first, or Lord’s day.”
Christ was seen of the disciples forty days (Acts 1: 3); and we have never yet seen it disputed that the ascension day was Thursday. The meeting on this occasion was as formal as any, for the record says: “And being assembled together with them,” etc. Acts 1: 4. And he imparted to them spiritual blessings also; for he lifted up his hands and blessed them. Luke 24: 50. Why, then, does this religious teacher assert that there is no record of anything of this kind except on the first day of the week?
Now if this had occurred on the first day of the week, let the reader try to imagine what use would have been made of it. Loud and long would every Sunday trumpet in the land ring over this text. How it would be held up as the day that Christ chose in which to make his royal ascent from earth to heaven, when the everlasting doors would be lifted up, and the King of glory would come in! Would not this be one of the most prominent Sunday texts in all the Bible? Every one knows that it would. There is no sort of question of it. But because this was not on Sunday, how do they treat it?—Not only do they slip over, ignore, and keep it out of sight in the background, but they make the outrageously false statements concerning it, that we quote above from Mr. Benson. We know not how others may look upon such work; but this is what we call dishonesty; it is handling the word of God deceitfully; it is the priest’s lips causing many to stumble at the law (Mal. 2: 7, 8), and is wicked just in proportion as their profession is high.
The reasoning of Mr. Potts in relation to this point is about the same—lifting into the highest prominence every meeting which by any stretch of the imagination can be supposed to have occurred on the first day of the week, but carefully ignoring every meeting which occurred on other days.
We submit the question to every candid Sunday-keeper whether this is a fair and honest way of treating the subject. Giving the utmost latitude possible to their claim, these teachers have only two different first-days on which Christ met his disciples, namely, the resurrection day and eight days after. But there were just as many meetings which were not on the first day, namely, John 21: 1–14 and the ascension day, unless it is admitted that the disciples, two weeks after the resurrection of Christ, had no more regard for the first day than to go a fishing upon it. But the ascension day still remains, the last meeting of Christ with his disciples, when he gave them his farewell charge, and left with them his parting blessing; and this was not on Sunday but Thursday. One of two conclusions inevitably follows from this: either his meeting the disciples on the first day had no significance whatever in relation to the day, or it had the same significance in reference to that Thursday on which he ascended; and that day is elevated into a Sabbath also. It matters not which horn of this dilemma they take. Their theory cannot survive the impaling which either one will give it.