SUPPRESSION AND THE SHUT DOOR

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 19, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 29.

Read the full edition

SUPPRESSION AND THE SHUT DOOR.

In the Review of June 14, in the article “Divisions vs. Visions,” it was intimated that other articles on the questions of “Suppression,” “Self-contradictions of the Visions,” etc., might follow if it was desired. Letters and requests received since that time lead us to devote a few thoughts to these points.
In the matter of “suppression,” we presume that the most of our readers, if not all, are well aware of the point at issue. It is simply this: It is claimed that the visions once taught certain views which were then entertained by those who were believers in the visions, but that a few years later the brethren discarded those particular views as unscriptural, and then to save the visions, undertook to suppress their testimony on these points by leaving out and keeping out of sight a portion of what had once been published, in order to convey the impression that the visions had never taught anything of the kind; and it is further claimed that two things are proved by these facts: First, that the visions are of only human origin, and, secondly, that those who have had the charge of their publication were destitute of all moral honesty, willing to devote their lives to the enactment of a great farce, and satisfy their souls with conscious fictions.
The particular view in reference to which it is asserted that this work of suppression has been done, is what is known as “the shut-door view.” That is, immediately after the passing of the time, and the consequent great disappointment in 1844, Adventists generally felt that their work for the world was done, and ceased to labor for the conversion of sinners. It is now claimed that in harmony with this, the visions of sister White taught that probation ended in the autumn of 1844; that there the door of mercy was shut, and that there could be no more conversions after that. After some seven years this view was discarded and an effort was made, so the charge runs, to suppress such portions of the visions as were supposed to teach it.
1. It is an interesting point to inquire when this work was done, and under what circumstances, and what methods were adopted to accomplish it. On the first day of May, 1850, we entered upon a connection with the REVIEW Office, which, with the exception of two brief intervals, has continued to the present time. During all these thirty-four years, therefore, we speak from personal knowledge when we say that there has not been the first suggestion, or the least indication of any desire or intention, to conceal or modify or in the least degree change anything revealed through sister White in vision. All that any one can claim has been done in this direction is therefore over thirty-four years in the past. So much for the time.
2. Now for the circumstances: The first vision was given shortly after the passing of the time and the great disappointment in 1844. In the summer of 1844, the wonderful experience known as the “midnight cry” of the parable of Matt. 25, had occurred. This experience, with the evident fulfillment of prophecy, and the indisputable expiration of the great prophetic period of the 2,300 days of Dan. 8, on the 10th day of the 7th month (Oct. 22), 1844, had made an impression upon some hearts which was not to be effaced. The great issue of that hour was whether that experience was light or darkness, the work of the Lord or the delusions of men. Some could not give it up, and the faith of that class is perpetuated in the S. D. A. movement to the present day. It was with reference to these movements and the situation that the vision was given, and among its utterances were the following:—
“But soon some grew weary, and said the city was a great way off, and they expected to have entered it before. Then Jesus would encourage them by raising his glorious right arm, and from his arm came a light which waved over the Advent band, and they shouted ‘Alleluia!’ Others rashly denied the light behind them, and said that it was not God that had led them out so far. The light behind them went out, leaving their feet in perfect darkness, and they stumbled and lost sight of the mark and of Jesus, and fell off the path down into the dark and wicked world below. [It was just as impossible for them to get on the path again and go to the city, as all the wicked world which God had rejected. They fell all along the path, one after another, until] we heard the voice of God like many waters which gave us the day and hour of Jesus’ coming.”
This, including the words inclosed in brackets, was substantially as it appeared in a tract entitled “A Word to the Little Flock,” published in 1847. But as it appeared in the first edition of “Early Writings,” entitled “Experience and Views,” the words enclosed in brackets were omitted and the word “soon” inserted to connect the sentences.
Here, then, is an inviting posture for the charge of “suppression,” and they haste to enter it. An effort is made to show that Eld. White held to the “shut door” view down as late as May 1850, from an exposition of the parable of Matt. 25, published by him in the Present Truth of that month and year; but that he had changed his views by the time the vision was published in “Experience and Views” in 1851; and hence that portion of the vision was then omitted, because it was not then believed.
But we have before us a fac-simile copy of a little paper called “Girdle of Truth, and Advent Review,” published by Eli Curtis, of New York, and bearing date Jan. 20, 1848. In that paper this vision is published, with the identical portion omitted which it is claimed Eld. White suppressed in 1851. In an introductory remark Mr. Curtis says: “The following vision was published in 1845, ’46, and ’47.” So it seems this vision was published only once with that passage in, but several times without it, and that, be it remembered, before the brethren had changed their views upon the shut-door question. This fact is fatal to the charge of suppression; for it is certain that so long as persons held certain views, and believed that the vision taught the same views, they would not suppress the vision on the ground that they did not believe them. Yet this vision was published in 1845–48, with the portion omitted which it is claimed was the grand foundation of shut-door views that were held and publicly advocated as late as 1850.
3. Again, if the charge of suppression is true, and there was really an intention to make the people believe that the visions did not teach views which they really had taught, something more would be necessary than simply to omit the objectionable passages in subsequent editions. An effort would certainly be made to gather in and destroy all the copies which had been put out before the public; and this could be easily detected. But has anything of this kind been done?—Nothing. No one makes any such claim. And if he did, not a particle of evidence could be produced to sustain it.
4. If it was the intention to suppress the teaching of the visions on what is called the “shut door” subject, then why should not all the testimony of that nature have been suppressed? Can any one conceive a sublimer piece of folly than simply taking out a portion of the testimony, leaving in a remaining portion, and that, too, the most objectionable portion, as we shall show it is, from the objector’s stand-point, with the idea of suppressing something not then believed? Even if it could be proved that these men were knaves, they certainly were not fools.
5. If the charge of suppression could be proved true, it would be nothing against the visions themselves; it would only show a very reprehensible course on the part of those who had charge of their publication; and they alone would have to bear the condemnation due to such a course.
6. With the first impression resting upon their minds after the great disappointment, that their work for the world was done (and it was practically, for the time being; for they could obtain no hearing anywhere), it was natural that those Adventists who could not give up the past should try to apply to the situation the shut door of the parable of Matt. 25; and when they began to receive light on the sanctuary, about the first thing that arrested their attention there was the “closed door” of the first apartment, when the ministration was transferred to the second; and of this, they would naturally, under the circumstances, take an extreme view, making it another pillar in their shut-door theory. Out of the narrowness of this view their minds were first led, and pointed to the open door of the second apartment by a vision in March 1849; and in connection with this it was taught that probation would not absolutely end till the ministry in the most holy place was closed. For we read in the Present Truth of September, 1849, over sister White’s own signature, as follows:—
“When Jesus leaves the Sanctuary, then he that is holy and righteous will be holy and righteous still; for all their sins will then be blotted out, and they will be sealed with the seal of the living God. But those that are unjust and filthy will be unjust and filthy still; for then there will be no priest in the Sanctuary to offer their sacrifices, their confessions, and their prayers before the Father’s throne. Therefore what is done to rescue souls from the coming storm of wrath must be done before Jesus leaves the most holy place of the heavenly Sanctuary.”
So direct was sister White’s teaching on this subject at that early date; yet it was not till the year following that Eld. White published the exposition of Matt. 25: 1–12, which is quoted to prove that he held the ultra shut-door views. And we may add that even after the publication of “Experience and Views” in 1851, when it is claimed that he had changed his views and suppressed the vision to correspond therewith, he still entertained the same view of the parable of Matt. 25 that he held before.
It is apparent from this that they did not consider the views taught by the visions and their views of the shut door dependent upon each other or antagonistic to each other; for it is certain that no one would undertake to suppress a vision because it taught shut-door views, and then continue to hold the same views himself. The idea is absurd.
7. We have said that expressions are retained which from the objector’s stand-point are more objectionable than the ones which he claims have been suppressed. This we will now prove by another extract over which a very great “tempest in a” very little “tea-pot” is raised by the opponents of the visions. In the Present Truth of August, 1849, a vision was published in reference to the wonders of Spiritualism, then beginning to attract the attention of the world, and the spiritual apostasy of the great religious bodies of the land, owing to the moral fall experienced under the second message of Revelation 14, in which it is said:—
“I saw that the mysterious signs and wonders and false reformations would increase and spread. The reformations that were shown me were not reformations from error to truth, but from bad to worse [for those who professed a change of heart had only wrapped about them a religious garb, which covered up the iniquity of a wicked heart. Some appeared to have been really converted, so as to deceive God’s people, but if their hearts could be seen, they would appear as black as ever]. My accompanying angel bade me look for the travail of soul for sinners as used to be. I looked, but could not see it; for the time for their salvation is past.”
The words inclosed in brackets were omitted as the vision was published in “Experience and Views” in 1851. Now it is claimed that they were suppressed because we do not now believe that the time for the salvation of sinners is past. On this view we ask the reader to look carefully at what is omitted and what is retained. If the design was to suppress the testimony, it would be just as practicable and just as easy to suppress the whole as a part, would it not?—Most certainly. And if any one wished to keep out of sight the fact that the visions had taught anything in regard to salvation being past, if he had the least shrewdness, discernment, or common sense, would he not take out the whole passage, or at least that portion of it in preference to any other? We leave it to any reader if this is not the course he would pursue. Yet instead of this a little statement about certain hypocrites who would pretend to be converted when they were not, is omitted, and the objectionable sentence, “The time for their salvation is past,” is retained. It is idle to talk about suppression under these circumstances. Again, we say, call the suppressionists knaves if you like, but don’t set them down as so incomprehensibly stupid as this.
8. Those paragraphs which it is thought there has been such an effort to suppress contain nothing which is not in accord with the sentiments of this people to-day. So if there has been any attempt at suppression, it might just as well not have been done, so far as our present faith is concerned, for we indorse the very points claimed to have been suppressed. Then, it will be said, you believe that probation ended in 1844, and that there can have been no true conversions since that time?—Not by any means; and the visions teach no such thing. Take the quotation first given above. Its special design was to warn against the danger of giving up the light of the past experience. Those who do this, fall off the elevated path they are represented as traveling upon, down into the wicked world below, and become involved in the same darkness. “They fell,” it says, “all along the path, one after another, until we heard the voice of God, like many waters,” etc. The voice of God is yet future, and hence this vision carries us beyond the present time down to the end. Before we reach that time the remnant are to pass through an experience described in another vision given in 1848, and published in “Early Writings,” pp. 29, 30. This speaks of the closing experience of the Church in the time of trouble, and their deliverance at the voice of God. Then another class was seen deeply bewailing their lost condition, as they saw written on their garments the fearful words, “Weighed in the balance and found wanting.” Who are these?—The very ones described in the other vision who fell off the path of truth and gave up the light of the past; for they are those who have once had the truth and rejected it. They do not consider themselves as belonging to the world; for they plead with Christ for acceptance, and exclaim, “We have believed in thy coming and taught it with energy.” That there will be just such a time and just such a class, is clearly taught in the parable of the ten virgins, when the foolish ones return too late, and seek in vain for admittance; and by Christ’s own words in Matt. 7: 22: “Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works? And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity.” Here is where they try to secure again the favor of God, get back upon the path, and go into the city with the overcomers. But can they do it?—No; it is as impossible for them to do this then, as it is for the wicked world whom God has rejected. The vision certainly carries us to that time, and there is evidently where this testimony applies. How gladly we would raise a warning voice to save any one from reaping such bitter fruits of his own self-deception and stubbornness and rebellion against the truth! But many will not hear.
The other extract relates to another class. To understand the closing statement, the previous portions of the vision should be studied, as published on pp. 34–37 of “Early Writings.” It refers to certain ones who “steal the livery of Heaven to serve the Devil in,” and under the garb of religion carry on a work of spiritual deception. The real object of these is to war against the truth. These engage in false reformations and revivals, and resort to mesmeric and other evil influences to carry on their work; but they do not have real travail of soul for sinners such as has been seen in the past, and would be seen in any genuine revival to-day. The reason why they do not have this travail of soul for sinners, is because they do not have any of the grace of God in their own hearts. They have given themselves to practice falsehood and deception, deceiving and being deceived. “The time for their salvation is past.” By no fairness of interpretation, and no sound principle of logic, can this statement be transferred from this class, and applied to sinners in general. Mark the words: “My accompanying angel bade me look for the travail of soul for sinners as used to be.” Where would she look for this? Would she look around among sinners for travail of soul for sinners?—Absurd! She would look to those who professed to be laboring for sinners, to those who were engaging in this false revival work. “I looked,” she says. Where?—To these revivalists. She did not see the travail of soul; with whom?—With these revivalists. Why?—Because “the time for their salvation is past;” whose salvation?—That of the class to which her attention was directed—these false revivalists. It is scarcely less than an insult to common sense to try to apply it to any others. Mark what conclusion follows from the position of our opponents. They say the passage teaches that the time for the salvation of all sinners was past, and that is the reason why there was no travail of soul for them. But those to whom her attention was called are plainly described as “agents of Satan.” Then the conclusion follows that if there had been any hope for sinners all these “agents of Satan” would be experiencing genuine travail of soul for them! They know that sister W. never designed to teach any such thing; and to put such a construction upon her language betrays anything but a candid and ingenuous spirit. She herself explains the matter on p. 2 of Supplement, giving the same solution of the matter that is herewith presented. She says:—
“The ‘false reformations’ referred to on p. 37, are yet to be more fully seen. This view relates more particularly to those who have heard and rejected the light of the advent doctrine. They are given over to strong delusions. Such will not have ‘the travail of soul for sinners’ as formerly. Having rejected the advent, and being given over to the delusions of Satan, ‘the time for their salvation is past.’ This does not, however, relate to those who have not heard and rejected the doctrine of the second advent.”
This is plain and consistent; and authors usually have the privilege of telling what they mean by language they have used, and having it so understood. We do not suppose, and the vision does not teach, that all so-called revivalists are of this class. But that there are among them persons of this stamp, and will be more and more to the end, we have no doubt.
But is it not a great wrong that no marks have been used to indicate these omissions when they have been made? The latest attempt to fix a mortal sin upon somebody, toward a half a century ago, is a little 8-page tract designed to show that it was a great crime that no marks were used to indicate the omissions above noticed. It would have been, of course, correct to use such marks; but it may be wrong to charge that they were purposely omitted with intent to deceive. It may have been because it was not understood that such marks were required, or because of carelessness in regard to inserting them. This tract may have come to the notice of some of our readers, and for this reason we refer to it. With ludicrous gravity it lays down the grammatical law on the subject in the form of a little primer, and then drones through the usual charges of suppression in regard to the foregoing extracts. But the author of the tract has suffered his printer to present him before the public in a most ridiculous light. He gives it the title “Marks or Ellipsis,” instead of calling it, as it should be, “Marks of Ellipsis;” that is, marks indicating an ellipsis, or omission, of some word or words. So it goes through all the sub-divisions, running titles, and every reference to the subject in the work—“Marks or Ellipsis.” Now, we would suggest to our friend, if he essays to appear again in print, that he should place his work in the hands of some one who knows how to use the English language. It sounds so utterly idiotic to keep hearing the expression over and over again—“marks or ellipsis.”
To sum up the evidence, it appears—
  1. That no suppression of the visions has been attempted within at least thirty-four years;
  2. That no evidence of any intention to suppress them at that time can be produced;
  3. That stronger expressions are retained than those which were suppressed.
  4. That they do not teach the views on account of which they were suppressed; and—
  5. That we now believe the very doctrines which the visions were suppressed for teaching.
But all this seems to go for nothing. They will not take our word in regard to what we now believe, nor sister White’s word in regard to what she intended to teach, nor the evidences of the case that there was not and could not have been any suppression under the circumstances. What would satisfy this spirit we do not know. It is a spirit which accuses sister White of having a demon, and arraigns such men as Eld. Geo. I. Butler, the president of the General Conference, as a persistent and deliberate liar. But perhaps we should not be surprised at this; for we remember that our Lord himself was accused of having a devil; and if they call the Master of the house Beelzebub, how much more shall they call them of his household. But we do not care to be identified with that class in either its ancient or modern phase. We prefer rather to labor to come behind in no gift, waiting for the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ.