UNIVERSALISM IN DISGUISE

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 24, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 21.

Read the full edition

UNIVERSALISM IN DISGUISE.

Our readers are doubtless more or less familiar with the “new hypothesis,” so-called, of probation after death, which has arisen in the ranks of the American Board of Foreign Missions, and has caused so much discussion for the past two years in popular religious circles. That it is, in tendency, what we have named it at the head of this article, one of the ablest and most earnest supporters of the theory, Dr. James M. Whiton, openly admits, in a paper recently read before the New York and Brooklyn Association. From this paper the N. Y. Independent quotes as follows:—
“If the ultimate destiny of any heathen is to be determined by their acceptance or rejection in the future world of the Redeemer first presented to them there, will not others have to be admitted in our theory to an equal benefit, who have never been classified as ‘heathen’? How many in Christian lands have never heard the pure gospel of the Son of God? Multitudes who have nominally heard of Christ, have heard of him nominally only, have never had him, rather than a theory or a caricature of him, presented to their conscience in his grace and truth. . . . If such a ministry of redemption were really the utmost of divine grace allotted to the populations for which those churches [of Italy, France, Spain, Germany, Holland, and England] were put in trust with the gospel, it might have been better for them to have been born among the heathen, to whom our Andover friends conjecture that an unadulterated and unperverted gospel may be preached hereafter. And if we candidly survey the successive centuries of Christianity, from the time when the apostolic churches began to lose their primitive purity, it must be admitted that the larger part of those who have ever heard the name of Christ have had him presented to them under forms so incongruous with his Spirit that it must be doubted whether to the mass of nominal Christians any more than to nominal heathen has the real Christ and his real salvation been made known.”
“If, therefore, any one holds that the apparent equities of their case give credibility to a larger hope for the heathen beyond the grave, the same logic must place the larger number of nominal Christians on the same ground. But this, whatever limitations be attached to it, is Restorationism, such as was taught in the early theological schools of Alexandria and Antioch, before Augustine and his successors turned the current of orthodoxy the other way. The outcry raised against the Andover hypothesis by all the denominational journals, proceeds from an intuitive perception that this is the logical issue of it.” . . .
The Andover hypothesis has been steadily gaining ground from the start, and shows no signs of speedily exploding and vanishing into the realms of dead superstition, as probably many have supposed it would. Once started on this road, the reckless adventurer is very likely to go on till he comes to the termination, which is Universalism. There is a recognized danger that it will be so with the American Board and the popular evangelists who have adopted it into their creed. As the Independent says:—
“If any think that the American Board, by some device of consenting councils, can be moved one separate stair in the descent, and left to stay there, they ought at least to take useful counsel from the example of the failure of seventy years ago. They stopped at the outset, and resisted the first downward movement, when Arianism was invitingly preached, and the gospel was presented chiefly as a scheme of beautiful ethics. Anybody can see, who has made himself familiar with recent discussions in the Unitarian conventions at the West, what the movement which they resisted, so slow and almost imperceptible at first, has come to be there in its conclusion. If it has not already reached the bottom, in the declared readiness of some to receive intelligent and respectable atheists into their churches, it cannot surely be a great way above that. It seems to us at least, wise and salutary for the Board to stop where it has been and is. Let it wait, at any rate, before movement is made, to find out how rapidly and how far this airy mirage of a future probation, which has lifted itself so temptingly before men, is to be transformed, by irresistible logic, among those who are attracted to it, into an alleged divine scheme for universal salvation. It seems to us entirely certain, as Dr. Whiton intimates that some who are inclined to it already foresee, that if one goes a mile with this hypothesis, it will straightway compel him to go with it twain.”
All of which is only another illustration of the inevitable result of clinging to the unscriptural dogma of man’s natural immortality. Of course no being gifted with reason could consistently suppose that the poor, ignorant heathen, who lived and died without a glimmer of gospel light, are to be tormented through all eternity in the raging flames of hell, because they did not live out the teachings of the gospel. No; some other supposition must be true, and the most natural one is that they will be given another chance at some future time. And having gone thus far, we only come to the cases of thousands in more civilized lands between whose condition and that of the heathen there is not enough difference to warrant such a terrible contrast in their fates as would be if future probation were granted to one and denied to the other. And so the hypothesis finally becomes wide enough to take in almost everybody, and we take our bearings and discover that we are standing squarely on the platform of final salvation for all. Starting as a small stream, the natural-immortality idea empties into the river of eternal torment, which in turn empties into the lake of Universalism. This lake has many inlets, but no outlet, and as a natural consequence it is steadily rising. So long as men will cling to the immortal-soul fable, they may expect to find themselves landed in all sorts of untenable locations, and impaled on the horns of numerous dilemmas.