CHRISTIAN SCIENCE

7%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 28, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 26.

Read the full edition

CHRISTIAN SCIENCE.

A NUMBER of inquiries have been addressed to this Office, asking our opinion of the system of healing called “Christian Science,” which is attracting so much attention in some quarters.
When we first heard of its claims and modus operandi, we felt prepared to discard it at once on general principles.
And when it appeared that the leaders in the movement proposed to instruct others how to use the “gift,” for the comfortable tuition of one hundred dollars a head, as Simon the sorcerer thought the power of the Holy Spirit was to be bought with money (Acts 8:18, 19), we felt still more confirmed in this position.
And when we glanced through two pamphlets, which a friend kindly sent us to learn our views of them, one called a “Historical Sketch of Metaphysical Healing,” by Mary Baker G. Eddy, and the other, “What is Christian Science?” by Ursula N. Gestefeld,—works which rant along in a transcendental, neological sort of style, very hard for the simple Bible reader to understand,—we felt more assured than ever that the basis of the system, whatever its profession might be, was evil and only evil.
But we prefer to give the views of one who has made a thorough investigation of the subject. J. B. Johnson, of Lincoln, Neb., after thus investigating it, expresses his estimate of it as follows, in the Christian Oracle of June 9, 1887. We commend his views to the attention of any who may be troubled with this new counterfeit of the work of the Lord:—
“Many people have asked me to publish the result of my investigations of Christian Science. I preferred quietly making my investigations, but the knowledge of my quest after information has become so wide-spread, and is being so used as to deceive and get money out of people, that I can delay no longer. In this paper I can do no more than give my conclusions:—
“R. C. Barrow writes, ‘Probably every religious error has a basis of truth.’ This is true in the case of Christian Science (so called). That basis is the mysterious power of the mind over mind, and the power of the mind over the body. The power is the same whether exerted by a Jesuit in performing a pretended miracle, by the mysterious doctor driving out disease without remedies, or the Christian Scientist healing by ‘the power of God.’ That there is a power in mental treatment to reach some diseases in some people in a way that seems almost miraculous, I know by both experiment and observation. This power is good just as any other power is good—in the hands of good people, and used in the right direction, it is good. In the hands of the bad (where it seems to be mostly), it is a very bad thing.”
“This power of the human mind is being used by the Christian Scientists (falsely so called) to build up a system of falsehood that will wreck many a home and many a soul.”
“The ‘healers’ deceive, making their patients and the world believe they are praying, when they are giving a mental treatment; and that the healing is in answer to prayer, when perhaps the healer never prays at all.”
“The teachers are robbers, as it appears to me, charging generally $100 per head for giving the information that could profitably be imparted in a few lessons at $1 per head, and that they know will never be worth a cent to the majority of their pupils. The healers deceive to get practice. To get a patient they will tell him it makes no difference whether he believes or not. When they fail in his case, they tell him it is because of his lack of faith, or because of its lack in his family.”
“The tendency is to infidelity. Good people, who are told the healing is by the direct power of God, seeing the wicked getting well and themselves finding no relief, are driven into infidelity, despair, or insanity. If they knew the difficulty was, they had more brains than the healer, they might feel better about it.”
“Much of the teaching is contrary to the Bible. For instance, the Scientists teach that the soul cannot sin, and therefore no evil can come to you, while the Bible teaches, ‘the soul that sinneth, it shall die.’ Some of the teaching is true and perfectly beautiful, but the tendency of the singular blending of truth and falsehood is to fanaticism or skepticism. Many good people may be and doubtless are found in the ranks of the Christian Scientists, and they should be treated with kindness; and the assaults of those evidently ignorant of these matters can result in no good.”
“I trust I have said enough to enable any one to know what I think of the good and evil there is in Christian Science. Not every one will be wise enough to cull out the good and reject the evil.”